Monday, June 10, 2024

A Tale of Two Murder Cases

The Philippine justice system is quite broken and there is no better way to demonstrate that fact than by comparing cases involving the same crime. The following two cases involve murder. It's the details that differ.

This first case is rather open and shut as it involves a witness, a ballistic examination, and a paraffin test. Presumption of innocence notwithstanding this man is guilty. 

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1947975/makati-prosecutors-office-finds-basis-to-sue-road-rage-suspect-for-murder

The Makati City Prosecutor’s Office found probable cause to file a murder case against the suspect in a road rage that occurred along the southbound lane of the Edsa Ayala tunnel in Makati City.

The incident resulted in the death of a stay-in driver.

Citing a resolution released by the prosecutor’s office on Monday, PNP spokesperson Col. Jean Fajardo said suspect Gerard Raymond Yu is facing complaints of murder and carrying of firearms without permits.

“The Office of the City Prosecutor of Makati has issued a resolution finding probable cause to charge our arrested suspect Yu with murder charges for violation of Article 248 of the Revised Penal Code and violation of Section 31 of Republic Act 10591,” Fajardo said, speaking in a mix of English and Filipino, in a press briefing on Tuesday.

The PNP official said the paraffin test results on Yu and the ballistic examination of his firearms were among the bases the prosecutor cited.

Last May 29. Interior Secretary Benjamin Abalos Jr. revealed that Yu tested positive for gunpowder from the confiscated weapons, which also matched the recovered fired cartridge at the scene.

“In the body of the resolution, the prosecutor says that he [Yu] chased [the victim] and made sure that he positioned himself on the right side of the Innova so that the victim would not notice him,” Fajardo said.

“The case was elevated, and the prosecutor agreed to the murder case we filed yesterday. The city prosecutor also filed information for murder before the Regional Trial Court of Makati,” she added.

And rightly the Makati prosecutor's office says they will be filing charges. There is no waiting for the victims family to file a case. There is no nonsense. There is the City legal office taking charge and filing a case.

Compare that to the following case. A 20 year old 11th grader (that is a whole different story!) was gunned down in his house in front of his parents. It was a case of revenge over a charge of rape. No matter the victim appears innocent. The fact is the cops and the parents seem to know who the perpetrator is. 

https://mb.com.ph/2024/6/6/police-brutal-slay-of-grade-11-student-triggered-by-alleged-rape-incident

Police said that the brutal killing of a Grade 11 student in Barangay Granada here was triggered by rumors linking him to an alleged rape incident.

Police Capt. Portia Nillosan, head of Police Station 5, said that 20-year-old Nicus Balagosa was allegedly shot by the father of the alleged rape victim in front of his parents in their house on Sunday, June 2.

Balagosa was mistakenly tagged as one of those who allegedly raped the 16-year-old daughter of one of the gunmen, according to Nillosan. 

Nillosan said the alleged rape incident happened a few days ago, when the teenage girl and Balagosa attended a friend’s birth anniversary party with their two other friends aged 17 and 19.

However, it was reported late to the police, she added.

After learning the incident involving his daughter, Nillosan said the girl’s father confronted Balagosa’s two friends who denied any involvement in the incident.

However, Nillosan said that the girl’s father may have heard rumors linking Balagosa to the incident that triggered him to act violently.

Nillosan said that based on medical examination, the girl was positively sexually molested. But she noted that based on their investigation, Balagosa had left the party before the alleged rape happened.  

She said they are probing Balagosa’s two friends in relation to the alleged rape incident.

Nillosan said they already have four persons of interest in the shooting incident and they have also identified the girl’s father as one of the two gunmen. However, she refused to name him to protect the identity of the alleged rape victim.

She said they were not able to clearly see the license plates of the get-away vehicle through a closed-circuit television (CCTV) camera, making it difficult for them to identify the car owner.

She said they are awaiting Balagosa’s family to file murder charges against the perpetrators who are still at large.

Wow. There are suspicions about who pulled the trigger but nothing definite at this point and the PNP is waiting for the FAMILY TO FILE CHARGES????  Are they supposed to conduct an investigation and figure out who killed their son? OF course not. That is the job of the PNP. And they should be the ones who file the case and forward it to the City Prosecutor's Office. 

Now, let's look at a third case. DILG Secretary Abalos has warned barangays that all online sexual child abuse cases must be prosecuted. There is no room for settlement. 

https://mb.com.ph/2024/6/5/abalos-warns-barangays-no-settlement-of-online-child-sexual-abuse-cases

Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) Secretary Benjamin “Benhur’’ Abalos Jr. warned barangay officials on Wednesday, June 5, that there should absolutely no settlement of Anti-Online Sexual Abuse or exploitation of Children (OSAEC) cases at their level.

