Tuesday, March 2, 2021

Insurgency: Kidnap of Minors

A few weeks ago the PNP rescued several IP (indigenous person) minors who had allegedly been taken against their will and the will of their parents to a school where they were being indoctrinated by the NPA.  

https://cnnphilippines.com/regional/2021/2/16/lumad-cebu-rescue-pnp.html

Police have arrested seven people in an operation in a top Cebu school on Monday, where they said 19 Lumad children from Davao del Norte were rescued from alleged kidnapping by a militant group.

According to authorities, parents claimed their children were taken by members of the Salugpungan Ta' Tanu Igkanogon without their consent and were told they would be brought to Davao City for their schooling. They were instead found to have been staying at a retreat house of the University of San Carlos-Talamban Campus in Cebu since 2018, police said.

In 2019, 55 schools operated and owned by the Salugpungan Ta' Tanu Igkanogon Community Learning Centers in the Davao region were shut down by the Department of Education for allegedly teaching "left-leaning ideologies." Salugpungan claimed its schools were established to give indigenous groups in remote areas access to education. 

The police were accompanied by personnel from the Cebu City Social Welfare Development Office, the Women and Children Protection Center Visayas Field Unit, and the Children Protection Desk of the Cebu City Police Office.

"According to their parents, their children were taken by the members of Salugpungan Ta' Tanu Igkanogon without their knowledge and consent," Police Regional Office-7 Director PBGen. Ronnie Montejo said in a press conference at Camp Sergio Osmena Monday afternoon.

For nearly three years these children were separated from their parents and allegedly taught leftist ideologies. PNP Chief Sinas claimed some of these children were undergoing warfare training. The DSWS, who interviewed them, said that is false.

https://www.philstar.com/nation/2021/02/16/2078166/rescued-lumad-children-said-they-were-taught-reading-and-writing-not-warfare-training-cebu-dsws

The Department of Social Welfare Services belied the national police's claims that the 19 children "rescued" from a Lumad bakwit school in Cebu were being indoctrinated as communist rebels, saying none of the children mentioned "child warrior training" in their exit interviews with social workers. 

They were, the children themselves said, being taught reading and writing in a small nipa hut at the retreat house of the University of San Carlos-Talamban campus. 

This comes after no less than Police Gen. Debold Sinas, the chief of the Philippine National Police, claimed in a statement Monday that "some of the children told [Women and Children Protection Desk] investigators that they underwent some form of warfare training while in the custody of their handlers."

"We won't comment on that. The children never said that to us. Nothing about training to be child warriors," Annie Suico, a social welfare officer with the Cebu City DSWS who was present when the operation was conducted, said in mixed Filipino and English in a phone interview with Philstar.com

"We interviewed all of the children. They said nothing about being indoctrinated. Sulat at basa lang ang tinuturo ng mga guardian nila (All their guardians taught them were reading and writing)." 

On the contrary, she said, the children were assessed to be in good condition by the time they were supposedly rescued before their interviews. 

She was, however, careful to point out that these were only "initial interviews" where social workers "gathered limited data using our basic intake sheet." 

Now it's the PNP's word versus the DSWS' word. But the DSWS admits that they only gathered limited data while doing a basic intake. I won't try to determine who is right. Oddly enough 4 of the parents of these minors were later kidnapped by the NPA.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1131681

Four parents belonging to the Ata Manobo tribe are being held by suspected communist rebels, Philippine National Police (PNP) Chief, Gen. Debold Sinas, said.

The parents were among the eight Ata Manobo parents who were supposed to meet up with the police in Sitio Kamingawan, Talaingod, Davao del Norte on Monday for their trip to Cebu City, Sinas said in a news release issued late Tuesday.

However, only two parents showed up, he said, citing reports from Police Regional Office 11 (Davao region).

Sinas said they later learned that four parents were taken on Sunday by suspected organizers of communist front groups who introduced themselves as police officers.

“Obviously, these four parents were lured into believing they would be meeting with their children in Cebu when they were taken by persons who disguised themselves as police officers. I can only surmise that this is part of desperate moves by the communist front organizations to get away from the criminal liability of serious illegal detention and child exploitation,” Sinas said.

Whatever the case with these minors is the fact is the NPA does employ child warriors.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1132014

A ranking military official dismissed claims made by the Communist Party of the Philippines-New People's Army (CPP-NPA) that it is not involved in the kidnapping of minors or children.

"Marco Valbuena, Chief Information Officer of the CPP, denies NPA kidnapping of children exists. Wow! Where is this denial coming from? From Utrecht, Netherlands? Let's refresh Valbuena of just a few of these kidnappings of minors by the NPAs," said Lt. Gen. Antonio Parlade, Jr., Southern Luzon Command (SolCom) chief, in a statement sent to the Philippine News Agency Thursday.

In debunking Valbuena's denial, he cited the case of Mary Jane Ganay alias "Elsie", who surrendered to the government with the help of the clergy in Oriental Mindoro in December 2020.

He added that in Elsie’s testimony, she claimed that she was only invited to attend the wedding of NPA member Daisylyn Castillo alias "Tikya" and Marjun Malucon, alias "Warren" in Sitio Mantay, Barangay Monteclaro, San Jose, Occidental Mindoro, not knowing that she will be held against her will.

"After the said wedding, she was never allowed to return (home) and she was only 16 years old during that time. She underwent courses and trained with NPAs, got pregnant, raped, until her surrender in 2020," said Parlade, who is also a spokesperson of the National Task Force to End Local Communist Armed Conflict.

