Thursday, May 13, 2021

Coronavirus Lockdown: Mega Jab Center, Mandatory Face Shields, and More!

More news about how the COVID-19 pandemic in the Philippines is being handled by the public and the government.

The government has not been shy about blaming the public for not following health protocols as being the cause of the spike in COVID-19 cases. But a new study shows half of those infected have one of the variants which are more infectious.


https://news.abs-cbn.com/news/05/06/21/nearly-half-of-covid-19-samples-from-metro-manila-linked-to-foreign-variants-expert

Nearly half of sequenced COVID-19 samples from Metro Manila are foreign variants of the virus, a member of the Philippines' vaccine expert panel said Thursday. 

Between January 4 and May 2, the Philippines has sequenced 7,167 samples nationwide, but has yet to disclose the recent number of samples taken from Metro Manila, according to data from the Department of Health (DOH). 

"Since these are only representative samples... it will just tell you that it is present in NCR (National Capital Region), said Dr. Rontgene Solante, who is also the head of San Lazaro Hospital's Adult Infectious Diseases and Tropical Medicine. 

"It does not mean that it is causing community transmission," he said in an online press conference. 

It would "really take time" before the Philippines could say if the new variants, which are about 50 percent more transmissible, are already the dominant strains of COVID-19 in the country, he said. 

(Our sampling is really very low... We need to get those data so that we can have a more objective way of telling people which variants have been detected.)

While it may be too early to say definitively what effects these strains are having on the spread of the virus it should not be ruled out as a cause. 

Along with having the longest lockdown in the world the Philippines will now be even more strict in enforcing health protocols as Duterte has ordered that all people who are not wearing face masks properly are to be arrested. This has caused LGUs and the PNP to have to adjust their policies.

The Department of the Interior and Local Government will confer with the Philippine National Police and local government units to adjust ordinances to President Rodrigo Duterte’s order to arrest those wearing face mask improperly.

DILG Undersecretary Jonathan Malaya said in an interview with ANC’s "Headstart" that they will sit with PNP leadership and LGUs "to determine the parameters of the presidential directive."

"We will have to reconcile this also with the various ordinances that were issued by different LGUs," he added.

In a recorded address aired on Wednesday night, Duterte ordered police to arrest those not wearing face masks properly in public and detain them for nine hours.

“My orders to the police are those who are not wearing their masks properly in order to protect the public—because if not, if you cannot defend the public—to arrest them and detain them, investigate why they are doing it. They have nine hours,” he said.

Malaya explained that LGUs have different ordinances and sanctions on directives issued by the Inter-Agency Task Force on the Management of Emerging Infectious Diseases, the policy-making body during the pandemic. 

LGUs imposed warnings or fines, and arrests are only allowed when there is resistance to authorities, added the DILG official.

But Malaya acknowledged that in implementing Duterte’s order, the DILG must also account for detention spaces.

“If we do make arrests, we would also need to prepare our detention cells because there may be a larger number of people detained than before,” he added.

Not only is this order against commonsense and completely draconian but it does not take into account the lack of space in which to detain people. It also contradicts the decision of the DOJ to not arrest violators but give them community service.

Strangely enough new PNP Chief Eleazar says no violators will be given harsh penalties despite arrest itself being a harsh penalty.

https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/news/nation/786775/no-harsh-penalty-vs-face-mask-policy-violators-eleazar/story/

Police officers will not enforce harsh penalties for violation of the face mask policy, the country's new top cop Police General Guillermo Eleazar said Sunday.

Eleazar said they will bring violators to a holding area and enforce local ordinances on the mandatory wearing of face mask, such as community service or imposing fines.

[Officials have no right to impose punishment. They will apprehend but won't hurt or punish. Violators will just be placed in a holding area.]

Already they are preparing detention facilities for those they apprehend. PNP officers have been ordered to "observe maximum tolerance in arresting violators" but the PNP does not have a good track record in such a thing as tolerance.

Right now it is only face masks which are mandatory in public across the nation. One town has recently made face shields mandatory in public as well.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1139621

The city government has amended its ordinance requiring the mandatory wearing not only of face masks but face shields outside their homes.

Aileen Refuerzo, Public Information Office chief, on Saturday said the city’s legislative body approved on final reading Ordinance No. 49, series of 2021, which amended Ordinance No. 45-2020 or the Face Mask Ordinance of Baguio City by incorporating the face shield requirement.

“The city government will enforce the Face Mask and Face Shield Ordinance of 2021 following completion of its amendment process,” Refuerzo said on Saturday.

The measure, she added, declares that it is “unlawful” for all persons including tourists and outsiders to go to public places, buildings, national roads, or highway, sidewalks, walkways, or public conveyances or other similar establishments, without wearing face mask and face shield until the threat of the Covid-19 is completely eliminated in the country.

The penalty for non-wearing of face mask is PHP1,000, PHP2,000, and PHP3,000 for the first to third offense, respectively and cancellation of business permit if applicable.

The penalties for non-wearing of face shield and indiscriminate disposal of used or damaged face masks and face shields are PHP500, PHP1,000, and PHP2,000 for first to third offense, respectively, and cancellation of business permit if applicable.

How necessary and ridiculous. Let us hope such a scheme does not become the law of the land.

Feeling hopeless during this pandemic? Just look to this cross if you live in the area where it has been erected.

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1429051/piats-giant-cross-in-the-sky-lights-up-to-bring-hope-amid-pandemic

A 16-meter-tall cross perched on the 50-meter-high Black Hill was ceremonially lit on Friday night (May 7) to serve as a symbol of faith, hope, and love for residents of Piat who are battling the COVID-19 pandemic.