In a press briefing, Abalos urged the public to report online child sexual abuse and exploitation cases to proper law enforcement authorities as he vowed that those involved would be prosecuted.

He reiterated that local officials could be held liable if proven that they are instrumental in the “settlement’’ of these cases.

To all those watching now, these are children, victims, this is a crime. You cannot say that this is only a camera that is only focused on them like that. Because there is this mindset. Some will say that is only a camera, no, even if it is only a camera, even if it is anything, this is a crime against children,’’ Abalos emphasized.

In the same briefing, National Coordination Council (NCC) against OSAEC Executive Director Margarita Magsaysay stressed that the barangay should endorse these cases to proper law enforcement authorities since settlement of this nature is out of the question.

She cited that the preference to settle these cases at the barangay level has probably something to do with maintaining family harmony, which should not be done since justice is not served to the child/victim with the perpetrators having the luxury of victimizing other children again.

Look at the reasoning here. There is to be no settlement because online child sexual abuse is a crime. No kidding!  But so is murder. So is homicide as a result of reckless driving. So is theft. So are so many other crimes yet the so-called justice system lets these crimes slip through the cracks because either the victims and the perpetrators settle or the victims refuse to prosecute. 

But it should NEVER be the job of the victim to prosecute. This is why so many criminals get away. Prosecution should be up to the City Prosecutor. And that is why the Philippine justice system remains broken. 

Friday, June 7, 2024

Retards in the Government 368

It's your weekly compendium of foolishness and corruption in the Philippine government.

 


https://cebudailynews.inquirer.net/576208/umapad-councilor-faces-charges-for-unpaid-salaries

Some employees of Barangay Umapad in Mandaue City, who have yet to receive their salaries for the last five months, filed a complaint before the Office of the Ombudsman Visayas on Thursday afternoon, May 30.

The complainants, Gemma Mata Ortega, Girlie Reyes Gabisan, Lea Gabisan Jimenez, Lima Sotchesa Orogan, and Erwina Batulan Caño, filed cases against Barangay Councilor Libertine Lumapas for alleged violations of Republic Act 3019, citing grave abuse of authority and oppression.

At least 80 employees of Barangay Umapad have yet to receive their salaries for the last five months, or since January this year. These employees include barangay tanods, clean and green personnel, lupon members, drivers, and others.

Umapad Barangay Captain Reb Cortes said the payroll for these salaries could not be processed because it has yet to be signed by Lumapas, who chairs the Committee on Appropriations.

Cortes explained that the barangay is currently operating under a reenacted budget from 2023 after the proposed budget for 2024 was not approved by the opposition-dominated barangay council. He added that according to his inquiry with Atty. Giovanni Tianero, the city’s budget officer, the honoraria can indeed be disbursed by the barangay under a reenacted budget. The Department of Interior and Local Government (DILG) also gave the same opinion.

Barangay Councilor Lumapas has yet to respond to CDN Digital’s messages and calls for her reaction to the cases filed against her. However, in a previous message sent to CDN Digital, she stated that she did not sign the payroll because of alleged irregularities in the barangay’s payroll.

Lumapas asserted that her actions as Chairman of the Committee on Appropriations are in accordance with the law.

Cortes believes that the ‘irregularities’ Lumapas refers to are the documents she demanded, such as the Daily Time Record, Oath of Office, and Concurrence of Appointment by the majority of the Sangguniang Barangay.

Cortes noted that most of the workers are job order employees and not elected officials, thus they do not require an Oath of Office. Furthermore, he believes that Concurrence of Appointment is only necessary for the Barangay Treasurer and Secretary.

Only two of the eight elected barangay councilors are allied with Cortes. He said that they have repeatedly asked Lumapas to sign the payroll, but she refuses.

Cortes also admitted that one of the unpaid workers is his ally who lost in the last Barangay Elections.

He claimed that the opposition councilors recommended 48 individuals for employment, but he only hired 20 because there are already existing workers employed.

With the cases filed at the Office of the Ombudsman by his employees, Cortes hopes for positive results and that the employees will receive their salaries soon.

Some employees of Barangay Umapad in Mandaue City, who have yet to receive their salaries for the last five months, filed a complaint before the Office of the Ombudsman Visayas on Thursday afternoon, May 30.

The Philippine Coast Guard (PCG) has filed criminal and administrative cases against one of its personnel allegedly involved in an extortion attempt on a job applicant.

The PCG said the cases were filed against Petty Officer Third Class (PO3) Ibrahim Banota who allegedly attempted to extort PHP150,000 from an applicant in exchange for guaranteed acceptance into the service.

“This occurred amid the ongoing PCG nationwide recruitment cycle for calendar year 2024,” it said in a statement Friday.

The extortion attempt was first reported on May 19.

