Friday, March 20, 2020

Retards in the Government 146

It's your weekly compendium of foolishness and corruption in the Philippine government. 


https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2020/03/13/2000557/workers-provinces-advised-live-metro-manila-coping-mechanism-dti
Department of Trade and Industry Secretary Ramon Lopez on Friday said that a possible solution for workers from the provinces who will be displaced by the impending lockdown in Metro Manila is to just “find a place” to live or rent in the area for the time being. 
(The workers can rent for the meantime in order to lessen the movement of people. In that way, the flow of people to and from Metro Manila would also be limited.)
This is ridiculous advice.  Metro Manila is basically under lockdown and commuters are told to rent a place in the city to avoid hassles. Do I really need to highlight the how asinine this is? People probably cant afford it and if the city is infected who wants to live there?
https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1096577
To cushion the impact of coronavirus disease 2019 (Covid-19) threat to local tourism industry, the province of Cebu will launch a program to spur local travel and bookings in luxury hotels and establishments at extremely low rates. 
Governor Gwendolyn Garcia on Thursday said the new program dubbed as “Suroy Suroy Alang sa Sugbo” is a reverse version of the already existing Suroy Suroy Sugbo, a famous tour junket organized by the provincial capitol to promote countryside tourism. 
With the new program, domestic tourists from the countryside will be given a chance to explore the Metro Cebu area and provided access to luxury hotels and resorts, shopping malls, restaurants, and day tour experiences. 
Garcia said the program is meant to lessen the “adverse and painful effect” of the Covid-19 pandemic that has hit the local tourism industry, and to allow resort and hotel workers to keep their jobs in these trying times. 
Occupancy rate of hotels and resorts, especially in Metro Cebu area, has dipped from 90 percent to 40 to 30 percent, with the diminishing tourist arrivals, she said.
All these cities going on "lockdown" to stop the spread of the disease and Cebu is trying to attract tourists!


https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1096609
A village councilor allegedly into illegal drug peddling was arrested by anti-narcotics and police operatives during an anti-drug operation in Columbio, Sultan Kudarat on Friday. 
Director Naravy Duquiatan of the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency (PDEA) in Region 12 (Soccsksargen) identified the suspect as Michael Tamles, 35, a three-term village councilor of Barangay Sucob in Columbio town. 
“Tamles belonged to the top ten priority target-listed personalities of PDEA in Sultan Kudarat,” Duquiatan said.
Another village councillor selling drugs.

Joint police and anti-narcotics agents arrested a former police officer during a drug sting operation in Pikit, North Cotabato on Saturday morning. 
Director Naravy Duquiatan of the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency-Region 12 (PDEA-12) led the operation with Pikit police personnel in Barangay Poblacion, Pikit, North Cotabato, that resulted in the arrest of Motin Kidap Jr., 41. 
“Confiscated from the suspect were 16 small sachets of suspected shabu with an estimated value of PHP8,160, the PHP500 marked money, cellular phone, and the motorcycle he used during the transaction," Duquiatan said in a statement. 
Kidap, a target-listed drug personality, is a former police officer assigned with the Police Regional Office in the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao. 
He was declared absent without official leave (AWOL) following allegations of his links to illegal drugs, Duquiatan said.
Another PNP officer involved in the drug trade. Isolated incident?  Bad egg? Just business as usual.


https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1242013/village-councilor-3-others-nabbed-in-bicol-buy-busts
A village councilor and three other suspects were nabbed in separate buy-bust operations in Catanduanes and Camarines Sur on Saturday. 
Col. Paul Abay, Catanduanes police chief, said in a report that Pio Dela Cruz, 44, was arrested in Barangay San Miguel, Panganiban town at around 10:20 a.m. 
Dela Cruz, a councilor of the said village, was included in the regional and national watchlist of illegal drug personalities. 
Recovered from him were 28 sachets of suspected crystal meth, locally known as shabu, and a .22-caliber firearm with three live bullets.
Another village councilor busted on drug charges.
https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1243120/cebu-city-cop-nabbed-for-involvement-in-illegal-numbers-game
A policeman was arrested in Cebu City by anti-scalawag unit of the Philippine National Police (PNP) due to his alleged involvement in the operations of “swertres,” an illegal numbers game. 
Staff Sergeant Carlito Tinoy was arrested by operatives of the PNP Integrity Monitoring and Enforcement Group (IMEG) Visayas Field Unit, assisted by other local police units, in an operation launched in Sitio Sudlon, Barangay Lahug at about 8:45 p.m. on Sunday.
“We have arrested a police non-commissioned officer who has been the subject of persistent reports regarding his involvement in the rampant operations of ‘swertres,’ a banned numbers’ game in his neighborhood despite the order of [PNP chief] Gen. [Archie] Gamboa to stop all forms of illegal gambling activities and the full implementation of the ‘no-take policy’ across the country,” IMEG chief Col. Ronald Lee said Monday.
 
He said the 41-year-old suspect is a member of the Police Regional Office 7’s (Central Visayas) 701st Regional Mobile Force Battalion. Also arrested during the operation was Tinoy’s alleged cohort identified as Joven Igam. 
Confiscated from the accused policeman were a total of P4,000 in different denominations, which were believed to be proceeds of his illegal gambling activity, a calculator, pen, and a tally sheet. Igam meanwhile yielded P500, a pen, and three pieces of stapled tally sheets.
A PNP officer involved in illegal gambling.


https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1096740
Police are hot on the trail of armed men who ambushed and killed a municipal councilor of Maguindanao and a companion along the stretch of the highway here on Sunday. 
Lt. Col. Bernard Tayong, speaking for the North Cotabato police, identified the slain councilor as Ruben "Udzi" Mindalagat of Datu Montawal, Maguindanao.
“The councilor died on the spot,” Tayong said. 
His companion, Mokamad Mindalagat, was critically injured and later pronounced dead on arrival at Albutra hospital situated about 20 meters away from the ambush scene. 
The two were heading home in Datu Montawal aboard a black Honda Fit vehicle (MGE-382) driven by the town official from Kabacan public market where they bought food supplies when ambushed at 10:30 a.m.
Another LGU official assassinated. 