He also mentioned the cases involving Layag Sanyuan alias "Layka", Helen Villanueva alias "Jenny", Maylin Ligduman alias "Joan" who are all minors who surrendered with four others after their leader Lorelyn Saligumba alias "Farah", reportedly a member of the Morong 38, was killed in an encounter in Baco, Oriental Mindoro in June 2020.

"They were asked to fetch water, bring backpacks of NPAs to the mountains, and were never allowed to return to their homes.

These minors, aged 15-17 became communists, married fellow NPA members to protect themselves from being raped, until they had a chance to escape and surrender to the government’s pastor friends. 

“Alias 'Joan' was forced to marry NPA (member) Nilo Ligduman alias 'Roel', also a minor. Alias 'Jenny', on the other hand, was forced to marry Renante Villanueva alias 'Rens/Joe'," he added.

"I can go on Valbuena, but the CHR and DSWD can also provide you a more complete list of NPA child warriors who were forced to have sex with NPAs while they were minors. And that will fall either as qualified or statutory rape, Mr. Valbuena. That's a double major offense, and no amount of denying will exonerate your terrorist colleagues,"  he added.

No matter how you slice it this is bad. Kidnapping minors, forcing them into marriages, raping them etc, etc. There is nothing good about this. Duterte has told the AFP to rescue child warriors.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1131809

President Rodrigo Roa Duterte has called on the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) to retrieve children, who were allegedly recruited by the New People’s Army (NPA) to become armed guerrillas, and return them to their parents.

“Itong mga NPA, kinukuha nila 'yung mga anak, dinadala nila sa ibang lugar. Kunin ninyo 'yung bata at isauli ninyo sa nanay pati tatay (These NPA rebels, they recruit the sons and daughters and bring them to different places. Bring them back to their mothers and fathers) because a child, a minor, should not be separated from the family home,” Duterte said in a situation briefing in Tandag City, Surigao del Sur on Tuesday night.

Duterte said soldiers do not need to have search warrants to enter the lairs of NPA terrorists who allegedly mold children into communist warriors.

“If the child is inside the house, there is already a crime committed, so you do not need a warrant to go in. Puntahan mo sa loob, kunin 'yung mga bata at isauli mo (Go inside, take the children, and bring them back) at the earliest opportunity,” Duterte added.

He said he would assume full responsibility in executing the war against insurgency.

That sounds a lot like the drug war and we all know how that has progressed.

Otherwise the insurgency continues ever on and on. One of they ways to end the NPA, so they say, is to build access roads.  Farm to market roads.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1131574

Improved access to far-flung villages in Borongan City, Eastern Samar is the key to wiping out the local communist terrorist group that has been threatening communities in the past five decades, Mayor Jose Ivan Dayan Agda said on Tuesday.

Speaking to members of the provincial task force to end the local communist armed conflict (ELCAC), Agda said terrorist activities of the New People’s Army (NPA) will continue for as long as some upland communities are hard to reach.

“People from remote barangays need us, people in the government. They need interventions, but all our planned interventions will be limited to none if we can hardly reach them, and if their needs remain unabated, resentment, division could prevail,” he said.

He cited the city’s Pinanag-an village with more than a thousand families.

This remotest village is about a three-hour motorboat ride from the city’s wharf passing through five villages. The long river is the only access to the village, about 23 kilometers away from the city.

The remotest village being a three-hour boat ride away is pretty outrageous. I'd imagine a concrete road would not help them.  But other villages need roads and the NPA is trying to stymie their construction.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1131826

The Police Regional Office in Caraga Region (PRO-13) on Thursday (Feb. 25) condemned the communist New People’s Army (NPA) for burning two units of heavy equipment utilized for the construction of a vital farm-to-market road (FMR) project in Surigao del Norte.

PRO-13 Director, Brig. Gen. Romeo M. Caramat Jr., said the burning took place at around 11 am Wednesday in Barangay Binocaran, Malimono town.

The dump truck and a backhoe, owned by CV Construction based in Surigao City, cost more or less PHP5.9 million.

“At least seven armed men poured gasoline and torched the dump truck and the backhoe,” Caramat said.

He said the suspects are reportedly members of the Guerrilla Front (GF) 16B of the NPA Northeastern Mindanao Regional Committee (NEMRC).

“The construction of the FMR project in Binocaran is temporarily stalled because of the attack. The NPA showed anew its true color of being a terrorist group and anti-peace and development. They deserve our shared condemnation,” Caramat said.

He added that the FMR is vital for the farmers and fishermen in connecting them to market centers to deliver their produce.

“Most of the common folks in the area will directly benefit from that FMR project considering that their primary source of living is farming and fishing. They thrive by selling agricultural and fisheries products from the barangays to the markets and the consumers,” Caramat said.

Perhaps they should have built those roads long ago. Is it really the insurgency that has hampered development in the Philippines? There has been all kinds of growth in the Philippines over the past 50 years. Why have the most remote places not benefited from that? Some of those villages don't even have access to clean running water and as a result people die from diarrhea outbreaks. Surely there are more factors at play than just the NPA. What will happen when they are gone? Will these places really see an influx of infrastructure construction?

More villaged have declared the NPA persona-non-grata.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1131985

Thirteen barangays in Capiz and Iloilo provinces, classified as under the influence of the communist terrorist group (CTG), have joined the list of local government units (LGUs) in Panay island that have denounced the Communist Party of the Philippines-New People’s Army-National Democratic Front (CPP-NPA-NDF) this February.