Called the “Cross in the Sky,” it stands at the People’s Integrated Agritourism Center. The local government of Piat allocated P1.5-million for its construction.

“The cross brings the message that we can surpass all problems including the pandemic if we have Jesus as our center of life,” said Mayor Carmelo Villacete on Saturday (May 8).

Villacete said the Piat Basilica Minore church and surrounding villages have been locked down following the death of a church organist, as well as the infection of two doctors and 11 other health workers.

Located near Piat’s black lagoon, the giant cross is expected to lure tourists once travel restrictions are lifted, according to tourism officer Benedict Santo Tomas. He said the Piat municipal government will strictly enforce all health protocols when that happens.

They hope to turn this cross into a tourist destination but there is no way that will happen soon. When the pandemic is over it will only be a reminder of all the excess waste of money spent on things like this. Speaking of waste the government wants to set up a temporary mega vaccination center in an urban forest.

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1429129/green-concerns-raised-vs-planned-mega-jab-center

Environment and heritage advocates are opposing a plan by the government to put up a “megavaccination center” in an urban forest, saying the short-term use of the property of the Nayong Pilipino Foundation (NPF) will result in long-term ecological damage.

Lucille Karen Malilong-Isberto, the NPF executive director, resigned on Thursday due to a conflict with Tourism Secretary Bernadette Romulo Puyat over the project that would require chopping down about 500 trees at the NPF’s property in Entertainment City, the reclaimed area in Parañaque City known for its casinos.

The heritage group Dakilang Pamana ng Lahi (Pamanlahi) said the proposed vaccination site would endanger the “park’s growing ecosystem” and “urban wildlife” as the site is close to the Las Piñas-Parañaque critical habitat and protected wetland and is home to about 25 bird species.

“The green and fresh environment that is open and free, a large public space that is much-needed by the people of Metro Manila, will be destroyed and will disappear,” the group said in a statement on Thursday.

The NPF, a government-owned and controlled corporation (GOCC) attached to the Department of Tourism (DOT), also expressed the same concerns.

The NPF promotes cultural heritage and Filipino identity “hinged on diversity,” according to its website. It spearheads and develops “hubs, spaces, activities, green infrastructure projects, and research and knowledge production initiatives that utilize innovation and creative potential as catalysts for national development.”

It's not as if the government has ever thought ahead about much. They pretty much do everything short term.

Did you know that there are no FDA approved vaccines to prevent COVID-19? That's right. All the vaccines in use are merely authorized under emergency use orders. The latest vaccine to get that treatment is Sinopharm but by the WHO and not the FDA. Perhaps there Sinopharm will be arriving en masse soon. The Philippines has imported millions of vaccines and now they are number 2 in SEA for the number of jabs given.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1139805

The vaccination rollout gains full steam as the Philippines is now second among Southeast Asian nations with the most number of coronavirus vaccines administered.

In a report by National Task Force Against Covid-19 chief implementer and vaccine czar Carlito Galvez Jr., data show that as of May 10, the country has administered a total of 2,409,235 vaccine shots, more than two months after it started its vaccination campaign.

The seven-day average of doses administered is 65,879.

It is next to Indonesia with 21,993,299 doses administered since its rollout began on Jan. 13; Cambodia at third with 2,284,788 since Feb. 28.

Worldwide, the Philippines ranked 41st out of 194 and 15th out of 47 countries in Asia.

The government appears to meeting its goals which is good. The mayor of Makati, Abigail Binay, says her city now has more vaccines than vaccinees. She says it is a "beautiful problem."

While the Philippines has enough vaccines apparently it does not have enough propaganda. 

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1430419/step-up-covid-19-info-drive-communicate-pain-of-disease-pcoo-told

Ang Probinsyano Partylist Rep. Ronnie Ong said the PCOO should maximize the potential of its various information dissemination assets such as the Philippine Information Agency (PIA), Philippine News Agency (PNA), and Philippine Broadcasting Network (PBN) to increase people’s awareness of COVID-19.

One possible way to dissuade people from violating the basic health and safety protocols, Ong said, is to come up with visual materials that make people realize that COVID-19 “is not just a killer but is also a very painful disease.”

“Some people I know who lived to tell their ordeal told me the indescribable pain that they had to suffer. They can feel their lungs collapsing as they try to struggle to breathe. Parang meron daw truck na nakadagan sa dibdib mo sa sobrang sakit,” Ong said in a statement.

“We have to share these stories in a manner that people will have a self-realization that taking the risk for non-essential activities like going to pool parties or biking on big pelotons could put you or your loved ones in extreme pain and even death,” he added.

The government, Ong said, “needs to let our people visualize and experience the pain of being sick with COVID” through various information materials such as boosted social media optics, leaflets, flyers, and television and radio infomercials that will not just provide the public faceless and nameless statistics but a graphic warning of the “horrific ordeal one has to go through because of COVID.”

“It’s really hard to understand how people could still act like there’s no virus when we have already reached the one million mark in terms of death,” Ong said.

What is Ong talking about? There have only been 18,562 deaths in the Philippines and the DOH says there is a 91.3% recovery rate. Is he talking about the worldwide total? He should be specific. With the Indian variant now being detected in the Philippines perhaps the death toll will catch up to Ong's statement.

Wednesday, May 12, 2021

Philippine Foreign Policy: Cursing, False Bravado, and Foreign Economic Interference

The Philippines' foreign policy is kind of strange to say the least. There are two components to look at here. The first is a false bravado that manifests by hard language and cursing. This appears to be something confined to the Duterte administration. Surely everyone remembers the f-bombs Duterte has thrown at the UN, EU, and USA and his critics in his speeches. This fake machismo has rubbed off onto DFA Secretary Teddyboy Locsin. 