https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2020/03/16/2001322/fact-check-panelo-says-korea-did-total-lockdown-eating-bananas-and-gargling-prevents-covid-19
Panelo first said that the Philippines would take Korea's lead in implementing a total lockdown. 
"What Secretary Año and other members of the Cabinet are considering is what [South] Korea carried out. They did a total lockdown. That is what we'll present to the president," he said in Filipino.  
As of this writing, South Korea has not implemented such a measure.  
Instead, the East Asian country initiated a comprehensive testing drive to supplement its already-advanced healthcare system. 
Duterte's mouthpiece also shared a few ways the general public could protect themselves from transmitting the virus. 
These included eating bananas often and gargling salt water.  
"I read a few things about how to destroy or contain the virus. You know, even without me knowing it, I've been fond of bananas," he said.  
"They I saw on the internet, that bananas are a good way to fight [viruses]. So here I am, eating bananas every day." 
"It has been my habit to gargle salt water. Whenever I feel a bit of colds, I do it. [Health Secretary Francisco] Duque said that's okay. Even gargling with Listerine," Panelo went on.  
He explained that this was because the virus would first enter the body via the throat. 
Panelo may have been referring to a graphic that circulated social media earlier this week with these same claims.  
“Corona virus before it reaches the lungs it remains in the throat for four days and at this time the person begins to cough and have throat pains,” the graphic read.  
"If he drinks water a lot and gargling with warm water & salt or vinegar eliminates the virus. Spread this information because you can save someone with this information." 
This is not necessarily true.
Presidential spokesman Panelo is literally disseminating fake news from his podium.


https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/news/nation/729945/why-duterte-keeps-saying-vee-rus-despite-being-corrected/story/
President Rodrigo Duterte on Monday addressed criticism that he repeatedly mispronounced the word “virus” in his public speeches. 
In a televised address, Duterte said he deliberately called the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) “vee-rus” because he was angry at the unseen enemy, which causes fatal respiratory illness, especially in older people.
Duterte is angry at the virus so he is calling it by the wrong name.  Take that you stupid virus!


https://cebudailynews.inquirer.net/295434/former-chairperson-of-cebu-city-parks-and-playgrounds-surrenders-to-police-for
A former official of the Cebu City Government surrendered to police after an arrest warrant was issued against him in violation of the Social Security Law (Republic Act. No. 8282). 
Dr. Librado Macaraya, ex-chairperson of the Cebu City’s Commission on Parks and Playgrounds, posted bail on Wednesday, March 18, 2020, after he voluntarily surrendered before enforcers from the Cebu City Mobile Force Company (CMFC). 
Police Lieutenant Colonel Randy Korret, said Macaraya is among the 11 people who surrendered to CMFC during their three-day operation against loose firearms. 
“Our intensified operation led to some of those to voluntarily turn themselves in, like this doctor, who told us that he is aware of a warrant of arrest issued against him,” said Korret in Tagalog. 
Aside from Macaraya, Korret also said a traffic enforcer from Mandaue City, identified as Leumel Cortes and who claimed to be a nephew of Mandaue City Mayor Jonas Cortes, also surrendered himself to authorities.
It is not clear if Dr. Macaraya was in possession of illegal firearms or how he violated RA 8282. 

Finance Secretary Carlos Dominguez III on Tuesday explained why the lion’s share or P14 billion of the P27.1-billion spending plan to combat the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) and provide economic relief to affected industries has been earmarked for the tourism sector. 
Under the Duterte administration’s economic team’s “war chest,” various programs of the Department of Tourism (DOT) will be given P14 billion to support the tourism industry.  The funds will be sourced from the Tourism Infrastructure and Enterprise Zone Authority (TIEZA).  
Meanwhile, an additional P3.1 billion will be mobilized to contribute directly to efforts to stop the spread of COVID-19, including the acquisition of test kits. The funds came from the Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corp. (Pagcor), Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office (PCSO) and the Asian Development Bank (ADB). 
Asked why bulk of the government’s package is allotted for tourism, Dominguez told GMA News Online “because as of now, the tourism sector is the most affected.” 
For his part, Budget Secretary Wendel Avisado said the allotments presented by the economic team are “tentative allocations.” 
“We will shift the funds where it is more needed, whenever required and/or necessary,” Avisado told GMA News Online. 
“What we are simply saying is that funds are available when needed,” the Budget chief said.
P14 billion to the department of tourism and only P3.1 billion to direct efforts to stop the spread of the coronavirus. It's always tourism!  What about the tourism industry? Every single time there is an emergency some kind.  Even DFA secretary Locsin can't impose necessary measures to stop the entry of foreigners without consulting the tourism secretary!


https://news.abs-cbn.com/news/03/19/20/philippines-stops-visa-issuance-bans-incoming-foreigners-as-covid-19-cases-rise
Its as if without tourists the Philippines economy would collapse! We will see how it goes during the next month.

Thursday, March 19, 2020

Picture of the Week: Epal In The Time Of Coronavirus

Ever since Duterte declared Metro Manila under a community quarantine each city and province of the Philippines has fallen one by one until now the entire country is practically paralyzed. No boats, no buses, no airplanes, no taxis, no jeepneys, no exit!  Stay inside. Keep your distance.  Don't shake hands or hug. Wear a face mask. Funny no one is saying don't have sex! I bet in nine months there will be a baby boom worldwide. That is love in the time of coronavirus.

As for epal in the time of coronavirus?  Take a look:



What is a Congressman Greg Gasataya awning doing at the hospital's emergency entrance next to the inflatable tent that will be used to isolate any patients with the coronavirus? I took this picture on March 18th. Two days prior it was not there!


https://www.facebook.com/bacolodcitypio/posts/891907061306116?__tn__=-R
So why is it there? How did it get there?  That is bad form. Congressman Greg Gasataya might not know about it but this awning does not look good next to the inflatable isolation tent.