Banota, who was part of the PCG Station Western Tawi-Tawi based in Zamboanga City, was arrested in an entrapment operation five days later.

He is facing estafa charges and an administrative case.

The PCG urged the public to report such illegal activities related to its recruitment. 

A member of the Philippine Coast Guard is facing charges for extortion. 

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1946668/hpg-nabs-tolentinos-2-mmda-escorts-for-using-sticker-with-pnp-insignia

The Highway Patrol Group (HPG) arrested two Metropolitan Manila Development Authority (MMDA) personnel in Parañaque City for “publicly and improperly using the insignia ‘POLICE’ and ‘Master Rider’s Badge’.”

Highway Patrol Group (HPG) Director Col. Neil Francia said the two escorts were assigned to the MMDA’s traffic aide unit and allowed to provide security to Senator Francis Tolentino.

The HPG official said the two MMDA staff were caught illegally using the insignia of the Philippine National Police and Master Rider’s Badge as printed on stickers attached to their motorcycles’ windscreen and saddle box.

Francia identified the two as Teofilo Labsan Padilla, 64, and Jonathan Alames Pacle, 42.

Based on the HPG’s report, the MMDA escorts were flagged down along J.W. Diokno Avenue corner Aseana Avenue on Wednesday, May 29, after operatives noticed they were using sirens, which violates Presidential Decree 96 and Joint Administrative Order (JAO) 2014-01 (motorcycle vehicle operating with unauthorized accessories, and devices such as blinkers and siren).

Operatives then asked the two MMDA personnel regarding police markings on their motorcycles, but Padilla and Pacle “refused to divulge any information.”

Francia said the arrested MMDA escorts are currently placed under the custody of the Regional Highway Patrol Unit- National Capital Region Investigation Branch for violating Article 177, Usurpation of Authority, and Article 179, illegal use of uniform or insignia of the Revised Penal Code.

He also said that Padilla and Pacle will be brought before the city prosecutor’s office for inquest proceedings while the motorcycles are temporarily impounded at the HPG field unit for further investigation and validation.

The Highway Patrol Group arrested two Metropolitan Manila Development Authority personnel in Parañaque City for “publicly and improperly using the insignia ‘POLICE’ and ‘Master Rider’s Badge’.”

A retired policeman wanted for allegedly raping his stepdaughter  was arrested in Barangay Cabug here on Friday, May 31.

Police Capt. Michael Tuburan, head of Police Station 9, said the 78-year-old suspect was served a warrant of arrest for 13 counts of rape and acts of lasciviousness.

Tuburan said the Counter Intelligence Division-Integrity Monitoring Enforcement Group (CID-IMEG) coordinated with them for the service of the arrest warrant.

He said the suspect, formerly a Senior Police Officer 3 (SPO3) assigned in Pangasinan, retired from the service in 2002.

The warrant with no bail recommended was issued by Regional Trial Court (RTC) Branch 68 in Lingayen, Pangasinan on July 19, 2006.

Tuburan said they are waiting for authorities who will transport the suspect to Pangasinan.

A retired cop has been arrested for raping his stepdaughter. 

https://mb.com.ph/2024/6/1/jealous-cop-slays-colleague-in-bacolod

A jealous policeman allegedly gunned down his colleague in Barangay Tangub, Bacolod City on Friday, May 31.

The victim was identified as Police Staff Sgt. Jotham Arrem Tuto, 31, of Sagay City, Negros Occidental, assigned to the Mobile Patrol Unit (MPU) of the Bacolod City Police Office (BCPO).

The suspect identified as Police Patrolman Alvin Rios allegedly shot the victim using his service firearm when he saw him and his former live-in partner inside the bedroom of their house.

Police Major Eugene Tolentino, head of Police Station 8, said the victim tried to pacify the suspect, but the suspect still shot him. The victim was rushed to a hospital where he was declared dead.

Recovered from the crime scene were a .9mm caliber pistol, two fired cartridges, and four magazines with live ammunition.

The 26-year-old suspect from Antique, and his former live-in partner has a six-month-old son, according to the police.

The suspect, who was assigned to the 1st Mobile Force Company of Iloilo Provincial Police Office (IPPO), is now under police custody. 

Tolentino said they are preparing murder charges against the suspect.

A cop has been arrested for shooting a fellow cop. 

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1947593/bulacan-city-cops-sacked-over-escape-of-8-pdls

Two police officers were relieved from their posts following the escape of eight detainees from the San Jose del Monte (SJDM) Police Station jail on Sunday.

The lead investigator of the case told INQUIRER.net on Monday that the two policemen are now under the custody of the San Jose del Monte City Police.

(The two were relieved and are now under administrative holding or restrictive custody while the investigation is ongoing. Their ranks are senior master sergeant and master sergeant.)