After filing scores of diplomatic protests regarding Chinese incursions into the WPS he finally "lost his temper" and dropped an f-bomb in a tweet regarding the issue.

https://twitter.com/teddyboylocsin/status/1389021070045290497

China, my friend, how politely can I put it? Let me see… O…GET THE FUCK OUT. What are you doing to our friendship? You. Not us. We’re trying. You. You’re like an ugly oaf forcing your attentions on a handsome guy who wants to be a friend; not to father a Chinese province...He doesn’t have a uterus. If he tried to give birth to a Chinese province it would be a ball of crap at best and the end of the regime. What is it so hard to understand about Duterte’s UN declaration that the Arbitral Award made all maritime features Philippines; no one else’s? 

Anyone who follows this man on Twitter knows how much of a blowhard he is and will just shrug this off as so much bluster no one, especially China, will pay attention to. The Palace had a rather unexpected take though.

https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2021/05/04/2095810/only-duterte-can-curse-palace-says-locsin-sorry-twitter-rant-vs-china

Foreign Affairs Secretary Teodoro Locsin Jr. has apologized for swearing at China on his Twitter account amid tensions over the West Philippine Sea, Malacañang said Tuesday. 

Locsin, who posts freely and often on the social networking site, the day before told China to "get the fuck out" of Philippine waters. "Usual suave diplomatic speak gets nothing done," he also said then, in defense of his remarks. 

"Before the press briefing, I spoke with Secretary Locsin and he informed me that he personally apologized to the Chinese ambassador and that the words he said were prompted by things that made him lose his temper," presidential spokesman Harry Roque said in Filipino. 

"The message of the president is: In the area of diplomacy, there is no place for cursing," he added. "Only the president can curse, no one else can copy him."

Teddy apologized for his tweet, which he has not deleted as of now, and Roque says Duterte's message is there is no place for cursing in diplomacy unless he does it. 

Duterte took office on June 30th, 2016 and already by September he had racked up a list of undiplomatic insults toward world leaders. You can read such a list here:

https://www.scmp.com/news/asia/southeast-asia/article/2015785/diplomacy-duterte-style-heres-10-philippine-leaders-top

How about these people just be diplomatic and professional and not resort to cursing and insults? Making such remarks results is a false bravado and gives a false impression that something is being done or that those in charge do not like what is happening. But actions speak louder than words and that China has been able to continually encroach upon Philippine territory with absolutely no negative consequences tells us a lot. 

As for diplomatic protests, China does not care one bit. In fact the Philippines needs to respect China's sovereignty over the WPS.

https://globalnation.inquirer.net/195612/china-doubles-down-on-ownership-claim-on-wps-tells-philippines-to-respect-it

Wang Wenbin, Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson, said the Philippines should “stop actions complicating the situation and escalating disputes.”

“China enjoys sovereignty over Nansha Islands, including Zhongye Island and Zhongsha Islands, including Huangyan Island and their adjacent waters, and exercises jurisdiction in relevant waters,” Wenbin said at a press briefing on Monday (April 27).

“We urge the relevant side to respect China’s sovereignty and rights and interests,” he added.

Nansha is the Chinese name for the Spratlys, or Kalayaan Island Group in the Philippines. Zhongye Island is Pag-asa (Thitu) Island, while Huangyan is Panatag (Scarborough) Shoal .

However this situation will be solved it won't be by cursing China or blaming past administrations or by accusing detractors of making "illegal remarks."

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1138804

“As a lawyer and a diplomat respectively, Justice Carpio and Secretary Del Rosario should know better. They do know better. Therefore, they should stop misleading and endangering our people with illegal, impractical, and irresponsible statements,” he added.

What the heck is an illegal statement? Let me consult my copy of 1984 and get back to you.

The second component to look at here is foreign interference, especially economic interference.

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1426890/foreign-grants-aimed-at-swaying-local-policy-an-attack-on-ph-sovereignty-solons

Foreign private organizations may try to influence the Philippines’ national policies through grants awarded to government agencies — which is “an attack” on the country’s sovereignty.

“I called for this investigation to find out the truth,” Savellano said at the hearing. “Did the FDA issue specific and pre-defined policies on e-cigarettes and HTPs in exchange for funding from foreign private organizations? Is this the reason why the FDA in its one-sided and less-than-transparent virtual public hearing could not give the public a real opportunity to flesh out important provisions and requirements for the regulation of e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products?”

For his part, Nograles said: “This is not about the FDA only. The bigger issue here is do we allow government agencies to be influenced by monies coming from foreign private organizations? What we are looking at here is a constitutional violation, an attack on the sovereignty of the Republic of the Philippines, our independence itself. That is the big problem.”

This is a long article about grants to the Philippines regarding the tobacco industry and polices regulating tobacco. The Solons posit that grants are being given based on how policy is written. The main contributor is The Union which operates under Bloomberg Philanthropies. Here is what they say about themselves.

The Bloomberg Initiative to Reduce Tobacco Use aims to reduce the global demand for tobacco through a comprehensive, proven approach that combines policy change with increased public awareness. Since 2006, The Union has co-managed the Bloomberg Initiative to Reduce Tobacco Use Grants Program in partnership with the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids, which awards funds to projects delivering high-impact tobacco control interventions in low-and middle-income countries.

https://theunion.org/our-work/tobacco-control/bloomberg-initiative-to-reduce-tobacco-use-grants-program

Here is what they say about their work in the Philippines:

The Union has been working with Philippines Department of Health since July 2010 to develop and promote legislation and policies that comply with the Philippines' commitments under the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, including Article 6 on implementing tax and price measures to reduce the demand for tobacco. 