Wednesday, March 18, 2020

Does The Philippines Need The World To Survive As A Nation?

"Do we need America to survive as a nation?", Duterte asked on February 26th, 2020. The context of the question was Duterte's attempt to justify his rash decision to abrogate the VFA but the substance underlying this question affects every area of the Philippines' existence as a nation. Presidential spokesman Panleo clarified Duterte's remarks by saying:
“As the President said, it is time we stand on our own feet,” Panelo said. “The President is correct, we have to strengthen our own resources,” he added.
https://globalnation.inquirer.net/185308/panelo-duterte-wants-no-more-military-alliances-with-other-countries-for-ph-to-stand-on-its-own
Again the context was defending Duterte's justification for abrogating the VFA yet divorced from that context the assertion is rather striking. The Philippines must stand on its own two feet and strengthen their resources. But the reality is that the while spirit may be willing the flesh is very weak. Rather than limit the question to America let's expand it.  Let's ask, "Does the Philippines need the world to survive as a nation?"

https://businessmirror.com.ph/2020/01/14/phl-ends-decade-as-worlds-top-rice-importer/
THE Philippines started and ended the previous decade as the world’s top rice importer, with the country formally overtaking China as the top buyer of the staple last year, based on data from the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA). 
Data from the USDA showed that the Philippines’s rice imports in 2019 rose to an all-time high of 3.2 million metric tons (MMT), making the country the top buyer of imported rice last year. 
In its first monthly forecast report, the USDA revealed that the Philippines has “soared to become the top global importer” of rice as its total purchases last year surpassed China’s 2.4 MMT. China has been the world’s top rice importer since 2013. 
With the USDA’s latest report, the Philippines has officially surpassed its previous record of 2.5 MMT in 2008, the height of the global rice price crisis. The Philippines was also the top rice importer that same year. 
The last time the Philippines was regarded as the world’s top buyer of rice was in 2010, when it imported 2.4 MMT, historical USDA data showed. 
The latest USDA figures showed the Philippines may still be the world’s top importer of rice this year, as total volume is projected to reach 2.7 MMT, higher than China’s estimated imports of 2.3 MMT. 
The Department of Agriculture (DA) earlier said the country’s total rice imports last year reached 3 MMT following the enactment of the rice trade liberalization (RTL) law, which eased the requirements for importing rice.
For all the many decades of the Department of Agriculture squawking about rice self-sufficiency the Philippines is no closer to that goal. They began and ended the decade as the world's top rice importer. Reaching this goal was made possible by the rice tariffication law which resulted in a P68 billion loss for local farmers. If the Philippines did not import rice there would not be enough to feed everyone.

https://www.philstar.com/business/2018/05/31/1820097/philippines-remains-worlds-call-center-capital-ccap
“The Philippines continues to be the largest location for delivery of contact services in the rest of the world. So as an outsourcing destination, we continue to dominate the No. 1 spot as a country. There is no close No. 2. We continue to be No. 1 in terms of market share,” Contact Center Association of the Philippines (CCAP) chairman Benedict Hernandez said. 
Citing data from Texas-based global consulting and research firm The Everest Group, CCAP said the Philippines is seen to continue being the biggest contact center market this 2018, taking 16 to 18 percent of the total outsourced services globally. 
This again will put the country ahead of India, its nearest competitor in this market. 
“From a cultural, language empathy, customer centricity standpoint, the Filipino customer  representative is really preferred around the world. There is also a cost advantage to doing work in the Philippines. If you combine all those qualities, plus cost advantage, then it becomes an attractive location for contact center services,” Hernandez said. 
Based on The Everest Group data, the Philippine contact center sector generated revenues of $13 billion in 2017, a slight improvement from $12.77 billion revenue in 2016. 
This year, CCAP expects the industry to expand by another seven to nine percent. 
“We are forecasting to add another $1 billion in revenues this year. That translates to an additional 70,000 more jobs,” Uligan said. 
Under its existing roadmap, CCAP expects the sector’s revenue to rise to $20.4 billion by 2022.
Western businesses have looked to the Philippines to outsource much of their call center work. The result is a staggering growth in jobs and revenue. No question that these foreign call centers play a huge role in the Philippine economy. If they vanished overnight the economy would tank.

https://www.rappler.com/business/252043-overseas-filipino-workers-remittances-2019
Despite political uncertainties across the globe, personal remittances from overseas Filipino workers (OFWs) reached a record high of $33.5 billion in 2019, 3.9% higher than the $32.2 billion recorded in 2018. 
Inflows were mainly from the United States, which accounted for 37.6%, followed by Saudi Arabia, Singapore, Japan, United Arab Emirates, United Kingdom, Canada, Hong Kong, Germany, and Kuwait. 
OFW money boosted household income and consumption last year, accounting for 9.3% of the gross domestic product and 7.8% of the gross national income.
Despite the fact that so much money flows into this country from OFWs many people still run out of money!
UniTeller also noted that poor financial planning is experienced by almost 19% of families who admitted that they regularly run out of money. 
Around 72% of Filipino families said they will reach out to the OFW when they run out of cash, while 53% said they will forego day-to-day needs if this happens.
If there were no countries for Filipinos to work in as baristas, cooks, maids, nurses, or engineers so they could send back money to their relatives the economy would be severely impacted.

https://cebudailynews.inquirer.net/288857/international-arrivals-in-philippines-exceeds-2019-target
The country’s international visitors in 2019 reached 8.26 million, slightly exceeding the 8.2-million target set in the National Tourism Development (NTDP) for 2016-2022, the Department of Tourism (DoT) reported on its Facebook page. 
“This heralds a new milestone in the country’s tourism history, breaching the eight millionth mark.  Without doubt, our convergence programs with other government agencies, particularly in improving access as well as product development and marketing initiatives with local government and private sector have greatly paid off,” Tourism Secretary Bernadette Romulo-Puyat said. 
The secretary expressed hope the Philippines could sustain these gains amid the global challenges.
Who can forget the perennial quest of the DOT to steer foreign tourists to the Philippines so they can shop at the mall? Without the influx of tourists the economy would not collapse but there would be less money flowing.