The villages are among the 49 barangays in Panay yet to be declared as cleared from the influence of the CTGs, said Major Cenon Pancito III, spokesperson for the 3rd Infantry Division of the Philippine Army (PA) in a phone interview on Friday. Panay is comprised of the provinces of Iloilo, Capiz, Aklan, and Antique.

“For us to complete the liberation of Panay we have to clear all affected barangays,” he said.

Of the 49 barangays, 43 are in Iloilo, two in Aklan, and four in Capiz.

Two are in Aklan?? Does that mean there are NPA in Boracay?? 

The army is using new techniques to persuade NPA fighters to surrender.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1131996

The Philippine Army’s 14th Civil-Military Operations (CMO) Battalion has stepped up its anti-insurgency campaign through the deployment of a mobile audio-visual system (MAVS) in various rural communities.

In Negros Occidental, the unit has assembled the first of the three MAVS on board a four-wheel drive military truck.

Maj. Arturo Dumalagan, commanding officer of the 14th CMO based in Murcia, Negros Occidental, said on Friday since they launched the initiative earlier this month, the mobile facility has been traveling to barangays in Cauayan and Hinobaan towns benefiting from the Army’s community support program.

“This innovation will address the need to dominate the information environment, especially in communities mostly affected by the false information fed to them by the left-leaning organizations allied with the Communist Party of the Philippines - New People’s Army - National Democratic Front,” Dumalagan said.

Dumalagan said they initially used the mobile loudspeaker system but eventually saw the need to also show videos to the people in the communities.

“We are showing the recorded interviews of former rebels to raise awareness among the youth, especially minors, who are targets for CPP-NPA recruitment,” he said.

The AFP is driving around blasting video and airing interviews of former rebels to raise awareness against the NPA. Apparently it has been effective because the battalion who is deploying it won an award last year. They are winning hearts and minds.

Fear is also an effective weapon. Remember when the mayor of Matuguinao, Samar gave all the rebels in his area an ultimatum to surrender? Some of them heeded that call.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1131582

At least 118 former members of the New People’s Army (NPA) and their staunch supporters formally yielded to the Philippine Army and the local government of Matuguinao, Samar, a military official said on Tuesday. 

All, including nine village officials, joined the mass surrender ceremony at the town hall on Feb. 19, four days after the ultimatum set by Mayor Aran Boller. 

Last January, the mayor gave NPA members and die-hard supporters until Feb. 15 to submit themselves to the authorities. Those who failed to surrender will be declared persona non-grata or face charges of supporting a terrorist group. 

Some 353 town residents were identified by the local government and the military as NPA members and supporters. 

Among them, only 195 have been subjected to tactical interrogation, said Lt. Col. Jasper Pecson, commander of the 19th Infantry Battalion. 

Of the 195, only 118 attended the mass surrender ceremony.

“The campaign is still a success because those who surrendered are officials in their respective villages who have influences,” Pecson said in a phone interview.

Perhaps the rest of those tagged as NPA members and supporters will surrender and avail of all the free money, housing, and job training the government is offering.

Monday, March 1, 2021

The God Culture: The Search for King Solomon's Treasure Sourcebook Review

In this article I want to take a look at some of the odd stuff in The God Culture's sourcebook which accompanies "The Search for King Solomon's Treasure." One would think this book would be rather straightforward. It's purpose is to show their sources. Now one does not have to scour the internet for PDF's or run to the library.  Instead you just look up the source in the sourcebook and see their proof. Most entries have a link to the source. But with all things concerning The God Culture there is more than meets the eye. If this group were Transformers they would be Decepticons. 

Follow Our Research In Detail In Our

SOURCEBOOK

Over 400 Sources That Prove

The Philippines Is Ophir & the Garden of Eden

In Addition to the Bible and Extra-Biblical Books

As I wrote above the premise is very straightforward. Timothy Jay Schwab is laying all his cards on the table for everyone to see. With this hand he has finally and indisputably proven the Philippines is Ophir and the Garden of Eden. No one can disprove him. 

Everyone should at least be mindful this is a very credible case with full support which is why no one has been able to disprove it.

But hold on a minute there's some writing on these cards! Tim has turned a Jack into a King. The King has turned into an Ace! What's going on here? What I'm saying is Tim adds his own little commentaries to some of these sources so that now they don't contradict him. Let's look at a few of these instances.


page 20

NOTE: Perfect example of British manipulations to this narrative: This Periplus quoted by Suarez is deceptively incomplete omitting important directions. We do not use Suarez in his misrepresentation of part of the directions to Chryse provided by the Periplus of the Erythaean Sea which we instead quote directly. We use his misrepresentation of Mela as an example of such. He totally misrepresented this by removing parts of the 2nd half of the directions which indicate it is the island beyond China and to the Southeast of China in the sea. That cannot be Malaysia but only the Philippines fits. He does so to force the Malay Peninsula into the equation which requires deliberate British fraud. See Next Page for Mela's actual words translated and the following page for the actual Periplus with full directions you will not find with this author. How any author could offer the Periplus and leave out the portion within "After this region under the very north, the sea outside ending in a land called This." [China] can only be fraud. Let's be clear. 

There is a blogger attempting to capitalize on this fraud by further advancing it and additional fraud of such also ignoring the actual Periplus wording and going right to authors like this who are clearly deceiving and not attempting to represent the truth. 