In 2013, a significant policy milestone was achieved when the President signed the Sin Tax reform bill into law - Republic Act No. 10351 (RA 10351). The Sin Tax law is a 'double win' for health in the Philippines as the new tax on tobacco has the net effect of raising the consumer price of cigarettes (and hence predicted impact on smoking rates) as well as raising funds for a universal health care system for the poor. This sin tax came into force on 1 January 2013, and was initially projected to raise P33.96 billion (approx. USD $761M) during the first year of implementation of taxes on tobacco and alcohol. This has been exceeded, and in early 2014, the Secretary of Health, announced the Department of Health will receive P48.3 billion (USD 1.08 M) in additional funds generated. 

The Union helped develop the 12 GHW templates which were officially approved by the Secretary of Health on October 2014. The visuals depict a range of health consequences of tobacco use, and are particularly powerful due to their portrayal of 'real life' tobacco victims from the Philippines. Innovative side panels include additional messages about the poisons contained in cigarettes and the back of pack template will contain a website address where smokers can obtain information about quitting. The GHWs come into full effect 20 months from the signing of the templates. 

Local Government Smoke-Free Ordinances continue to be a critical tobacco control strategy in the Philippines as these are able to achieve more comprehensive measures than those prescribed by the national laws. Several Union grantees have been involved in supporting the development and enforcement of local government smoke-free ordinances, including Metropolitan Manila Development Authority (MMDA), FCAP in a series of regional provinces, and via the Civil Service Commission and its effort to raise awareness of and compliance with policy to exclude tobacco industry interference.

https://theunion.org/our-work/tobacco-control/bloomberg-initiative-to-reduce-tobacco-use-grants-program/tobacco-control-in-philippines

It is pretty obvious that The Union is helping to write legislation for the Philippines regarding tobacco regulation. That is indeed very problematic. But the rabbit hole goes much deeper. The Philippines is the recipient of billions in aid from various groups, many of which are CIA fronts. The real question is not, "Are foreign groups influencing the Philippines' legislative process for money," but "which groups are influencing the Philippines' legislative process for money. That is not something I can hope to adequately cover in this blog.

Tuesday, May 11, 2021

Insurgency: CTGs Downfall Inevitable

Stop me if you've heard this one before: the downfall of the CPP-NPA is imminent. How many times  has the AFP has made that proclamation over the years?

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1139448

A ranking military official said on Friday that the snowball of surrenderers led to the dismantling of various communist terrorist groups (CTGs) under the Communist Party of the Philippines-New People’s Army (CPP-NPA).

Major General Alfredo V. Rosario Jr., commander of the 7th Infantry “Kaugnay” Division (7ID), Philippine Army based in Fort Magsaysay, Palayan City, Nueva Ecija, said in an interview that the series of setbacks of the communist groups in Central and Northern Luzon, ranging from the dissolution of its two main units, neutralization of top-ranking leaders, and the withdrawal of support by their exploited supporters, resulted in the collapse of the NPA fronts in the 7th ID's area of responsibility (AOR).

The 7th ID's AOR covers the whole of Ilocos (Region 1) and Central Luzon (Region 3), Abra province, and the municipalities of Besao and Tadian in Mountain Province.

The continuous collapse of the CTG leadership and the influx of surrenderers from their ranks were manifestations that the terrorist groups' downfall is inevitable, Rosario said.

Records showed that the 7ID dismantled the Komiteng Larangang Gerilya (KLG) Caraballo during the first quarter of 2019.

Last year, the 7th ID recorded 192 members of the communist terrorist groups who surrendered while 2,172 members of underground movement organizations (UGMOs) withdrew their support.

This year, Rosario noted that at least 38 surrenderers were recorded with 63 UGMO members who abandoned their affiliation with CTGs.

“We unmask the CTG fronts' deceptive scheme of recruitment through massive information dissemination in schools and conflict-affected barangays to protect the vulnerable sectors from being exploited by the rebels,” he said.

He cited that social media has been one of the most effective online platforms to expose the truth behind the CTGs.

Now, that is rather interesting. Of the thousands who have surrendered only 192 were actually members of the NPA. The rest were mass supporters. All will no doubt receive thousands in cash, housing, and job training skills.


Major General Alfredo V. Rosario Jr. says social media has been very effective in exposing the CTGs (communist terrorist group.) That means the AFP is posting memes. Indeed the war against the NPA has many fronts with Facebook being the latest. So how does the NPA recruit? Through agitating the public.


https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1139058

Virgilio Quisto, a former rebel, said preying on people who feel helpless is the expertise of CPP-NPA for them to rise in arms against the government.

"Agitation as a strategy to keep discontent high,” Quisto said in his confession included in the information which he shared before testifying on government’s goodwill to returnees like him after deciding to go back to the fold of the law.

Among the issues raised to agitate the people against government evolved on social issues including land reform, palm oil, poverty and alleged militarization.

He said the CPP-NPA’s agitation strategy has special training and admitted he once worked as a key agitator and leader of the underground movement.

"Then, it was always easy to hit the raw nerve of the poor people, because we trained for that. Now, however, no matter how good the agitation is, somehow the government can easily get and appease the sentiments of the people," Quisto said in front of hundreds of land reform beneficiaries accepting their Certificates of Land Ownership Awards and Agricultural Free Patents during the service caravan in San Vicente village in Trinidad, Bohol on April 27.