Rice sufficiency, BPO's, OFW remittances, and tourists are just the tip of an iceberg which is Philippine dependence on foreign countries to "stand on their own." We could also look at Foreign Direct Investments or FDIs as well as the money promised by China and Japan to build infrastructure. There is also the many countries the Philippines has solicited for military equipment including Russia, India, and Korea. There are also many foreign NGO's distributing goods, building houses, providing education all through USAID and the NED. But that is all part of that iceberg tip.  Let's now look below the waters and see the mass of foreign money that is the base of Philippine development.

Since 1957 the Philippines has taken out billions in loans from the World Bank's lending arm the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD).  You can view all of these loans in detail at this link.  The very first loan was for the construction go Binga Power Dam. Then there are loans for various projects such as port dredging, Angat Dam, Maria Cristina Power Plant, Upper Pampanga River Irrigation Project (Pantabangan dam), and even highways. 

Some of the borrowers include the National Power Corporation, the Central Bank of the Philippines, the Private Development Corporation of the Philippines, Metropolitan Waterworks and Sewage, the Department of Finance, and the Philippine National Bank.

Here is a table of the latest approved programs.

https://financesapp.worldbank.org/en/countries/Philippines/
That may be too tiny for anyone to read. One of the projects listed is "Improving Fiscal Management." The budget for the project is $450,000,000!  This is not a project to help poor Filipinos become financially literate.  It is a project to institute economic reform within the government.
The development objective of the Improving Fiscal Management Development Policy Loan (DPL) Project for Philippines is to support the high-level objective of the Government of the Philippines to improve fiscal management with three development objectives: (A) strengthening tax policy; (B) enhancing public finance management and budget planning; and (C) strengthening fiscal risk management of public assets. This DPL forms an integral part of the Philippines country partnership strategy (CPS) which aims to support the government’s fiscal and budget reforms. This operation responds to a direct request from the government to support the acceleration of fiscal reform efforts in the Philippines. While the Philippines has a robust macroeconomic framework and strong reform program, due to changing global market conditions it is experiencing an increased government financing need. The government’s commitment to maintaining reform momentum is evidenced in the recent efforts in advancing further tax reforms, as well as a significant demand for technical assistance which the World Bank is responding to with other development partners.
https://projects.worldbank.org/en/projects-operations/project-detail/P167651 
"This operation responds to a direct request from the government to support the acceleration of fiscal reform efforts in the Philippines." Who made this direct request? Was it Duterte? Was it the finance secretary? What exactly is the $450,000,000 going towards? To write tax policies like TRAIN?

According to the World Bank there are have been 200 projects in the Philippines with a combined total commitment of $20,210,393,044.31. These 200 projects are as diverse as a Cebu Bus Rapid Transit project to disaster risk management. While the World Bank is an international organization that is part of the United Nations system it is located in the USA and presided over by an American citizen chosen by the President of the United States. 

Does the Philippine need the world to survive as a nation? Undoubtedly. The Philippines can't even feed itself without importing millions of tons of rice! If OFW's were not working overseas and sending remittances a large part of the economy would vanish.  The same thing would happen if not many tourists visited and if BPOs shut down. Without loans from the World Bank many projects in the Philippines would not be funded.

It's complete nonsense to think that abrogating the VFA will enable the Philippines to stand on its own feet when all these other programs remain in place propping up the nation.

Tuesday, March 17, 2020

Insurgency: Integrate MILF, MNLF to PNP, AFP Now

Duterte is at it again assigning the AFP a date by which to finish off the insurgency.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1096204
“I have always called it as an article of faith, but no progress or development in any nation — wherever it is — cannot really hope to grow if there is trouble. Itong atin dito, what ails us is many, the insurgency of the Communist Party of the Philippines (CPP), then you have the terrorists,” he said during the annual general assembly of the League of Municipalities of the Philippines in Pasay. 
I have two years. Frankly, I have asked the military and the police, kung kaya niyong tapusin, tapusin na ninyo ngayon (if you can finish it now, finish it now),” Duterte said. “Kung hindi ko ito matapos (If I won’t be able to stop it), then I have to pass this problem to the next generation.”
Like his predecessors Duterte makes the ending of the insurgency all about himself. Cory Aquino, Gloria Arroyo, Ramos, Benigno Aquino, each of them were confident the insurgency could be ended before their terms expired. They were all wrong. The only thing Duterte is right about is that if not soon stopped this problem will be passed on to the next generation. In fact the problem has lasted for two generations if we consider 25 years a generation. 

So what is the AFP to do?  Keep on at it. The war against the insurgency is a war of attrition and deadlines mean nothing. Take them down Johnny Cash style One Piece at a Time