Earlier, Pating reported that eight persons deprived of liberty or PDLs, broke out of the facility on Sunday around 3 a.m.

He said that based on their initial investigation, the eight inmates escaped the SJDM jail through a window of a restroom by cutting its grills using a saw.

Pating also said four fugitives have since been recaptured as they visited their relatives or acquaintances in various San Jose del Monte City areas.

He said a pursuit operation was launched to rearrest the other four escapees.

Two cops have been relieved of duty and are now under custody over the escape of 8 prisoners. 

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1226093

The Office of the Ombudsman has ordered the suspension of Bamban, Tarlac Mayor Alice Guo and two others for up to six months in connection with the graft charges filed by the Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG).

The DILG alleged that Guo allowed illegal Philippine Offshore Gaming Operators (POGOS) to operate in the municipality.

In an order dated May 31, the Ombudsman said it finds sufficient grounds to suspend Guo, Edwin Ocampo, and Adenn Sigua “considering that there is strong evidence showing their guilt" on the charges of grave misconduct, conduct prejudicial to the best interest of the service, and gross neglect of duty.

Ocampo is with the Municipal Business Permits and Licensing Office while Sigua is a municipal legal officer.

The suspension was issued as “their continued stay in office may prejudice the investigation of the case filed against them,” the Ombudsman stated.

"They are preventively suspended, without pay, during the period of investigation until its termination, but not to exceed six months," the order read.

"The order is immediately executory. Notwithstanding any motion, appeal, or petition that may be filed by respondents seeking relief from this Order, unless otherwise ordered by this Office or by any court of competent jurisdiction, the implementation of this Order shall not be interrupted within the period of prescribed."

In its complaint, the DILG questioned Guo's divestment of shares in Baufo due to the disproportionate consideration compared to her investment.

Despite the raid on Zun Yuan and its predecessor Hong Sheng Gaming Technology Inc., the DILG alleges that Guo retained financial interest in Baufo Land Development Inc., which was raided by the Presidential Anti-Organized Crime Commission for alleged human trafficking and serious illegal detention in March.

The DILG also accused Ocampo of processing permits for Zun Yuan despite incomplete documents.

Further, the DILG said Sigua failed to investigate the negligence of Sangguniang Bayan (local council) members and the Business Permit and Licensing Office.

Mayor Alice Guo  has been suspended for six months pending an investigation into graft charges field by the DILG.

https://www.philstar.com/nation/2024/06/04/2360146/4-more-cops-civilian-charged-over-theft-ex-profs-house

Four more police officers and a civilian have been charged in connection with a robbery incident that occurred at the house of a retired professor in Imus, Cavite last year.

The five brought to 12 the total number of respondents in the case that stemmed from a supposed anti-drug operation, according to the National Police Commission (Napolcom).

Lawyer Owen de Luna, chief of the Napolcom-Calabarzon (Cavite, Laguna, Batangas, Rizal and Quezon), yesterday said that complainant Rebecca Caoile and the Napolcom filed additional criminal charges such as unlawful arrest, violation of domicile and planting of evidence against the respondents.

“The charges were filed before the Department of Justice (DOJ) on May 7,” De Luna told The STAR over the phone.

He said for the administrative aspect of the case, four officers filed appeals before the regional internal affairs service, while seven were dismissed from the service.

The DOJ ordered the policemen to appear before the preliminary investigation that would be conducted by Assistant State Prosecutor Mary Grace Pulido-Sadian on June 7.

Records showed that in August 2023, the accused officers barged into the house of Caoile in Barangay Alapan and arrested her and another person on alleged drug charges.

A viral footage of a closed-circuit television camera installed in the area showed the officers taking out items, including brand new motorcycle parts, from Caoile’s house.

Four more police officers and a civilian have been charged in connection with a robbery incident that occurred at the house of a retired professor in Imus, Cavite last year.

https://mb.com.ph/2024/6/4/50-cops-in-bamban-tarlac-relieved-to-undergo-retraining

At least 50 policemen assigned in Bamban, Tarlac were sacked from their posts, a move that is believed to be connected to the filing of charges and eventually the suspension of Mayor Alice Guo over allegations of link to the Philippine Offshore Gaming Operator (POGO) in the area. 

Interior and Local Government Secretary Benjamin “Benhur’ Abalos, Jr. confirmed the relief of the 50 policemen assigned to the Bamban Municipal Police Station.

Police Brig. Gen. Jose Hidalgo, Jr., director of the Police Regional Office (PRO3) presided over the turnover ceremony of the relieved cops and their replacements from the police mobile forces units in nearby areas on Monday morning.

According to Hidalgo, all the relieved policemen will undergo values formation seminars which is part of the internal cleansing program of the Philippine National Police.

