Davao City Refuses to Enforce Health Ordinances

A recent diarrhea outbreak occurred in Davao killing six people and causing others to be hospitalized. The outbreak was traced to mishandling of food. 

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1180656

The culprit of the diarrhea outbreak in Toril district here was due to food contamination, the City Health Office (CHO) said Friday.

“I announce that the diarrhea outbreak was due to a foodborne microorganism, with Vibrio cholera as the pathogen of concern. The most likely vehicle of transmission is contaminated food,” CHO acting chief Dr. Ashley Lopez said.

At least six infected persons died from the virus outbreak in Toril that began on July 15.

Lopez said a male patient was the latest fatality of the outbreak who died on July 24.

Rectal swabs done on the affected cases showed that 60 percent turned out positive in the bacteriological culture testing, he added.

Based on the CHO investigation, he said diarrhea patient cases have gone down to 217 cases as others that were previously recorded were not related to the outbreak.

Of the figure, 163 or 75 percent of the admitted cases have recovered.

“There are now only 11 individuals remaining, or 5 percent of the total affected cases in the hospitals being treated. Twenty-six cases were treated in the outpatient department of hospitals, while 11 other cases are still for verification,” he said.

Of all those infected, 41 percent had episodes of eating and drinking at food stalls in Rasay Street in Toril, while 21 percent of the cases ate and drank at the district’s public market.

The remaining 38 percent are from multiple sources but are statistically insignificant to be considered as exposure for cases.

“Based on investigations, food may have been contaminated during preparation and handling by infected handlers. It was also found that proper storage, delayed serving, and unsanitary environment may have contributed to the food contamination because of exposure to elements,” Lopez said.

Meanwhile, Toril Police Station Police chief Maj. Carol Jabagat said the city will not file any charges against the street vendors.  

However, a policy will be released that will serve as the guidelines for the food establishments, she said.

Six people are dead and hundreds of others have been incapacitated due to the mishandling of food and the PNP says the city will not filing charges against any of the vendors. However, Mayor Duterte is singing a different tune.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1180629

Mayor Sebastian “Baste” Duterte vowed to hold accountable the culprits behind the diarrhea outbreak in Toril District here that killed six people, saying the city may pursue charges.

“People have lost their lives just because of mishandling of food. I hope that you have put yourselves in the situation of the victims,” Duterte told reporters Thursday.

However, the mayor said he was disappointed by reports that families of the victims are not keen on pressing charges against the culprits.

“I told them if they decide to press charges, I will accompany them. However, the family said they would rather not,” he said.

“That is what I want,” he added when asked whether the city government will file charges instead.

Following the outbreak, Duterte said the local government will enforce additional policies for street food vendors before they are allowed to operate.

“I have already tasked the barangays and CHO to coordinate. Having a health card is only one of the requirements, there will be more. We cannot allow this to happen again. It is unacceptable,” he said.

Based on investigations, food may have been contaminated during preparation and handling.

It was also found that proper storage, delayed serving, and an unsanitary environment may have contributed to the food contamination because of exposure to elements.

By all means the city should charge these vendors for violating existing health ordinances. That Duterte asked the victims if they wanted to press charges is beside the point. It does not matter what the victims want. These vendors did not follow existing ordinances and six people are dead as a result. Did the Mayor ask the deceased victims if they wanted to press charges? What good is having laws if the city will not punish those who violate them? Once again this situation shows how ultimately the Philippines is a lawless nation.