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1096228
Government forces found more war materials and bomb-making components in former lairs of the Islamic State-linked Bangsamoro Islamic Freedom Fighters (BIFF) in the peripheries of the province following the military's week-long air and ground assaults. 
Aside from war materials, the military also recovered a black flag of the terror Islamic State of Iraq and Syria and personal belongings of BIFF radicals who fled the heavy bombardments the past several days. 
“Fourteen BIFF and four soldiers died during the week-long gun battles in the mountains of Maguindanao,” Alburo said. 
He said a total of 18 improvised explosive devices, bomb components, and war materials were recovered in the clash sites.
The AFP continues to engage in firefights with the BIFF and finding their weapons caches as a result. NPA leaders are being taken out one at a time too. Some are arrested.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1096734
The Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) and Philippine National Police (PNP) conducted a joint operation that led to the arrest of an alleged top-ranking official of the New People’s Army (NPA) in her hideout in Lala town, this province on Sunday. 
Police and Army operatives arrested Teresita Lapuz Naul, alias Tessie or Bessy, secretary of the NPA’s "Regional White Area Committee (RWAC)” under the North Central Mindanao Regional Committee (NCMRC). 
She was arrested by virtue of warrants of arrest for her crimes of destructive arson, including two counts of kidnapping and serious illegal detention. All cases were filed with no fixed bail issued by the Regional Trial Court, Branch 7, in Bayugan City, Agusan del Sur.
Some are killed.
https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1096603
Philippine Army (PA) chief Lt. Gen. Gilbert Gapay lauded military and police personnel for the successful operation in Baguio City which led to the neutralization of a ranking Communist Party of the Philippines-New People's Army (CPP-NPA) leader and two of his companions. 
"With Giron's death, justice is served. But we must not cease. We must not stop in uniting against such tyranny, which for many years, have deprived the Filipino people the peaceful lives they deserve," Gapay said in a statement late Friday. 
Government forces raided a house at Lourdes Subdivision Extension, Barangay Queen of Peace, Baguio City around 3:30 a.m. Friday. 
Killed were CPP chair and CPP-NPA Executive Community member Julius Soriano Giron, Lourdes Tan Torres, and a still unidentified male believed to a member of the rebels' National Military Commission. 
Security troops were supposed to serve Giron various warrants for murder, frustrated murder, arson and rebellion when the NPA leader and his companions opened fire, triggering a firefight which led to their deaths.
NPA weapons caches also continue to be found by the AFP.

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1241261/high-powered-guns-explosive-seized-in-camarines-sur-clash
Recovered were two M16 rifles, M1 Garand rifle, and M203 grenade launcher.
Camarines Sur is a stronghold of the NPA. Last year the AFP found a weapons cache in the same region.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1074961
"The firefight lasted for five minutes before the enemies scurried to different directions. No one was harmed in the government side," he said. 
Aguilar confirmed that two M16 rifles and other war materials and subversive documents were recovered in the encounter site. 
“Ang pagtulong nila para makarating sa atin ang impormasyon sa ginagawang pangingikil at paghahanap ng panibagong miyembro ng mga teroristang NPA sa kanilang barangay ang naging susi ng encounter na ito (This encounter is a result of the residents’ willingness to report the extortions and recruitment being made by the NPA terrorists in their barangay)," he added.
While the war against the insurgency is a war of attrition with the AFP it's more like trying to empty the water out of a sinking boat. It's a losing proposition. More needs to be done. We already know that the AFP has been lax in the war against the NPA by declaring an area insurgent free and then abandoning it to the LGUs to take care of the security.  I have written about that at length here.

One crucial component in defeating the NPA is intelligence gathered from the rebels themselves.

https://cebudailynews.inquirer.net/294185/cops-soldiers-more-vigilant-ready-to-foil-npa-attacks
Law enforcers and military forces in Negros Oriental remain more vigilant and prepared to foil any attack of the New People’s Army. 
This after three suspected NPA members were arrested in Sta. Catalina town on March 12 and provided information that boosted the veracity of the intelligence reports about the rebel group’s alleged simultaneous attack plans. 
Police Colonel Julian Entoma, Negros Oriental Provincial Police Office chief, said that these three alleged members of the Southeast Front, New People’s Army (SEF-NPA) provided information about the planned attacks. 
These attacks were planned because of the upcoming anniversary of the NPA on March 29, 2020. 
(They also provided information that the group met somewhere in the boundary area. So we validated the information about the plan to attack and planned atrocities to be done against the government forces. It seemed that they planned to implemen these attacks this month.) 
He said that the suspects’ information confirmed intelligence reports gathered by security forces regarding simultaneous attacks by the NPA against vulnerable detachments, patrol bases and police stations. 
(We have an offensive operation against them because we have received several information about the NPAs plans to harass police station and their plans to regroup. That is the reason that their target is the province’s southeast. That will include Sta. Catalina town, Siaton and Zamboanguita.)
Will attacks happen nationwide on March 29th? Probably not. The NPA makes a lot of noise about their anniversaries but nothing ever seems to happen. 

More than actual battle between the AFP and the communists and Islamists the one project that the Philippine government is banking on to end the insurgency is the whole-of-nation approach as laid out in EO 70.

https://pia.gov.ph/news/articles/1035916
In an effort to address the root cause of local armed conflict, the government through EO 70 orders the institutionalization of the whole-of-nation approach as a government policy for the attainment of inclusive and sustainable peace. 
DILG OIC Provincial Director Danilo Laguitan said the program is the government’s resolve to end the local communist rebellion by bringing the government services closer to the people with the end-in-view of ushering inclusive development to attain peace during the Kapihan sa PIA on March 3. 
The officer-in-charge explained that the local government units shall champion the implementation of the Retooled Community Support Program (RCSP) and spearhead initiatives by engaging the community to collaborate and co-create with their local government developments and solutions to local issues. 
Laguitan pointed out that RCSP is a convergence mechanism for LGUs particularly in the barangay for the identification of issues and needed government interventions. 
He then explained that the program is anchored on the empowerment framework geared to provide needed government services to the community, open and access available platform for democratic participation where everyone is involved.
That's a lot of big words just to say that the government is giving NPA and Islamic terrorists who surrender cash, housing and training for jobs. For the MILF though there is something greater than simple bribery and that is the BARMM.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1096251
The implementation of Republic Act 11054 or the Bangsamoro Organic Law (BOL) and the ongoing transition of the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (BARMM) remains on track amidst the challenges being faced by the national and Bangsamoro governments. 
“The mandate of the new Bangsamoro government is that we shall always be cooperative and collaborative with all endeavors to pursue good governance and ultimately development,” said lawyer Ali Pangalian Balindong, speaker of the BARMM Parliament during Tuesday's hearing called for by the Senate Committee on Local Government. 
“We are assisting in the baby steps but we would want to ensure that these would be translated into successful adult strides because the success of BARMM is the success of the Philippines,” he said.
The success of he BARMM is the success of the Philippines. Why didn't they take that approach with the ARMM? Part of the success of the BARMM is the Philippine government's fulfilling of their promises to the MILF who govern the MILF.