50 cops have been relieved over links to POGOs.

Four police officers were arrested and charged for the alleged kidnapping of a Malaysian and three Chinese on June 2, according to Interior Secretary Benjamin Abalos Jr.

Abalos on Wednesday said that Senior Master Sergeant Angelito David, Master Sergeant Ralph Tumangil, Staff Sergeant Ricky Tabora and Major Carlo Villanueva were charged with kidnapping for ransom, robbery and carnapping.

Ten other civilians also reportedly involved with the kidnapping remain at large, the Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) reported.

Of the four victims, Abalos said that only two Chinese, identified as Meng Zhao, 29, and Yang Zhuan Zhuan, 30, were kidnapped early Sunday morning, while the two other foreigners, Shi Yi Xuan, 32, and a 25-year-old Malaysian, Tang Heng Fei, escaped.

(It happened early on June 2 at around 12:20 in the morning. Four foreigners were in a Lexus car, which was flagged down by PNP motorcycle cops on Taft Avenue in Pasay.)

(A white van was following these policemen on motorcycles.)

Citing a police report, the DILG official said the two who escaped reported the incident to barangay officials nearby.

To save their friends, Zhi and Tang paid a ransom worth P2.5 million, resulting in Meng and Yang’s release around 6 a.m. on June 3.

Upon receiving the information, National Capital Region Police Office chief Brig. Gen. Melencio Nartatez launched a search operation that led to the apprehension of the four suspects.

The Southern Police District and Anti-Kidnapping Group operatives took part in the arrest.

Four cops have been arrested for kidnapping. 

Three police officers were arrested on June 2 for kidnapping two Chinese in Pasay and holding them for ransom.

A barangay tanod was allegedly gunned down by a retired police major  over irrigation water in Purok 4, Barangay Nabbuan, this city, on Monday evening, June 3.

Police Lt. Col. Saturnino Soriano, Santiago City Police Station spokesperson, identified the victim as Sonny Julian, a resident of Purok 7, Nabbuan, Santiago City.

Soriano said the victim and two companions were onboard in a tricycle when the suspect appeared and shot him with a caliber. 38 revolver.

Julian died on the spot from multiple bullet wounds.

One of the victim’s companions was wounded. The other was unscathed.

The suspect fled after the incident.

Soriano said that the shooting was related to a dispute over irrigation water for a rice field.

He said that police are pursuing the suspect.

A retired cop has gunned down a barangay tanod.

https://www.philstar.com/nation/2024/06/05/2360409/volunteer-firefighter-held-rape

A volunteer firefighter was arrested for rape in Port Area, Manila on Monday afternoon.

Police officers served an arrest warrant on Angelo Tapaya, 21, who resides in Baseco Compound.

Manila Regional Trial Court Branch 29 Judge Delight Aissa Salvador issued the warrant on May 29.

A volunteer firefighter has been arrested for rape.

https://mb.com.ph/2024/6/6/ombudsman-suspends-2-negros-occidental-officials-for-conflict-of-interest

The Office of the Ombudsman has suspended two Negros Occidental provincial government officials for six months without pay due to conflict of interest when they engaged in private law practice in 2020.

The Ombudsman found lawyers Rayfrando Diaz II and Chery Sheil Valenzuela guilty of violating Section 7(b)(2) of Republic Act (RA) 6713 or the Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees.

The complaint was filed by former Attorney IV Roxenne Sumanting of the Provincial Legal Office (PLO) on June 20, 2022. 

It stemmed from the alleged failure of the respondents to provide legal assistance or representation to the municipality of Binalbagan relative to an expropriation case that the town filed with the Regional Trial Court (RTC) in Himamaylan City and conflict of interest on the part of Diaz and Valenzuela who appeared as counsels for JLL Agriculture and Development, one of the defendants in the case during their incumbencies as provincial administrator and executive assistant II, respectively.

The Ombudsman, in a 20-page decision, stated that both admitted engaging in the private practice of their profession when they represented JLL, claiming that they were granted authority by Gov. Eugenio Jose Lacson.

“But appearing as counsel for JLL undeniably came in conflict with Diaz and Valenzuela’s obligations as officials of the provincial government of Negros Occidental,” according to the Ombudsman.

“Even if the trial court did not officially consider Valenzuela’s appearance during the pre-trial conference on January 27, 2020, the fact remains that she was still then counsel of JLL during the incumbency of her employment with the government which is prohibited,” it also said.

“Thus, substantial evidence exists that Diaz and Valenzuela committed violation of Section 7(b)(2) of RA 6713,” the Ombudsman said.

Section 7(b)(2), which refers to prohibited acts and transactions, states that public officials and employees during their incumbency “shall not engage in the private practice of their profession unless authorized by the Constitution or law, provided that such practice will not conflict or tend to conflict with their official functions.”