Suarez then misinterprets Mela above who located Chryse and Argyre as islands in the South China Sea not the Malay Peninsula, misrepresents the Periplus completely and then, goes on to claim Pliny the Elder and geographer was confused about whether Chryse was an island or a Peninsula thus it must be a Peninsula yet Pliny calls it an island every time. He seizes on directions where Pliny involves 3 rivers in China, a bay and the "Promontory of Chryse." Again, Pliny was a geographer. He knew the difference between an isle and a peninsula. He also knew the word promontory refers to a rocky point and islands can have promontories just as much as peninsulas. Yes the word can be a peninsula but not when the same author calls it an island many times and a promontory only this once which is also a description found on an island. That's deception not scholarship. However, he fraudulently deals with such and concludes Pliny must have meant peninsula. To make such assumption requires one to believe Pliny did not know the difference and was confused yet his writings are very clear and he was a geographer. This is propaganda

In this commentary Timothy is calling Thomas Suarez, the author of early Mapping of Southeast Asia, a fraud and a propagandist. He even takes time to mention me! I think he is referring to my article, The God Culture: Finding Chryse: Don't Follow Biased Paradigms. Why is the man who wrote the authoritative book on early maps of Southeast Asia a fraud? Tim says it's because he omits the 2nd half of the directions to Chryse. Here is the full text.

63.   After these, the course turns toward the east again, and sailing with the ocean to the right and the shore remaining beyond to the left, Ganges comes into view, and near it the very last land toward the east, Chryse. There is a river near it called the Ganges, and it rises and falls in the same way as the Nile. On its bank is a market-town which has the same name as the river, Ganges. Through this place are brought malabathrum and Gangetic spikenard and pearls, and muslins of the finest sorts, which are called Gangetic. It is said that there are gold-mines near these places, and there is a gold coin which is called caltis. And just opposite this river there is an island in the ocean, the last part of the inhabited world toward the east, under the rising sun itself; it is called Chryse; and it has the best tortoise-shell of all the places on the Erythraean Sea.

64.   After this region under the very north, the sea outside ending in a land called This, there is a very great inland city called Thinae [i.e. China], from which raw silk and silk yarn and silk cloth are brought on foot through Bactria to Barygaza, and are also exported to Damirica [=Limyrike] by way of the river Ganges. But the land of This is not easy of access; few men come from there, and seldom. The country lies under the Lesser Bear [Ursa Minor], and is said to border on the farthest parts of Pontus and the Caspian Sea, next to which lies Lake Maeotis; all of which empty into the ocean.

https://depts.washington.edu/silkroad/texts/periplus/periplus.html 

Paragraph 63 describes the land of Chryse. Paragraph 64 says "after this region" is China. Understand the directions are moving eastward. From Chryse we go east to China. Is China to the east of the Philippines? No. So Tim is wrong in his interpretation of this text. He is also wrong about Suarez. He does not ignore paragraph 64 as Tim alleges. Here is what Suarez writes.

Early Mapping of Southeast Asia

Chryse most likely represented Malaya, while Argyre was probably Burma, perhaps Arakan. Both are seen as islands in the world map after Mela (fig. 9), Chryse being the island off the east Asian coast, and Argyre the island at the Ganges delta next to Taprobana. On the twelfth-century 'Turin' world map (figs. 30 & 31), they appear as a single island in the easternmost ocean sea, the right-hand isle of the two immediately above Adam and Eve (the left-hand isle is simply designated insula, and thus may have been intended for either Chryse or Argyre). 

Mention of Chryse is also made in the Periplus of the Erythrean Sea, which describes Chryse as "the last part of the inhabited world toward the east, under the rising sun itself, " a land from which comes "the best tortoise-shell of all the places on the Erythrean Sea." The work's anonymous author then described the land of This (China) and city of Thinae, from which raw silk, silk yarn, and silk cloth, acquired through silent barter, were brought overland to India. Isidorus Hispalensis (Isidore of Seville, ca. 560-636 A.D.), in his Etymologiae, one of the most popular cosmographies of the Middle Ages, also placed the lands of Chryse and Argyre in the southeastern extreme of the world, along with Taprobana and Tyle (Tile, an island near India).

Suarez says Chryse is mentioned in the Periplus of the Erythean Sea. After that place is described Suarez says the author moves on to describe China. Again we are going east and China is not east of the Philippines. Tim does not agree wth Suarez so he calls him a fraud and misrepresents his book.

I'm not going to bother to refute him on Mela and Pliny. The fact that Pliny, Mela, and everyone else has different directions and descriptions for Chryse as being both an island and a peninsula should alert Tim to the fact that  Greeks were unfamiliar with this region and never sailed there for gold. 

There are two places in the sourcebook where Tim mentions the Rothschilds. The first one is located on page 35.

This search tells us that there is a huge paragraph on page 35. But there isn't. Instead the text is hidden!