https://manilastandard.net/news/national/319439/integrate-milf-mnlf-forces-to-pnp-afp-now-bato-.html
Senator Ronald ‘Bato’ dela Rosa wants to hasten the integration of the Moro Islamic Liberation Front and Moro National Liberation Front personnel to the Philippine National Police and the Armed Forces of the Philippines to boost the government’s efforts to attain lasting peace and development across the country, especially in the BARMM area. 
During the hearing of the Senate Committee on Local Government to discuss the updates of the implementation of the Bangsamoro Organic Law, Dela Rosa urged Office of the Presidential Adviser for Peace Process Secretary Carlito Galvez to speed up the provision of guidelines [thru NaPolCom] and the integration process of the MILF and MNLF to the PNP and AFP. 
He said he believes that the competence of MILF and MNLF forces could help the country’s soldiers and policemen in maintaining peace and order in the land.
The former national police chief validated with Secretary Galvez, former AFP Chief of Staff and currently the OPAPP secretary, the reports that the latter got from the ground during his stint as PNP Chief that the MILF and MNLF are snappy and very qualified to be members of the PNP and AFP. 
“Sir I personally saw their [MILF / MNLF] behavior and you are really correct sir, some of those or many of those are really qualified to become members of the Armed Forces and the PNP,” Galvez said. 
Galvez added that some of the MILF and MNLF combatants had already undergone training under the Joint Peace and Security Teams of the Annex of Normalization included in the BOL. 
“I understand it would take time, mahaba pa ang proseso at magkakaroon pa ng training…the more that we should be motivated to receive them into the Armed Forces, sabi nga magagaling na sila, mas disiplinado pa yung iba kaya bilisan natin sir and I hope expedite na natin yan,” Dela Rosa said. 
“Sir actually may mga re-positioned na kami with the Armed Forces. Actually, Sir ang pinaka priority for the possible integration to the Armed Forces and the PNP are those who were trained at the JPST because we saw that they are very much qualified that is why we are hurrying up for the listing so the integration of the MILF will be taken from the JPST,” Galvez explained.
What makes MILF and MNLF terrorists qualified to be members of the PNP and AFP? How will integrating them lead to peace? Why pay them to surrender their weapons and then enlist them in the PNP and AFP? If the government is that hard up for men it would be better to instate the draft than enlist terrorists.

Monday, March 16, 2020

The God Culture: Does Timothy Jay Schwab Have A Missionary Visa?

I did not want to write about the God Culture again so soon but here I am writing about the God Culture again so soon. The impetus is a comment Anna Rose Lipshy or Timothy Schwab or Justin Hester or whoever left on the last entry about Philippine gold jewelry allegedly being found in first century Egypt.
In your attempt to create doubt you further entrench this 1 point you attempt to attack. Foolish. So, not only did the Philippines trade with Egypt 2000 years ago which was our only point on this 1 slide of about 1 minute but so did West Asia/Persia. Wow! That’s even better. This point becomes even stronger in a timeline of concurrent gold trading in the Philippines. The assumptions in these articles that India had to be a mediator between the Philippines and Egypt is illogical and unfounded even by their own admission. That is the exact scholarly false paradigm we have crushed and you are going to have to deal with whether you like it or not. For one to mention the Philippines trading with Egypt and West Asia even recognizing they had the large balangay ships at least (some 80’ long according to Pigafetta and actual archaeology in Butuan some dated as early as 320 AD), is willing ignorance. Professor Adrian Horridge even documents those balangay in operation going to Sri Lanka and India back in 200 BC at least. Wikipedia stakes a claim of Philippines mining gold since 1000 BC and we test that.
http://philippinefails.blogspot.com/2020/03/the-god-culture-philippine-gold-jewelry.html?showComment=1584100051224#c4938809290190470428
Responding to this comment will also give me space to write about another and more important aspect of the God Culture pertaining personally to Timothy Jay Schwab. As Tim says, "We'll get to that."

First of all the commenter says the Philippines traded with Egypt 2,000 years ago as if that is an established fact but that is not what the three sources I looked at claim. While they mention trade contacts between Southeast Asia and Africa they do not say the Philippines traded directly with Egypt or that Filipino balangays sailed to Africa or Egypt. However the content of those sources do not matter to the God Culture because they say the conclusions of those scholars are illogical and unfounded and that they have crushed this "scholarly false paradigm." It's another instance of Tim and the God Culture discarding what a source actually says and substituting their own opinions and inferences despite citing the source as proof of their claims.

Secondly the commenter cites Professor Adrian Horridge as documenting Philippine balangays "going to Sri Lanka and India back in 200 BC at least." This claim is cited in their video "Solomon's Gold Series Part 1D: Testing the RESOURCES of Ancient Ophir, Tarshish, Sheba" beginning at 44:55.

https://youtu.be/gG39WFEYfiU?t=2695
"Now, Professor Adrian Horridge believes that by 200 BC, now we're way back to the same date we gave you for being able to firmly establish that gold was being traded, mined and traded from the Philippines and here you have Austronesian sailors were regularly carrying cloves and cinnamon to India and Sri Lanka. Funny because everybody says Sri Lanka is the origin of cinnamon. Yeah because that's where the Filipinos took their cinnamon.  Does it have a lot still? Yes. Do they grow it there? Yes. No doubt. But does it only come from Sri Lanka? It's another one of those things. No it does not. It may today for instance but it cerintaly did not in ancient times.