The decision dated November 10, 2023 was penned by graft investigation and prosecution officer III Leilani Tagulao-Marquez and approved by Ombudsman Samuel Martires on April 1, 2024. 

The Office of the Ombudsman has suspended two Negros Occidental provincial government officials for six months without pay due to conflict of interest when they engaged in private law practice in 2020.

Thursday, June 6, 2024

Coronavirus Lockdown: Don't Call it FliRT, Yearly COVID Vaccinations, and More!

More news about how the COVID-19 pandemic in the Philippines is being handled by the public and the government. 

After claiming there are no more funds to procure new vaccines the DOH now says there is enough money to handle new COVID variants including purchasing vaccines

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1225832

The Department of Health (DOH) on Wednesday assured lawmakers that there are ample funds to prepare for the emerging Covid-19 variants, including the procurement of updated vaccine doses to protect vulnerable Filipinos.

DOH Undersecretary Achilles Gerard Bravo made the assurance during the oversight hearing of the House Committee on Appropriations after Marikina City 2nd District Rep. Stella Quimbo expressed shock over a newspaper headline suggesting a lack of preparation to protect Filipinos from the new “FLIRT” variants driving a wave of infections worldwide.

During the hearing, Quimbo noted the DOH's significant yet underutilized funds after a presentation of the agency’s budget utilization report.

She said various funding sources, such as the quick response fund and the communicable disease program, remain largely untapped.

Bravo confirmed the availability of funds, and assured the committee of the DOH’s readiness to adjust its budget.

“Madam chair, you are correct. So, what we will do is that we have so many funds at the DOH, even from the CONAP (Continuing Appropriations) in 2023 and the current. If there’s a need to provide something for the emerging Covid variant, we can always make some modifications within our budget,” he said.

“What we are doing right now is we are collating all the resources of DOH how much are savings and CONAP of other programs, and then we will decide what will be prioritized because the slow-moving appropriations, we are going to modify them and transfer them to fast-moving appropriations.”

House Deputy Majority Leader and Iloilo 1st District Rep. Janette Garin urged preparedness for the emerging “FLIRT” variant.

She highlighted the challenges of implementing border control and emphasized the importance of vaccination and access to pneumonia and flu vaccines.

“Bottomline is, preparation should go back to either vaccination if an updated version is available, but more importantly is pneumonia, flu vaccines and the medicines for whoever will need it,” Garin said.

The former Health Secretary also called for the DOH to ensure free hospitalization and medication for health care workers and immunocompromised individuals.

In response, Bravo assured that the department is utilizing its savings to meet these needs.

Even though the DOH previously admitted there are no funds to procure new vaccines they will find the money if it is needed by shifting around their current funds.

The DOH also says there is no need for restrictions to combat the new variants. 

https://mb.com.ph/2024/5/29/2020-all-over-again-doh-says-there-s-no-need-for-restrictions-vs-f-li-rt-variants

The Department of Health (DOH) said on Wednesday, May 29, that the Philippines won't have to undergo past pandemic restrictions as it intends to take full control regarding the possible effects of the emerging new variants of Covid-19, dubbed “FLiRT”.

DOH spokesperson Assistant Secretary Albert Domingo gave this assurance to members of the House of Representatives during an oversight meeting by the Committee on Appropriations with the agency.

It was ACT Teachers Party-list Rep. France Castro who sought this response from the DOH in the wake of possibly another period of health restrictions in the country.

(So that our people will be in the know, and we will neither be complacent, nor resort to threatening our countrymen. So how ready are we for the reported FLiRT Covid?)

(So is the DOH making sure that we will not experience the 2020, 2021, 2022 level of Covid?)

Domingo quickly said that the agency was indeed making sure that the country was prepared against the emerging Covid variants.

Of course that is what was said at the beginning of 2020 and we all know what happened. 

The new variants are being dubbed FLiRT which is "is based on the technical names for the variants' spike protein mutations or the specific amino acid changes." But the DOH says they should not be referred to by that name. 

https://mb.com.ph/2024/5/30/don-t-call-it-f-li-rt-baka-hindi-seryosohin-doh-spox-tells-solons

The Department of Health (DOH) is intent on calling the newest Covid-19 variants by the names of KP.2 and KP.3 instead of the more commonly known term “FLiRT” variants, in a bid to make the public take them more seriously.

DOH Spokesperson Assistant Secretary Albert Domingo gave this message during an oversight meeting held by the House Committee on Appropriations with the agency on  Wednesday, May 29.

(KP.2 and KP.3 variants, that's what we call FLiRT because people may not take us seriously because they think of flirting when we say FLiRT.)

“Kaya KP.2, KP.3 ang ginagamit namin (That’s why we are using KP.2, KP.3.),” he added.