Why does Tim have hidden text in his sourcebook? Doesn't he want his readers to be informed about everything he has to say? If you look at the coding it hardly seems unintentional especially considering the hidden text he has on all his other webpages. As far as I can gather the text reads as follows:

’s have funded the suppression of Ophir since the 1600s when they paid Purchas to commit their   …   propaganda. The Malay Peninsula was never an island and no sailor nor cartographer in those days could possibly confuse the two unless they operate in a   …   completely broken paradigm such as Ptolemy regarding the Far East in which he had no clue. In fact, mariners would largely hug the coasts thus they would   …   follow India through Burma to Malaysia noticing Malaysia to be a peninsula. It is impossible for them to mistake based on their practices. These maps are   …   our interpretation based on this mindset. We are using a modern map but notice we are blacking out the Malay Peninsula and Indochina to the left just as   …   most of these maps do even the ones we already covered on the previous pages. When you follow these directions from The Periplus of the Erythaean Sea,   …   Pomponius Mela, Dionysius the Tourist and others, this becomes evident as they all tie and lead to the same place in the correct paradigm. Additionally,   …   the maps we selected actually represent their written directions which we covered. All of them call Chryse an island and none of them accidentally meant   …   a peninsula just as Pliny the Elder calls it an island and never a peninsula. Dionysius even adds in an incredibly fixed marker regardless identifying Chryse   …   directly under the Tropic of Cancer. This made us realize that is exactly what The Periplus was describing as “under the very north” as the North begins   …   at Cancer. No one can move that and Malaysia is not even a remote fit as there are 2 countries North of it between such line yet the Philippines is directly   …   under Cancer which is inline with South China and Taiwan. Malaysia is also on top of the Equator and could never to associated with accuracy with the   …   Tropic of Cancer. Review these in detail, compare with the previous maps and any others you can find, and prove it out. We believe you will find this to   …   be accurate. As you complete this chapter, you will find this thinking fully confirmed on the next pages as the Portuguese found Chryse and Argyre and   …   documented it with a government-commissioned map.   …   20 continued...

That paragraph should start with "Rothschild's" but if you look at the coding you see that Rothschild is separated from the text by a mark tag <mark>. How can that be unintentional?

The second instance where the Rothschilds are mentioned is on page 128.

page 128

NOTE: Dr. Craig did not wish to make a case for the Philippines as Ophir as he references Former Prime Minister Paterno did. Such is understandable. However, if he had actually truly researched the Biblical passages as we have, especially knowing the abundant history which he certainly did, such connection would become incredibly obvious. Does he quote Sir Douglas properly? Yes. See below. These are all native products of the Philippines and Ophir brought to China. See Testing All the Resources of Ophir. Though Douglas does not state Philippines by name nor could he as the Rothschilds would have his head, the products match and the deduction accurate especially in lieu of all the other evidence in context. Ophir/Philippines was trading across the ocean by ship as early as 990 B.C.  

In this note Tim calls Sir Robert Douglas a pawn of the Rothschilds who could not mention the Philippines or they would "have his head!!"

What evidence does Timothy have that Sir Douglas was working for the Rothschilds? What evidence does he have that the Rothschilds were actively suppressing historical information about the Philippines trading with China millennia ago? He does not say. Tim claims Douglas is covering up the Philippines' role in early shipping to China by not naming them. But Sir Douglas does not name any of the eight nations alleged to have been trading with China during that period. Here is the text.

During the Shang dynasty (1766-1154 B.C.) we learn from the native records that' travellers from the neighbourhood of Canton came bringing fish-skin cases, sharp swords and shields. These men wore their hair short, we are told, and their bodies were tattooed. Other companies arrived bringing pearls, tortoise-shells, elephants’ teeth, peacocks' feathers, birds and small dogs. 

At the beginning of the next dynasty — the Chou (B.C.1122-255) — intercourse had been established with eight foreign nations; and it was at Canton that the merchants of these states exchanged their goods for the products of Cathay. 

Europe and the Far East, 1506-1912, pgs 1-2

That text says nothing about the Philippines or any other nation. To make it fit his purposes Tim resorts to quoting Dr. Austin Craig who says that those are products of the Philippines. Thus the Philippine-China connection is established, right? Wrong! Tim does not quote Dr. Craig in full and thus misrepresents him.

The British Museum's oriental scholar (Douglas: Europe and the Far East, Cambridge, 1904) states that by the beginning of the Chou dynasty (B. C. 1122-255) intercourse had been established at Canton with eight foreign nations. Duties as early as 990 B. C. were levied, and among the imports were birds, pearls and tortoise shell, products of the Philippines, but the origin of these has not been investigated. "Reliable history,"' says Dr. Pott (A Sketch of Chinese History, Shanghai, 1908), "does not extend further back than the middle of the Chou dynasty (B. C. 722). 


After the time of the Chou dynasty we come to more solid ground, for at the beginning of the Han dynasty (B. C. 206) the custom originated of employing Court chroniclers to write a daily account of governmental proceedings. These diaries were kept secret and stored away in iron chests until the dynasty they chronicled had passed away; then they were opened and published, and so form the basis of our knowledge of the events that had transpired while the dynasty was in existence." 

Philippine history, however, has attracted only incidental interest in the translating of these voluminous chronicles so that while the first three mentions hereafter to be cited are well within the reliable history period they have not been verified and are valuable only as suggesting more definitely where to investigate.  

On page 137 of "The Search for King Solomon's Treasure" Tim write this:

In his original work "Europe and the Far East", 1506-1912," Sir Douglas, whom Dr. Austin Craig is citing, notes this trade took place in Canton in 990 B.C. thus Filipinos and others travelled there. Dr. Craig (1914) concluded that these products originated in the Philippines.