Quisto's family received 2.14 hectares of land which they have cultivated since they occupied a portion of the government-sequestered lands of the abandoned Bohol Cattle Corporation.

Land reform is a serious issue in the Philippines. It is certainly not a small thing for farmers to be able to own their land and profit from it. His statement is totally ironic as he made it while receiving 2.14 hectares from the government. At least he's got his.


He goes on to say that he was disillusioned with the CPP-NPA's broken promises. Was he also starving?


https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1139229

Two ranking New People’s Army (NPA) leaders operating in the areas of Agusan del Sur and parts of Agusan del Norte surrendered on May 3 to the Army’s 23rd Infantry Battalion (23IB), a military official said Wednesday.

In a statement, Lt. Col. Julius Cesar C. Paulo, 23IB commander, identified the NPA officer only as alias 'Hajie' or 'Saed,' 36, the front secretary of Guerrilla Front 88 of the North Central Mindanao Command (NCMRC) of the NPA.

The other surrenderer, Paulo said, is alias 'May-may or Wena,' 31, political officer and political instructor of the same NPA unit.

Paulo said the two surrendered at the headquarters of 23IB in Barangay Alubihid, Buenavista, Agusan del Norte on May 3, and handed over a 1911 .45-caliber pistol with one magazine and five ammunition.

Hajie could no longer endure the hunger and difficulties they experienced inside the movement, he said.

“We do not have enough supply of food as most of our supporters in communities in Agusan del Norte and Agusan del Sur has already cut ties with the movement. Securing food supply is among the difficulties that GF 88 is facing. Most of the members and fighters in GF 88 are demoralized due to the difficult situation,” Hajie was quoted in the dialect as saying.

He said he also wished to reunite with his family, especially his children.

Paulo welcomed the two surrenderers as he recognized their "bravery in deciding to leave the rebel movement".

“The testimony of alias Hajie indicates the disintegration of the NPA movement in Agusan del Norte due to the difficulties they now face as the consequences of the mass surrenders of their supporters in communities,” Paulo said.

Isn't it rather odd that only two ranking members of this particular NPA group, GF 88, surrendered while the rest stayed behind? If most of the members of their group are demoralized then why did they stay behind? Did no one speak openly of surrendering? These two will certainly be availing of the government's bountiful E-CLIP program and receive cash, housing, and maybe even some land. 


Another reason some NPA fighters are surrendering is because of the "meaningless revolution."


https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1139601

A regular member of the Communist Party of the Philippines-New People’s Army (CPP-NPA) and nine Milisya ng Bayan (MB) members surrendered to the government last May 6.

"Agot" (not his real name), 24, married, resident of Barangay Molina, Tubungan, Iloilo, gave up to the community support program (CSP) team under the Army's 61st Infantry Battalion (61IB) based in the municipality of Miagao.

“Hardship and the realization of this meaningless revolution pushed alias 'Agot' to yield,” a statement of the 301st Infantry Brigade said on Saturday.

"Agot" was assigned under the Sibat platoon of the Southern Front (SF) of the Kilusang Rehiyon–Panay (KR-P).

Meanwhile, the MBs, supporters of the SF of KR-P, were from Tubungan and Miagao.

“Aside from being a force multiplier, these individuals act as the eyes and ears of the enemy in their barangays to report on presence and movement of government security forces; and offer logistical support to the NPA,” the statement added.

With their surrender, they also gave up seven homemade shotguns with ammunition and magazine, a homemade caliber 45 pistol, and a homemade caliber 38 with ammunition.

One wonders if these people really know what they are fighting for. Have they read the CASER agreement? Do they really think the government would ever agree to such a thing?


We have all heard about how the NTF-ELCAC is necessary to fight the communists. They do this by giving huge grants to communities which are free of CPP-NPA influence so they can build roads, schools, and other necessary infrastructure. But the NTF-ELCAC is not the only organization involved in such activities.


https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1139214

The ongoing construction of an 11.85-kilometer Sta. Maria-Mallig-Upper Atok farm-to-market road (FMR) in Flora, Apayao is seen to boost economic livelihood and help end insurgency.

The PHP195 million project is under the World Bank-supported Philippine Rural Development Project (PRDP) with a 10 percent counterpart fund from the provincial government of Apayao.

The road is expected to benefit at least three farming villages of Flora such as Barangays Santa Maria, Mallig and Upper Atok.

The mission of the PRDP is:

The Philippine Rural Development Project is a six-year (6) project designed to establish the government platform for a modern, climate-smart and market-oriented agri-fishery sector. PRDP will partner with the LGUs and the private sector in providing key infrastructure, facilities, technology, and information that will raise incomes, productivity, and competitiveness in the countryside.

http://prdp.da.gov.ph/about-us/overview/

If roads are the antidote to the insurgency then there should be more roads being constructed throughout the nation. There is no reason farmers should have a difficult time getting their produce to the market.


Unity will also bring an end to the insurgency says one commander.


https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1138914

Amid calls for the defunding of the National Task Force to End Local Communist Armed Conflict (NTF-ELCAC), a military official called for unity on Monday for a "final push" to end the communist insurgency.

“It is then our prayer and hopes that we set aside politics and personal agenda for a while and work together as one in this final push to end the insurgency. This we ask in the name of all those in the frontlines enduring immeasurable sacrifices away from their homes and the thousands who were scarred and died fighting this communist insurgency,” Maj. Gen. Ernesto Torres Jr., commander of the 10th Infantry Division (10ID), said in a statement. 

As one of the prime movers on the campaign against the CTGs, Torres said they have a good chance to catch up, reverse the tide to favor the government, sustain the gains, and finally defeat the communist rebel movement.