On May 3, the World Health Organization (WHO) said it is closely monitoring four circulating variants, namely JN.1.7, JN.1.18, KP.2, and KP.3.

These variants appear to have descended from the JN.1 variant—a Covid-19 strain that emerged in late 2023 and caused an uptick in cases worldwide.

In a recent statement, the DOH said the unusual moniker of “FLiRT” was coined by researchers to describe the amino acid changes in the Covid-19 virus’ spike protein, specifically from phenylalanine (F) to leucine (L), and from arginine (R) to threonine (T).

The department said it avoids using “FLiRT” to refer to the new variants because it might result in a “miscommunication of health risk” due to its “informal and casual” nature.

Is anyone taking these new variants seriously anyway?

One health expert is pushing for annual COVID vaccinations. 

https://mb.com.ph/2024/5/30/expert-pushes-for-yearly-covid-vaccinations

Former Philippine College of Physicians president Dr. Maricar Limpin on Thursday, May 30 said the medical community is advocating for annual vaccinations against Covid-19.  

In an ANC interview, Limpin emphasized that the medical community expects a flu-like vaccination for Covid-19 that would need to be administered annually.

"For now, what we expect is something like the flu that occurs every year, we need to have a flu vaccine," Limpin said in a mix of English and Filipino.

She explained that similar to the flu, which tends to mutate, the vaccine available around this time in 2024 will be tailored to the strain that was prevalent last year.

"So, just like this, we are currently facing the FliRT variant that was observed in the last part of 2023. Therefore, a vaccine can be developed, which will actually be used this year," Limpin said.

"We're hoping all of us in the medical community, especially our pediatric doctors and primary care practitioners, want vaccines that can protect the people. Especially the elderly, those with comorbidities, or those who are immunocompromised," she added.

Meanwhile, the expert said that based on the studies, "we can still get protection from the vaccine that was made last year (2023)."

Isn't this more proof that COVID vaccines do not work and COVID is merely the flu?

Angeles City has reverted back to masking up inside government offices. 

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1946976/angeles-city-reverts-to-no-face-mask-no-entry-rule-in-govt-offices-due-to-covid-19-threat

The mayor in this city has ordered the strict wearing of face masks in the city hall and all local government buildings and offices as a measure against the possible spread of COVID-19.

In a memorandum on Wednesday, May 29, Mayor Carmelo Lazatin Jr. said this was in line with the City Health Office’s recommendation after the Department of Health reported an increase in COVID-19 cases in the country and the World Health Organization’s update on three new variants of the coronavirus.

“The wearing of face masks shall be strictly enforced inside all city government offices, especially inside Angeles City Hall,” he said.

Lazatin also encouraged residents and transients in the city to always wear face masks in public places and on public transportation.

The mayor also advised the observance of the one-meter physical distancing and urged private establishments to place hand sanitizing stations and regularly disinfect their premises.

As if wearing a mask ever prevented a single COVID-19 infection.

The House is still investigating financial anomalies that occurred during the pandemic. It turns out that Duterte ordered the transfer of funds from the DOH to the PS-DBM and he did not inform the public. 

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1947691/duterte-ordered-transfer-of-p47-6-billion-covid-funds-to-ps-dbm-duque

It was then-President Rodrigo Duterte who ordered the transfer of P47.6 billion in COVID-19 funds from the Department of Health (DOH) to the Department of Budget and Management (PS-DBM) in 2020.

Former Health Secretary Francisco Duque III admitted this information during the hearing of the House of Representatives committee on appropriations Monday, upon the questioning of ACT Teachers party-list Rep. France Castro.

Based on a Commission on Audit (COA) report, the P47.6-billion COVID-19 fund includes PS-DBM contracts with Pharmally Pharmaceutical Corp., which was accused of selling overpriced medical supplies such as face masks, face shields, and other equipment used during the pandemic to the government.

Former Health Secretary Francisco Duque III said it was former President Rodrigo Duterte who directed the transfer of P47.6 billion under the Department of Health (DOH) to the Procurement Service of the Department of Budget and Management (PS-DBM) during the height of the pandemic.

“Another question, it was authorized by former President Duterte, right?” Castro asked Duque, referring to the transfer of the funds.

“Oho (Yes), in his public pronouncements, the transfer was done because of the public health emergency, which he declared sometime in March [2020],” Duque replied.

In an interview after the House panel’s hearing, Solicitor General Menardo Guevarra – who was Justice Secretary during Duterte’s administration and when the COVID-19 pandemic hit the country in 2020 –said he could not recall Duterte making a public pronouncement about transferring funds to PS-DBM.

Guevarra, however, noted that if the announcement had been made through the media, he may not have known.