Tim could not be further from the truth. Dr. Craig says the history of China is unreliable beyond 722 B.C. and "solid ground" to determine history does not occur until around 200 B.C. when records began to be kept. Furthermore while Dr. Craig does admit those are Philippine products he says unambiguously that the origin of those products has not been investigated. He absolutely does not conclude they originated in the Philippines. This passage in "The Search for King Solomon's Treasure" is a blatant lie.

Tim has twisted Dr. Craig's words and he has smeared Sir Robert Douglas as being an agent of the Rothschilds.  That's neither the work of a scholar or an honest man. That's the work of a propagandist. To quote Tim, "That's deception not scholarship." Tim does not know how to play the game right. He does not know when to hold 'em or when to fold 'em. He should just walk away from the table. He should not have entered the game in the first place. He is no scholar. He is the fraud here.

There is more commentary like this throughout the book but let's look at the strangest thing of all about this sourcebook: there are missing sources! Sources 161, 184, 190, 209, 225, 229, 230, 272, 277, 278, 290, 327-334, 342-346, 357-360, 363, 375, 385, 391, 413, 415, 416  are all missing from the Sourcebook! I cannot show all of these so I will show the most egregious case.  

The Search for King Solomon's Treasure Sourcebook

There is a leap here from 326 to 335. Why did Tim OMIT these sources from his Sourcebook? It does not make sense. That is a real problem because this authoritative sourcebook is supposed to prove his case beyond all doubt. Some of these sources do not even show up in the main text of his book. 

Even though 209 is not listed in the bibliography of the sourcebook it is in fact on page 212. 346 is found on page 183 despite not being in the bibliography. 346 is a little confusing because it is the same reference as 179.




1. "History of Batnagas." Batangas Provincial Information Office. Province of Batangas. 2. Strong's Concordance "Ba'ah" #H1158, "Tan" #H8565, and "Gan" #H1588. Blue Letter Bible.

Source 298 is in the sourcebook and in the bibliography of "The Search for King Solomon's Treasure" but is not in the main text. Like 179 and 346 it is a reference to "Gan" #H1588. That means Tim has three sources with the same reference. Why is that?

Several sources appear to not show up in the book "The Search for King Solomon's Treasure" except for in the bibliography. These are: 161, 184, 190, 225, 229, 230, 277, 278, 298, 327-334, 342, 344, 357-360, 375, 413, 415. That is 26 sources unaccounted for. I noted in my review of "The Search for King Solomon's Treasure" that source 28 does not show up in the text of the book but only in the bibliography. That could have been a simple oversight but what are we to make of 26 other sources being left out of the book? What are we to make of all the sources missing from the sourcebook?   

Some of these omissions could possibly be explained by the fact that they are duplicates. For instance 229 and 216 have the same reference to "pealim.com #6051." Source 216 actually has two references the second being to "pealim.com #5053." It is not clear why this reference to #6051 is repeated for 229.  

Sources 161 and 166 refer to the same book but a different page. 166 makes it into the sourcebook and main text while 161 does not.

Sources 230 and 217 are exactly the same. They both refer to "Strong's Concordance #4327 Biblehub.com." 

34 and 357 are basically the same as they refer to the same book and chapter of The Antiquites of the Jews. However 357 has two additional references to a Wikipedia article about the Kabul River and to "Old Iranian Online" which is a glossary of old Iranian words. Curiously Tim does not include this in his sourcebook though he clearly discusses these matters on page 52 of "The Search for King Solomon's Treasure."


The Search for King Solomon's Treasure, pg 52

Josephus is only dealing with Mesha in this rendering not Sephar and he is narrowing down the area very specifically based on references that we can connect even today in modern history. I)ohir and family lived initially in the bort', region of what we would identify today as Iran and Afghanistan. The Cophen River is acknowledged as the modern Kabul River in Afghanistan. Notice then Joseph. connects this with "and" meaning this is at border legion. The second region is "part of Aria adjoining Is it." Aria is very easy to identify Arya is the Old Persian name of what we call Iran today and its etymology still originates in Aryan. Therefore, Josephus is locating Mesha on the border of Iran and Afghanistan. Meshad, Iran accordingly materializes to be positioned on the Northeastern border or Iran right next to Afghanistan exactly where he placed it

What we have here is a bizarre instance where Tim did not attribute his sources in the text but did include them in his bibliography yet kept them out of the sourcebook. That is a huge oversight and certainly requires emendation for any future editions of this book.

Sources 22 and 344 refer to the same book. But source 22 actually refers to 3 sources not just one. In fact a few of Tim's sources have more than one reference attributed such as 346 with 2, 367 with 3, and 10 which has 4. This makes for a lot of clutter and overlap.

One of the sources left out of the sourcebook is 385. It is in the book. Here is the passage.

In fact, it was not until 1599, until the Philippines legally recognised the Spanish sovereignty over the Philippines. [385]

"The Search for King Solomon's Treasure," page 262

The source is listed as 

Villarroel 2009, pp. 93–133

What exactly is this source? What is Villarroel 2009? If you Google that citation you will find out that it comes from Wikipedia. That means Tim did not read this source, has no idea what it says, but simply lifted the citation from Wikipedia. It's no wonder he excises it from his sourcebook. He cannot prove to his readers anything from it. How sad and pathetic for Tim to lift a citation as proof for his case even though he has no idea what it says because he never read it. But that is his method and we have seen this before in the 100 Clues review where he lifts three citations for proof that there was Filipino gold jewelry found in first century Egypt.

Source 345 is a strange case because there is no source number 345. Not in "The Search for King Solomon's Treasure" and not in the sourcebook. Tim skips from 344 to 346. 