And perhaps even as far as the coast of Africa in sailboats with outriggers he says. I know he must be crazy too except they have built replicas of these ships now and actually this balangay has been sailed all the way around the world. So they most certainly could have taken that journey." 
The source for this quote from Professor Horridge comes from a document titled "The South China Sea Dispute: Philippine Sovereign Rights and Jurisdiction in the West Philippine Sea," by Antonio T. Carpio.
Prof. Adrian Horridge believes that by 200 BCE, Austronesian sailors were regularly carrying cloves and cinnamon to India and Sri Lanka, and perhaps even as far as the coast of Africa in sailboats with outriggers.
The South China Sea Dispute: Philippine Sovereign Rights and Jurisdiction in the West Philippine Sea," pg.3 
This is another instance of secondhand quoting from Tim instead of using primary sources. If he had followed the footnotes he would have found that Carpio's source for this quote comes from a book titled "The Austronesians: Historical and Comparative Perspectives." A copy of that book can be downloaded here.  On page 146 we read the following:
Although influences from the Indian Ocean were too late to influence the Pacific Austronesians, Sanskrit words and possibly some rigging techniques could have started to spread east of Peninsular Malaysia by 200 BC. Trade routes were also open between Vietnam and eastern Indonesia about 200 BC, as shown by the distribution of the Dong Son bronze drums along the natural sea route dictated by the monsoons in the South China and Java Seas. Recent excavations at Sembiran in Bali have also revealed evidence of drum casting and deposits of South Asian rouletted ware pottery, most likely dated before AD 200 (Ardika and Bellwood 1991). Annual trade between China and India through the Malacca Straits had opened by about 200 BC. Perhaps by that time Austronesian sailors were regularly carrying cloves and cinnamon to India and Sri Lanka, and perhaps even as far as the coast of Africa in boats with outriggers. Certainly they have left numerous traces in canoe design, rigs, outriggers and fishing techniques, and a mention in Greek literature (Christie 1957).
Both Carpio and Tim cite Horridge wrong.  Professor Horridge does not say that Austronesian sailors were regularly sailing to India. What he says is perhaps they were. That word perhaps is very important and Carpio and Tim both omit it. Perhaps is very different than I believe. Professor Horridge is speculating and not stating a fact. Horridge's reference to Christie is also very important because it leads to a discussion of the Periplus which is a central text to Tim's thesis.
The obscure passage in question is the following:
60.   Among the market-towns of these countries, and the harbors where the ships put in from Damirica [=Limyrike] and from the north, the most important are, in order as they lie, first Camara, then Poduca, then Sopatma; in which there are ships of the country coasting along the shore as far as Damirica; and other very large vessels made of single logs bound together, called sangara: but those which make the voyage to Chryse and to the Ganges are called colandia, and are very large. There are imported into these places everything made in Damirica, and the greatest part of what is brought at any time from Egypt comes here, together with most kinds of all the things that are brought from Damirica and of those that are carried through Paralia.
https://depts.washington.edu/silkroad/texts/periplus/periplus.html
This brief paper says that some consider this passage in the Periplus to be corrupt. The problem lies in the interpretation of the word highlighted above, colandia. Anthony Christie spends nine pages identifying what kind of ship a colandia is even investigating Chinese documents concerning these ships.  Needless to say he does not identify it as a balangay or anything Filipino. In fact both Horridge and Christie use the all encompassing term Austronesian which could mean any number of people groups and not necessarily Filipinos.

It is interesting to note that the commenter says Professor Horridge documents Filipino balangays as making trips to India and Sri Lanka in 200 BC when he does not mention balangays at all. That is an addition the commenter makes because Tim makes the connection with his slide. Now in the mind of the commenter, as well as the mind of anyone who watched the video, Professor Horridge is saying that Filipino balangays made the trip to India in 200 BC. It's a very subtle trick Tim has played on his unsuspecting audience to associate the balangay with the quote from Professor Horridge. It's an instance of personal biases and inferences becoming fact.

It's the same kind of trick Tim played in his video Clue #3 where he says Philippine gold jewelry was found in Egypt, asks how did it get there, and then proceeds to talk about Philippine ships. Anyone watching that video would think Filipinos sailed to Egypt even though Tim never says that.

Taken as a whole along with the paper by Anthony Christie Professor Horridge does not support Tim's thesis that balangays were making ports of call to India by 200 BC. Tim is also wrong when he says that a balangay has sailed around the world. The Balangay Voyage project did build a balangay but they only sailed to China and around Southeast Asia.  They did not circumnavigate the globe.

Thirdly the commenter says "Wikipedia stakes a claim of Philippines mining gold since 1000 BC." Here is the reference:
Mining in the Philippines began around 1000 BC. The early Filipinos worked various mines of gold, silver, copper and iron. Jewels, gold ingots, chains, calombigas and earrings were handed down from antiquity and inherited from their ancestors. Gold dagger handles, gold dishes, tooth plating, and huge gold ornaments were also used. In Laszlo Legeza's "Tantric elements in pre-Hispanic Philippines Gold Art", he mentioned that gold jewelry of Philippine origin was found in Ancient Egypt. According to Antonio Pigafetta, the people of Mindoro possessed great skill in mixing gold with other metals and gave it a natural and perfect appearance that could deceive even the best of silversmiths. The natives were also known for the pieces of jewelry made of other precious stones such as carnelian, agate and pearl. Some outstanding examples of Philippine jewelry included necklaces, belts, armlets and rings placed around the waist.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mining#Classical_Philippine_civilization
Right away this reference is suspect because it also includes the false claim that Legeza mentions Philippine gold jewelry being found in ancient Egypt. He does not. He says it appears this is so and he does not source his claim. The source for the claim that mining in the Philippines began in 1,000 BC is traced to a defunct Geocities page. 
Mines dating back to at least 1,000 B.C. have been found in the Philippines. When the Spanish arrived the Filipinos worked various mines of gold, silver, copper and iron. They also seemed to have worked in brass using tin that was likely imported from the Malay Peninsula. The iron work in particular was said to be of very high quality in some cases, and occassionaly in some areas, even better than that found in Europe. 
https://web.archive.org/web/20071201054321/http://www.geocities.com/Tokyo/Temple/9845/tech.htm#jew
This website appears to be the personal blog of Paul Sekai Manansala who is the author of "Quests of the Dragon and Bird Clanwhich is a revisionist history about the Nusantao. This guy even believes Prester John was a real king! Seeing as this page was first captured in the internet archive back in 1999 it would seem likely that it is the source of the erroneous citation of Peralta which is among the three sources cited to prove that Philippine gold was found in ancient Egypt.