“For the first time, the CPP-NPA-NDF has been given a bitter pill that they struggle to swallow. The NTF ELCAC provides the mechanism and programs to finally put an end to the communist insurgency. And this must be understood and realized by all peace-loving Filipinos,” he said.

Final push, put an end to the communist insurgency, sustain the gains, we've heard this all before. And the AFP has been wrong every single time in predicting the demise of the NPA.

https://thediplomat.com/2021/02/an-end-in-sight-for-the-philippines-maoist-insurgency/

As Marco Valbuena, the information officer of the Central Committee of the CPP said himself, “[w]e must remember that through the past decades, all of the AFP’s past predictions of crushing the NPA have all been proven wrong.” The NPA’s ability to survive is not only down to factors like the enduring appeal of communism among rural communities and the Philippines’ indigenous peoples (see my recent article), but also because there are clear incentives for the government and the AFP to prevent its total collapse. As long as sustained conflict is mutually beneficial for all sides involved, it is difficult to see an end to the insurgency by 2022.

I would encourage all to read that article in The Diplomat. The author takes a good look at the AFP's claims that the insurgency is on the way out and shows how they don't match reality.

Monday, May 10, 2021

The God Culture: The Scholars Speak

Timothy Jay Schwab of the God Culture hates scholars. At least that is what he says in all his videos and writes in his books. Time and again Tim will harangue the scholars who operate in a  false paradigm sitting in willing ignorance denying the truth that he has unveiled by reading their books. That's right. Tim uses the works of scholars to flesh out his claims. For this reason I wrote to several scholars whose material he uses and asked them what they thought of Tim's conclusions. Do I even need to reveal the answer? I know Tim won't care a hill of beans for what's about to follow but anyone with half a brain who is really interested in truth and not just confirming their own opinions would do well to carefully read what these men have to say.

First up is Professor Adrian Horridge. Before I came along to fact check Timothy he had never heard of Professor Adrian Horridge. Instead he had quoted him secondhand from former Supreme Court Justice Carpio who utilized a quote from Horridge to prove that the Philippines has domain over the South China Sea or West Philippine Sea. Here is what he writes in his book about Horridge's research.


"Theories that Austronesian rigs were derived from those of the Indian Ocean, or even from Egupt, are mistaken because the Austronesions had left Mainland Asia long before contacts spread eastwards.” -Professor Adrian Horridge

We had one question the "belief" of Adrian Horridge yet his "belief" is clear here and Justice Carpio was accurate in his rendering of such.

Here is what Carpio wrote and it is to be found on page 136 of "The Search for King Solomon's Treasure."

Professor Adrian Horridge believes that by 200 BCE, Austronesian sailors were regularly carrying cloves and cinnamon to India and Sri Lanka, and perhaps even as far as the coast of Africa in sailboats with outriggers. -Supreme Court Justice Antonio T. Carpio
It should be noted that Carpio is using Horridge to prove that the WPS historically belongs to the Philippines.

It was I who questioned what Horridge meant in this paper because he uses the word "perhaps" in suggesting that Austronesians  were sailing to India and Africa by 200 B.C.
Annual trade between China and India through the Malacca Straits had opened by about 200 BC. Perhaps by that time Austronesian sailors were regularly carrying cloves and cinnamon to India and Sri Lanka, and perhaps even as far as the coast of Africa in boats with outriggers.

https://philippinefails.blogspot.com/2020/03/god-culture-does-timothy-schwab-have.html

Perhaps is not a definite "is." Also it was apparent that Tim was drawing conclusions from Horridge's paper that were not supported by the text. Most notably he wrote that Filipinos were sailing balangay's directly to Egypt to engage in trade. Horridge writes nothing of the sort and uses the broad term Austronesians and not the specific term Filipinos. Who can clear up this mess better than Adrian Horridge himself?

I sent Professor Horridge a PDF file of pages 135-137 of Timothy Jay Schwab's book "The Search for King Solomon's Treasure where Tim quotes Horridge as proof that Filipinos sailed to Egypt for trade in 200 B.C.  His response is as follows:


Dear David, 
The Austronesians were certainly carrying cargoes with outrigger boats as far as the Red Sea, and the coast of Africa near Zanzibar, and they colonized Madagascar before 200BC,
Traces of cinnamon can be found in Egyptian Mummies from  2000 BC,
The trade hugged the coasts of India and Persia, then via Basra and Palmyra. 

The Romans imported the laxative Cassia from the Malabar coast of India etc, etc.
and there is no shortage of evidence about pepper, ginger etc..
However, the argument has no strength because there were others besides the Philippino Austronesians, who perhaps went no further than the Malacca Straits.
From the 8th to 11th centuries the Empire of Sri Vijaya ruled Sumatra and Malaysia
and their ships dominated the trade through the south China Sea as far as China,
and they carried the seaborne trade for the Chinese, who called them the 'kun lun'.

They were followed, until about the 14th century, by the maritime empire of the Chams, 
also Austronesians, who were  based at Hue upon the coast of present Vietnam.
They travelled as far as Japan and India.

The arguments based on this history are all rubbish.
The seas were free for all until coastal limits of about 12 miles were set, with  maritime laws that were recognized internationally.
Later, limits were set at 200 miles in some places, but it was always recognized that international shipping could pass freely  except in times of war.

Actually, all fishing should be banned in the huge area where 6 nations compete, so that the fish stocks can recover.
The question is not "Where can the fishermen go"
There are too many fishermen and the fish are overfished.