Again, is that an oversight or is it intentional? 

Source 144 appears to not be in the bibliography but it is there. You just have to look closely.


Why is source 144 not in the margin?  That is incredibly sloppy.

Let's end this critique with one more anomaly. Tim has 417 sources listed in the bibliography of  "The Search for King Solomon's Treasure." But in the sourcebook he has 419 sources listed. Where do these two extra sources come from? 

The Search For King Solomon's Treasure

The Search for King Solomon's Treasure Sourcebook

Again, is this a mere oversight or was it intentional? 

Source 418 is actually included in the book on page 201 and in the sourcebook on page 209.


The Search for King Solomon's Treasure, pg. 201
Sinai. Hebrew: ×¡×™× ×™‎: Modern Sinait [418] Near Laoag where the Lost Tribes of Israel may have landed in the desert, we oddly find three symbols of a second exodus. Today the name has been changed adding a "t" on the end but on this 1775 map, the area, the river and an island North are all labeled Sinai. Unto itself this is perhaps coincidence. However; with all the overwhelming such references in the Philippines, this is certainly a Hebrew word. Vigan, originally Bi-Gan, is also a Hebrew possibility meaning come and go in the Garden. 
Exactly how a map drawn up by a Frenchman in 1775 has anything to do with the Lost Tribes and residual Hebrew is left unexplained by Tim. It is not clear at all why Jean-Baptiste d'Après de Mannevillette, the man who made this map, labelled three places "Sinai" but it is rash to jump to Tim's conclusions. With no actual proof as to why three places are named Sinai Tim's explanation is ad hoc. In fact Wikipedia offers a totally different account of why there is a place named Sinait in Illocos Sur which totally contradicts Tim.
Small battles were daily occurrence so that in the year 1535, when the locality was organized and established as a “Pueblo” Salcedo named the new community as “SIN-NAIT”, a word in the local tongue which means “CONTEST”. 

In the year 1575, the natives fully realized the hardships of pronouncing the term “SIN-NAIT” and to go away with the trouble, Salcedo declared that one of the letter “N” be dropped. Since then, this Municipality has been called “SINAIT”.

Is it true? I don't know and that's not the point. The point is there are alternate explanations for all the place-names in the Philippines rather than ancient residual Hebrew. And by the way the map Tim uses is actually from 1810 and not 1775. The link he gives for this source tells us that. A small detail but important nonetheless as accuracy is crucial.

What can we conclude from this? If this were all a mere oversight then we can conclude that Tim is a very sloppy editor. He claims to have 30 years of experience in the publishing industry and his self-published books are the fruit of all those years. It's hard to imagine that a man with so much experience in publishing could be such a sloppy editor. It is also equally hard to imagine that these are mere oversights. There are too many anomalies. What accounts for all the missing sources? Why are there 417 sources in the main book but 419 sources in the sourcebook? Why are there sources in the bibliography of "The Search for King Solomon's Treasure" missing from the main text? Why are there duplicate sources? Why is 345 completely missing?

Lest Timothy Jay Schwab and Anna shriek out that I am nit-picking let me remind them of their own words.
Everyone should at least be mindful this is a very credible case with full support which is why no one has been able to disprove it.

They are very proud of this sourcebook and declare it proves all their claims. Why is it so sloppy? Their listeners and readers deserve an answer.

Friday, February 26, 2021

Retards in the Government 195

 It's your weekly compendium of foolishness and corruption in the Philippine government.


 

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1131473

Some 18 police officers and non-uniformed personnel of the Philippine National Police (PNP) are facing dismissal after they tested positive for illegal drugs during a random test.

PNP chief Gen. Debold Sinas on Monday said he ordered the pre-charge investigation and summary dismissal proceedings against the 17 police officers and one non-uniformed personnel.

“Starting this year I have already signed the directive that all cases related to random drug testing at tao namin sa drugs should be resolved by the regional director immediately para mapabilis po (to hasten the process) at centralized na angrecording ngayon (and recording is now centralized)," Sinas said in a press briefing at Camp Crame.

17 PNP officers and one non-uniformed personnel to be dismissed for testing positive for drugs.

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1399032/quezon-village-watchman-nabbed-for-possession-of-illegal-gun

A barangay tanod (village watchman) in Sariaya town in Quezon province was arrested for alleged illegal possession of a firearm.

A police team nabbed Alexander Cabula, 49, a watchman in Barangay Bignay I, for carrying an undocumented caliber .45 pistol in the said village around 8:30 p.m., a report said.

A policeman accosted Cabula, whom they saw with a pistol grip protruding from his waist.

The suspect failed to produce a permit and license for the said firearm.

A village watchmen was caught with an illegal gun.

https://www.philstar.com/nation/2021/02/24/2079908/soldier-kills-superior-cagayan

An Army sergeant was shot dead by his subordinate following an argument in Barangay Piggatan in Alcala, Cagayan on Monday.

A police report said the incident occurred when Cpl. Rickson Rulloda confronted Sgt. Paulino Gavino Jr. for assigning him to another unit.

He will probably be courtmartialed as well as tossed in the brig.

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1399592/suspended-patrolman-allegedly-abducted-in-manila-police

A suspended police officer was allegedly abducted by five unidentified armed men in Sta. Mesa, Manila on Wednesday morning, police said.

In an initial report, Manila Police District (MPD) chief Brigadier General Leo Francisco identified the victim as Patrolman Real Lopez Tesoro, 41.