“I don’t think it’s referring to a Cabinet meeting because I don’t remember any such Cabinet meeting where the President made that. I was Justice Secretary at the time and I was attending, of course, Cabinet meetings,” said Guevarra, who was present during the discussions of the House appropriations panel Monday.

“But, frankly, I do not recall any Cabinet meeting where a public statement like that was made by the President, unless he made it publicly before the media.  Not before the Cabinet. I’m not too sure though, but that’s my recollection,” he added.

The House committee on appropriations held the hearing as part of its oversight functions to check on the budget performances of the DOH and Philippine Health Insurance Corporation.

In August 2021, the COA found deficiencies in how the DOH managed its P67.32-billion fund to fight the COVID-19 pandemic, adding that it contributed to the challenges that the country faced during the health crisis.

Questions were eventually raised on how the DOH handed over to PS-DBM the responsibility of procuring protective equipment, when the latter’s mandate is to purchase common-use supplies like pens, paper, and other generic equipment.

PS-DBM was also quizzed at the Senate as to why it gave a contract to Pharmally, despite the company having a small paid-up capital of P625,000.

Now we know it was Duterte who handed over the responsibility to the PS-DBM to procure protective equipment which lead to the Pharmally scandal. 

Wednesday, June 5, 2024

Philippines to Send Mental Health Workers To Ukraine War

Ukraine President Volodymyr Zelenskyy was recently in the Philippines. During his visit he asked Marcos to send health workers to assist in the ongoing war with Russia. In particular he asked for mental health workers. President Marcos said he would do so. 

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1226069

Ukraine President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has appealed to President Ferdinand R. Marcos Jr. for humanitarian assistance, particularly in the mental health of Ukrainian soldiers amid the ongoing war with Russia.

In his meeting with Marcos at the Malacañan Palace on Monday morning, Zelenskyy said they need more mental health workers for their soldiers at the forefront of the crisis that their country has been facing for over two years now.

“Thanks, you mentioned about humanitarian possibilities especially for medicine and like I said to you, especially, psychological mental health and etc, – army. So, you understand how many people need their help when they come back, they can’t lose in the families,” Zelenskyy said, as quoted by a Presidential Communications Office (PCO) news release.

“It’s difficult for them – to study again,” he added.

For his part, Marcos told his Ukrainian counterpart that the Philippines could offer them help by sending Filipino mental health workers.

“That is something that I think we are able to offer,” President Marcos told Zelenskyy.

Marcos stressed that “the Philippines is quite well-known in healthcare in terms of providing assistance,” which is part of the country’s commitment to the United Nations for the peacekeeping process.

“I am happy to do all that we can to make sure that we can help especially the civilians and the innocents that are involved in the war. This is something that comes naturally to the Philippines so this will be something that we could pursue,” he added.

This rather a bizarre request from Zelenskyy who has gone hat in hand around the world seeking help to fight Russia. Why does he want Filipino mental health workers? Why did Marcos agree to send them when the DOH has admitted there is a lack of mental health workers in the Philippines which has created a crisis?

https://tribune.net.ph/2023/10/12/doh-admits-lack-of-mental-health-professionals

The Department of Health admitted on Thursday the lack of mental health professionals to address the looming mental health crisis in the country.

"Subjectively, I know there we do not have enough psychologists and psychiatrists," Health Secretary Ted Herbosa told reporters on the sidelines of the launching of the 2024-2028 Philippine Council for Mental Health Strategic Framework in Pasay City.

"So, we need more young people to be encouraged to go into psychological sciences," he said.

Herbosa issued the remarks when asked whether the country has enough human resources for mental health after the Philippine Mental Health Association, Inc. raised the alarm over the "rising epidemic of mental health crisis" in the country.

Citing data from the DOH, PMHA said at least 3.6 million Filipinos suffer from mental, neurological, and substance use disorders.

The PMHA said that access to mental health services in the country "remains limited and unequal due to stigma and scarce resources."

There is also less than one mental health worker for every 100,000 Filipinos, according to the group.

To address the problem, Herbosa proposed easing the requirements for psychologists and guidance counselors who want to work in government agencies.

"The government requires psychologists interested in working for them to have a master's degree, but their compensation is very low," he said.

Currently, he noted that psychologists in the government earn up to P27,000 per month under salary grade 11.

"That is wrong. So, I'm calling on CSC (Civil Service Commission) to change that," he said.

Not only is there a lack of mental health workers but DOH Secretary Herbosa has recommended lowering the requirements to become a psychologist. 

If Marcos had any sense he would have told Zelenskyy to buzz off but he did not. So, will mental health workers who cannot be spared be sent to Ukraine? Will unqualified wannabe mental health workers be shipped to console battle-scarred Ukrainian soldiers? Time will tell, of course. The whole thing is quite ridiculous.