Thank you
Adrian Horridge

Two things to note here. Professor Horridge says that Austronesians were "certainly" sailing to Africa by 200 B.C. That means I was wrong that Horridge was merely speculating. But there is nothing wrong with being cautious rather than jumping to unwarranted conclusions. The conclusions that Tim and Carpio makes based on his paper Horridge calls "rubbish" and of "no strength" because there were others Austronesians besides Filipinos sailing afar. Professor Horridge also notes that not all Austronesians made it past the Malacca Straits.

Next up is Professor Frank Romer whose translation of Pomponious Mela Tim uses. He does not outright call the man a fraud and a propagandist but from the notes  where those who do not teach Tim's doctrine are called such it is clear he does think Romer is in fact a fraud and propagandist.


I have written elsewhere how Timothy completely misinterprets Mela and contradicts the notes Romer makes to the text. My email to Romer was pretty straightforward. I asked two questions.

1. What do you think of the claim that the islands of Chryse and Argyre are actually the Philippines being Luzon and Mindanao respectively? Is this a viable identification?

2. Is there any evidence that the Greeks cirucmnaviagted Africa to trade with the Philippines or Chryse or whatever Chryse may be?

Here is his response.

As to your question 1: As you will know Chryse and Argyre are problematic in the ancient record, and you could write an article about them if you wanted to do so. I looked at the text in the picture, which you sent previously, but which is very unclear, and I managed to make out some of it. I think it very unlikely that Chryse and Argyre are Luzon and Mindinao for some of the reasons given at the bottom of the page you sent. In addition, I know of no evidence that suggests otherwise. You may already know that Ptolemy puts Argyre as the capital of Java and sees Chryse as the Golden Peninsula of Malaysia.

 

As to your question 2: I know of no such evidence on this question either. The earliest info about the circumnavigation of Africa indicates that the Egyptians under Necho II did it from East to West, but that’s it, with no indication that any kind of trade followed. There is no evidence, material or literary, known to me that the Greeks themselves circumnavigated Africa and traded directly with the Philippines.

 

I hope this helps.

 

Best wishes,

Frank Romer

Let's deal with the second answer first.  According to this man who is a professor of ancient history there is no evidence that the Greeks circumnavigated Africa to trade with the Philippines. Now Tim will likely latch on the the words "known to me"as if Romer is just ignorant of evidence he does not know about. But Tim never provides any evidence to prove that the Greeks sailed around Africa to trade with the Philippines or vice versa. He simply makes deductive claims based on zero actual evidence "material or literary." In fact when I asked for further information about this claim Tim was dismissive and refused to provide anything which could substantiate his claim.

As for the first question, Romer says it is unlikely that "Chryse and Argyre are Luzon and Mindanao for some of the reasons given at the bottom of the page you sent." I do not know what he means because the page I sent is the page above where Timothy makes mincemeat out of Mela and calls anyone who does not follow him a propagandist.

I did know that Ptolemy idneitifes Chryse as the Malaysian Peninsula but I did not know that he places Argyre as the capital of Java. But here it is on an older map.

https://www.raremaps.com/gallery/detail/59685op/southeast-asia-fries

Lest Tim object by saying that is Argentea and not Argyre I challenge him to prove, from the Geography, that Ptolemy did not put Argyre as the capitol of Java or that he did not refer to Chryse as the Malaysian Peninsula. Remember, nu-uh is not an answer.

Third of all is noted Jubilees scholar James VanderKam. Aside from listing VanderKam's commentary as a source of note in his edition of Jubilees there is no indication that Tim actually cites VanderKam in his videos or books. I wrote to him asking his opinion concerning Tim's map of Noah' s division of the earth.


 

Here is his response:


Mr. Roxas,

My research into the map section of Jubilees gives me no reason for thinking that Ham's territory stretched as far as this commentary claims.  His territory is in Africa.

Best wishes,

Jim VanderKam

It's not as detailed an analysis as I would have liked but it gets straight to the point. Tim is wrong about Ham's allotment of Australia and South America. We can infer from that terse statement that if VanderKam read Tim's annotated Book of Jubilees he would find much fault.

Now, these are only the opinions of three scholars. I would have like to have had more expert testimony but it was not to be. Many of the people Tim cites are long dead and a few others whom he does not cite but are experts in the things Tim writes about, such as the Dead Sea scrolls, did not respond. I am omitting the testimony of Professor Fabrizio Lelli who is an expert on Abraham Farrisol who Tim claims places the lost tribes in the Philippines. You can read that at this link

As I wrote in the introduction Tim is not going to care what these people say. He has leveled so much vituperative invective in the pages of his book that it makes for hard reading. Who wants to read every other sentence, "We are right, scholars are wrong, and they are also lying frauds and propagandists?" But Tim actually does care what these men and other experts have to say. In fact he writes the following:

It is time for this to be taken seriously by those in authority, those in academia and those in the church.

https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=690346041525416&id=376627072897316

It's totally disingenuous for Tim to lambast men who have devoted their life to a particular field or even book such as Jubilees and then say that those men should take him seriously. What Tim should really do is send copies of his books to VanderKam, Romer, and other experts in the field. Jose Eleazar Bersales is an archeologist in the Philippines. Why not send him a copy? He teaches at the University of San Carlos in Cebu. Here is his information page. Hopefully in the future we can read a review of Tim's book by an expert in ancient history, Philippine history, or second temple Judaism and the Dead Sea scrolls. 

Friday, May 7, 2021

Retards in the Government 205

 It's your weekly compendium of foolishness and corruption in the Philippine government.