Police records showed that Tesoro was last assigned to the Regional Police Holding and Accounting Section of the National Capital Region Police Office.

According to the police report, the patrolman was walking along V Mapa Extension in Barangay 601 at 10:05 a.m. when four armed men and a woman, onboard two sports utility vehicles, reportedly abducted him.

No word on why this cop was suspended which would no doubt shed light on why he was abducted.

https://news.abs-cbn.com/news/02/24/21/missing-dswd-staff-found-dead-in-bulacan-arms-and-feet-tied-head-wrapped-in-packaging-tape

An employee of the Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD) was found dead in San Jose Del Monte in Bulacan Sunday afternoon. 

Police identified the victim as Justine Charles Accad, 30 years old and a resident of Barangay Malanday in Marikina City. 

Accad was reported missing on February 19, and was found dead 2 days later, with his arms and feet tied and his head wrapped in packaging tape.

No word on who the perpetrators are or why they would commit such a horrendous crime.

https://www.philstar.com/nation/2021/02/25/2080172/pdea-boc-chiefs-face-raps-p1-billion-shabu-auction

The National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) yesterday filed complaints of graft and grave misconduct against Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency director general Wilkins Villanueva, former PDEA chief Aaron Aquino and Bureau of Customs (BOC) Commissioner Rey Guerrero over a shipment of P1 billion worth of shabu stashed in tapioca starch in 2019. 

Also charged before the Department of Justice (DOJ) were BOC Deputy Commissioner Raniel Ramiro as well as PDEA directors Joel Plaza, Aldrin Albarino, Jigger Montallana and several anti-narcotics agents. 

The respondents are facing charges related to drugs, graft, grave misconduct, serious dishonesty as well as violation of the Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Employees, Customs Modernization and Tariff Act and conduct prejudicial to the best interest of service. 

The charges stemmed from the smuggling of 171 kilos of shabu that were found to be hidden in aluminum pallets in a tapioca starch shimpment. 

The PDEA said it received intelligence information that drugs concealed in tapioca would be delivered to the country in January 2019. 

Authorities reportedly found an abandoned tapioca shipment in March and put it up for auction in April allegedly to draw out possible members of drug rings. 

The drug haul was confiscated in May in the warehouse of the winning bidder in Malabon.

The BOC had insisted that it only auctioned off tapioca.

What started off seeming like a bright idea could end up costing these officials their freedom.

https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2021/02/24/2080190/pnp-failed-follow-protocols-many-drug-operations-guevarra-tells-un-rights-body

At a high-level meeting of the UNHRC, Guevarra said initial findings showed that  weapons allegedly recovered from those killed in the operations were not examined to check the police narrative that the "drug personalities" sought to resist arrest or that they fought back.


"No verification of its ownership was taken [and] no request for ballistic examination or paraffin test was pursued until its completion," he said. 

"In more than half of the records reviewed, the law enforcement agents involved failed to follow standard protocols pertaining to coordination with other agencies and the processing of the crime scene." 

He also told the UNHRC that Philippine National Police leadership had already been informed of the findings, and administrative and criminal charges were already recommended against "scores of police officers" found to have violated protocols.

Shouldn't the PNP leadership have known about this? They probably did and did not care. This report only serves to justify all the critics of the drug war.

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1400008/negros-oriental-judge-finds-5-pdea-agents-guilty-of-indirect-contempt-of-court-for-fake-buy-bust

A judge in Negros Oriental has found five agents of the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency (PDEA) guilty of indirect contempt of court in connection with an alleged fake buy-bust operation in Barangay Looc, Dumaguete City.

Judge Amelia Lourdes Mendoza of the Regional Trial Court Branch 34 sentenced PDEA agents Nelson Muchuelas, May Ann Carmelo, Jose Anthony Juanites, Cheryl Mae Villaver, and Realyn Pinpin to six months imprisonment at the Bureau of Jail Management and Penology in Dumaguete and to pay P30,000-fine each.

The court has also issued warrants of arrest for the five agents.

The court concluded that the PDEA agents arrested five drug suspects in separate places and not in a single buy-bust operation on June 28, 2020. The drug charges against the five agents were dismissed in October.

“The court wants to emphasize that the basis for the indirect contempt charges arises from the fact that the official narrative of the arrests as contained in the affidavits, photographs, and other attachments to the complaint, has been unmasked as false and fake,” the judge said.

These cops arrested 5 people in separate locations and then claimed that they arrested them all in a single buy-bust operation. It was all a lie. Now they will likely end up in prison for six months.

https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2021/02/25/2080271/cops-vs-pdea-shootout-near-mall-leaves-2-dead

The gunfight erupted near a fastfood restaurant shortly before 6 p.m. and lasted for almost an hour, reports said. Bystanders scampered into different directions as gunshots rang out.

An initial police report said three police officers from the QCPD Special Operations Unit, identified as Lt. Ronnie Ereno and Corporals Lauro de Guzman and Calvin Eric Garado, and two PDEA agents were wounded in the incident.

Investigation showed the police were conducting a drug sting, unaware that the persons they were transacting with were PDEA agents.

During the confrontation, the PDEA agents reportedly opened fire and shot the policemen which triggered a shootout which lasted for almost an hour.

The policemen claimed the operation was properly coordinated with PDEA and had the necessary documents.

If this operation were properly coordinated then how was the PNP unaware they were transacting with PDEA agents?