Paul neglects to provide a source for his claim that mines dating to 1,000 BC have been found in the Philippines. Who discovered these mines and where are they located? The Wikipedia page also does not quote Paul correctly. Wikipedia says mining in the Philippines began around 1,000 BC while Paul only says mines dating to 1,000 BC have been found in the Philippines.

If mining began in the Philippines in 1,000 BC that would not be enough time for Filipinos to become miners of international renown whose gold King Solomon coveted.  King Solomon's dates are 990-931. Yet Tim takes this Wikipedia article as Gospel even mapping it out on a timeline.

https://youtu.be/gG39WFEYfiU?t=1371
"Again Wikipedia says the Philippines has been mining gold since 1000 BC..." 
I am not going to deny that Filipinos were mining gold back in 1,000 BC but Tim needs a better source to prove his claims than what Wikipedia is "staking." As it stands a date of 1,000 BC for the beginning of mining in the Philippines is too late for the Philippines to have been recognized as the land of gold to where King Solomon sent his ships. For the Philippines to be the premier land of gold in the way Tim claims it is the mining industry needs to be much, much older. Tim offers no proof or suggestion that this is the case but sticks with the date 1,000 BC.

I can imagine the commenter reading all that and thinking its a big nothing burger and that I am a fool who is nitpicking and being a libeling communist agitator yada, yada, yada. But getting your sources right is very crucial and time and again we see that Tim gets his sources wrong. In this same video Tim says:

https://youtu.be/gG39WFEYfiU
This is why gold jewelry of Philippine origin was found in a dig in Egypt dating first century AD.
I have already looked at the three sources cited to make this claim and shown it to be vastly overstated. It's funny that Tim adds the detail about the jewelry being found in a dig. None of those sources mention such a thing. It is very clear that Tim has not even read these three sources but is citing them secondhand just as he uses some sources but twists what they say to fit his paradigm. Thomas Suarez, Charles Nowell, and Rev. Thomas Stackhouse are three examples of men from whose writings he "gleans" what supports his thesis and ignores the rest. I have made it abundantly clear in these posts about the God Culture that Tim is not an honest or objective researcher. He has an agenda and shoehorns in the facts to support it. As they say, "Never let the truth get in the way of a good story."

Now let's talk about Timothy Jay Schwab. He claims he is challenging tradition and is not part of any organization or denomination.
We are The God Culture, a group of independent researchers with no affiliation to any denomination nor organization whatsoever. 
The God Culture is a group of independent researchers not affiliated with any denomination nor organization. This team focuses solely on relationship with the Father through His Son testing all things using scripture as it’s foundation.
https://www.thegodculture.com
Yet he also claims he is here in the Philippines conducting conferences as part of an evangelistic ministry.
They chose the platform of YouTube to share their research initially in order to gather a following and after 2 years and over 5 million views from 214 countries on a teaching channel, The God Culture now re-enters the evangelistic ministry in conducting conferences beginning in the Philippines as much of the geography the Holy Spirit has restored leads to that land. Married to a Filipina, Timothy desires to spend much more time in the Philippines, the land of Ophir and the Garden of Eden (try to disprove it) and on their first tour, The God Culture already has over 15 conferences booked in their first month in May 2019 alone from North Luzon to Visayas to Mindanao
(EDIT and UPDATE) The God Culture has deleted this passage from their website.  Here is the original:




Anna Rose Lipshy even says that she and Tim were evangelists touring the USA.
We used to be evangelist touring the US for a number of years conducting altar calls consistently (oh forgot, we don't have any ministry experience according to this ignorant blog) and our experience in follow up was a whole lot of people who did not continue in relationship. 
https://philippinefails.blogspot.com/2020/02/the-god-culture-100-clues-philippines.html?showComment=1580699091074#c7458184243698567772
If Tim is doing the work of an evangelist in the Philippines surely he has a missionary visa, right? I don't think so.  He has said he is not part of any organization, not part of any denomination. That means no one sent him to do religious work in the Philippines. By his own admission he stands completely outside of the Church.

Here are the requirements of a missionary visa. I admit this is not the Bureau of Immigration's webpage but it is from a company who specializes in assisting people to obtain Philippine visas and is more forthright and clear than the information on the BI's webpage.
This visa is issued to a foreigner who: 
1. is a member of a religious denomination that is a bonafide non-profit organization in the Philippines  
2. is a minister or a religious worker of a non-profit religious denomination 
3. is requested by his religious organization to carry out a religious occupation in the Philippines 
4. is going to study a fixed curriculum in order to accomplish and undergo a proper formation training
Do any of those four qualifications apply to Timothy Schwab? Not according to what he says about himself. He is a foreigner having no affiliation with any religious organization yet he is in the Philippines acting as a missionary. His webpage shows him posing with Bishop Rod and Ruth Cubos at a conference in Davao.


In fact it appears that all of his conferences are held in tandem with a local church as this video shows:



The God Culture deleted the video above in order to cover their tracks. Clearly they do not want people to know that they are doing missionary work in this country. But someone uploaded it on Facebook so here it is:

 

Despite the fact that Tim is obviously involved in missionary work it is very doubtful he has a missionary visa. If he does have one that would mean he either belongs to a religious organization, which he admits he does not, or someone invited him to the Philippines which seems unlikely because his ministry is that of a wandering evangelist and he is interacting with a wide variety of Filipino churches and pastors. The only way to be sure is to actually see his missionary visa. I dare him to post it if he has one. I dare him to tell us what organization he belongs to and sent him here or who requested that he come to the Philippines to evangelize. If he doesn't have a missionary visa then he is in flagrant violation of Philippine immigration law for doing the work of a missionary without the proper and necessary credentials.

That's is it for the God Culture. I don't want to bore my regular readers with this "cult" and I don't want to harp on these guys either. I have said basically everything that needs saying about them. The only things left to do in regards to the God Culture are to review their book when it is published and to post a write-up after attending a conference. Hopefully the coronavirus pandemic doesn't cancel any of their upcoming conferences.