 

https://www.manilatimes.net/2021/04/30/news/regions/ncotabato-vice-mayor-escapes-slay-attempt/868587/

Vice Mayor Cristobal Cadungon of Antipas town, this province, has blamed politics for an assassination attempt on his life at 1:44 in the morning last Wednesday, April 28, when his family’s residence was showered with bullets.

Before the shooting, according to the vice mayor, an unidentified person could be seen trespassing in front of his house on the evenings of April 19 to 21 based on a closed-circuit television (CCTV) footage.

Cadungon immediately reported the incidents to the police on April 23 but the latter allegedly did not act on the matter.

Fortunately for him, the vice mayor said, he was lying down on his bed during the gunfire and as a result, he and his wife did not sustain any injury.

Only the windows of the house were damaged by the bullets.

Another attempted assassination of a Vice Mayor.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1138675

A police officer was nabbed for alleged extortion in an entrapment operation in Cagayan province on Friday.
 
Brig. Gen. Thomas Frias, chief of the Philippine National Police-Integrity Monitoring and Enforcement Group (PNP-IMEG, identified the suspect as Staff Sgt. Arphie Bryan Tuliao. 

He was arrested during an entrapment operation along V8 Gas Station located along Barangay Camasi in Peñablanca town.

He added the operation stemmed from the IMEG Luzon Field Unit’s intelligence report that Tuliao is asking PHP40,000 each from the four suspects who were earlier arrested during a police operation against illegal gambling, particularly "sabong" or cockfighting.

Tuliao allegedly demanded the amount in exchange for not filing the case in court against the offenders. Frias added that it was later reduced to PHP12,000 after several transactions among the parties involved.

Another cop busted for extortion. He demanded money in exchange for not filing a case against four men caught in illegal cockfighting.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1138701

A mayor in Maguindanao who maintained a private armed group (PAG) has voluntarily surrendered, along with his men and firearms, to the police in the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (BARMM).

“This is to serve as an example to other PAGs in the Pagalungan area,” Mayor Salik Mamasabulod of Pagalungan, Maguindanao said in a phone interview with reporters here Saturday.

On Friday afternoon, Mamasabulod dissolved his PAG and surrendered to the police.

A mayor and his private army surrendered to the police in the BARMM.  No word on what will happen to them.

https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=tl&tl=en&u=https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/news/ulatfilipino/785879/enforcer-na-naglabas-ng-patalim-habang-nanghuhuli-ng-jeepney-driver-sinuspinde-at-iniimbestigahan/story/

A member of the Public Order and Safety Division (POSD) in Baguio City has been suspended and is under investigation after he pulled out a knife while arresting a motorist.


In a report on GMA News "24 Oras Weekend" on Saturday, it was said that the video of an argument between a jeep driver and POSD personnel went viral on Facebook.

The POSD chief said the jeep was illegally parked on the street.

The POSD personnel were about to remove the license plate from the jeep and give the driver a ticket when one of their personnel immediately pulled out a knife.

The driver quickly entered the jeep, took a pipe and then chased the enforcer.

The driver and enforcer eventually confronted and reconciled, where the driver admitted he had made a mistake.

The enforcer was suspended while the incident was being investigated. He refused to give a statement.

A traffic enforcer pulled out a knife and ran after a jeepney driver. They later reconciled but the enforcer is now being investigated.

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1426295/masked-gunmen-kill-capiz-town-administrator

Two masked gunmen shot dead a Capiz town administrator in Roxas City, the provincial capital, on Sunday afternoon.

John Heredia, a long-time and well-known journalist in Capiz before he was appointed administrator of Pilar town, succumbed to multiple gunshot wounds.

Heredia, 54, had just come out from a hardware store in Barangay Lawa-an when he was repeatedly shot as he was about to board his vehicle.

He was executive producer and host of the cable television program “Abri Aga.” He also wrote for community newspapers.

The National Union of Journalists of the Philippines said Heredia was a former national director and chairperson of its Capiz chapter.

Lawyer Criselda Azarcon-Heredia, the victim’s widow, confirmed that her husband had received death threats but did not elaborate.

“Let the police investigation (take) its course,” she told reporters in Roxas City.

Criselda, a member of the National Union of People’s Lawyers, escaped unharmed from an armed attack in September 2019 in Sigma town in Capiz after her vehicle was fired upon by assailants in another vehicle.

A former journalist appointed as town administrator was assassinated by unknown gunmen. His wife said he had received death threats and she herself survived an assassination attempt in 2019. Police are not sure if the two events are related but it's highly likely.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1138865

A personnel of the Philippine Coast Guard (PCG) and three others were arrested in separate anti-drug operations in this city and in Zamboanga del Sur, a top police official said Monday.

Brig. Gen. Ronaldo Genaro Ylagan, Police Regional Office-9 (PRO-9) director, identified the arrested PCG personnel as Zulpicar Tan, 32, a native of Tawi-Tawi province, who was arrested in a buy-bust operation around 12:30 a.m. Monday in Barangay Cawit here.

Tan yielded some PHP2,500 worth of suspected shabu and PHP200 marked money, police said.

A member of the Philippine Coast Guard has been busted for drugs.

https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=tl&u=https://digicastnegros.com/punong-barangay-sa-dauin-negros-orienal-gin-patay-sa-sulod-sang-barangay-hall/&prev=search&pto=aue

The incumbent barangay captain of Bagacay in Dauin town in Negros Oriental died after gunmen entered the barangay hall this morning.

The victim was Chief Barangay Stephen Bandoquillo Alam.

During the Dauin PNP investigation, Alam was immediately stabbed in the head by three unidentified persons at the barangay hall and shot several times in the head.

A barangay captain was killed inside the barangay hall.