Friday, July 16, 2021

Retards in the Government 215

 It's your weekly compendium of foolishness and corruption in the Philippine government.



https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1458011/barangay-captain-wounded-in-camsur-shooting

A barangay captain was wounded in a shooting incident in San Fernando, Camarines Sur Friday night.

Police Colonel Bernardo Perez, Camarines Sur police chief, reported that Cesar Hufancia, 35, was shot and wounded while attending a wake in Barangay Rizal at around 9:30 p.m.

He sustained a gunshot wound to the right leg and was brought to hospital.

The gunman is  now the subject of a manhunt.

Barangay captain survives an. assassination attempt.

https://www.philstar.com/nation/2021/07/10/2111478/coa-flags-afp-over-p18-billion-unauthorized-bank-accounts

The Commission on Audit (COA) flagged the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) over its failure to close 20 unauthorized bank accounts with a total balance of P1.813 billion.

In its 2020 annual audit report on the AFP general headquarters (AFP-GHQ) released yesterday, the COA said that under the 2020 General Appropriations Act, all government agencies are directed to close down and revert to the national treasury all the balances of their special accounts, fiduciary or trust funds and revolving funds “when there is no legal basis for their creation.”

The COA said the bank accounts were maintained without the required authority from the Permanent Committee, which was created under the Administrative Code of 1987 and is composed of the finance and budget secretaries as chairpersons and COA officials as members.

The COA said the AFP’s unauthorized bank accounts are maintained with the Land Bank of the Philippines, Development Bank of the Philippines, Philippine Veterans Bank and United Coconut Planters Bank.

The COA’s breakdown showed that AFP Modernization Act Trust Fund-Central Office (AFPMATF) was responsible for three unauthorized bank accounts with a total balance of P1.346 billion; the AFP Educational Benefit System Office, eight bank accounts with a balance of P347.483 million; AFP Real Estate Office, with two bank accounts with a balance of P84.362 million and the GHQ Central Office with seven bank accounts with a balance of P37.744 million.

The COA noted that Finance Secretary Carlos Dominguez wrote a letter dated June 19, 2020 to Defense Secretary Delfin Lorenzana recommending that he order the closure of the AFPMATF bank accounts and remit to the national treasury the outstanding balances.

The AFP has P1.87 billion illegally stashed away in 20 bank accounts. The DoF wrote to the DND last year recommending the accounts be closed and the money be remitted but this has not yet happened. But wait, there's more!

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1459345/coa-flags-afp-for-failure-to-remit-p469m-to-treasury

In its 2020 audit report on the AFP General Headquarters, COA noted that the P469.12 million consisting of donations, interest income, scholarship fund and other unused funding was still deposited in banks. 

The unutilized funds included P2.17 million that was supposed to go to the payment of rewards and other claims and P33.7 million for allowances. 

The COA called out the AFP for its failure to remit the funds and also flagged it for P130.178 million worth of disbursements without the required documents.


According to COA, the disbursements were used for the purchase of various military, police and traffic supplies from the procurement service of the Department of Budget and Management. 

It observed that the payments for the repairs and maintenance of facilities in the AFP central command lacked official receipts.

The AFP has an additional P469 million hidden away that needs to be refunded to the treasury. The AFP says they are working on it.



https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1146551

Local authorities are set to file charges against 10 policemen of the Police Regional Office-Bangsamoro Autonomous Region (PRO-BAR) for presenting fake negative swab test results while trying to enter this city. 

Maj. Shellamie Chang, Police Regional Office-9 (PRO-9) information officer, said Friday this was based on the recommendation of the City Legal Officer upon the request for legal advice of the Zamboanga City Police Office’s (ZCPO) Station 11. 

Chang said the 10 policemen tried to enter this city with fake swab test results coming from the cities of Isabela and Lamitan in Basilan and Sulu, respectively. 

City Tourism Officer Sarita Sebastian earlier said the policemen were intercepted on Monday after the fake swab test results were discovered by her personnel and the City Health Office during profiling.

10 BARRM cops faked swab tests to enter a city.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1146563

The Office of the Ombudsman has ordered the suspension of five officials of the Land Registration Authority (LRA) and the Registry of Deeds (RD)-Taguig for conspiring to legitimize cloud on titles of over 18,000 square meters of prime real estate within Bonifacio Global City (BGC).

In an order dated June 23, Ombudsman Samuel Martires ruled to suspend for six months without pay LRA Legal Service Director Rhandolfo Amansec, Docket Division chief Joel Mari Martin Bigornia, and Micrographics and Computer Division chief Ser John Pastrana.

Also suspended were Taguig RD’s Dorylene Yara and Ron Jacob Merced, a records officer.

The Ombudsman said it "found sufficient ground to preventively suspend respondents considering that there is strong evidence showing their guilt" and that "the charges against them for gross neglect of duty, grave misconduct, serious dishonesty and conduct prejudicial to the best interest of the service may warrant their removal from the service (and that) their continued stay in office may prejudice the investigation of the case filed against them”.

Amansec, Bigornia, and Yara approved the confirmation of a group of transfer certificate of titles (TCTs), known as the Vizcarra titles, covering 18,000 square meters of prime real estate in BGC even if the documents lacked credible evidence affirming authenticity.

Five LRTA officials fired for conspiring to legitimize spurious land titles.

https://www.sunstar.com.ph/article/1900397/Tacloban/Local-News/Barangay-captain-shot-dead-in-Northern-Samar
A 37-YEAR-OLD barangay captain was shot and killed in Las Navas, Northern Samar Saturday, July 10, 2021, police said.

The victim was identified as Crispin Nale Mordido, chairman of Barangay San Andres, Las Navas.  

According to the initial report, an unidentified group of gunmen shot the victim around 12:40 p.m. Saturday in Barangay Lourdes of the said town.

He was hit in the different parts of his body which caused his instantaneous death.
Barangay captain assassinated by unknown men for unknown reasons.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1146985

Police authorities in Sarangani are investigating the alleged pointing of gun by a police official in Kiamba town to violators of the face mask policy.

Col. Michael Lebanan, Sarangani police director, said Wednesday they are currently gathering the necessary information regarding the incident involving acting Kiamba police station chief, Maj. Rolan Catoburan, in an operation last July 10.

He was referring to a complaint from civilian June Comanda, a resident of Tual in Barangay Poblacion, who claimed that the police official pointed a handgun at him and several other persons after they were rounded up for not wearing face masks.

Lebanan said he instructed their investigators to look into the incident and gather statements from witnesses.

Comanda, a fisherman, said in a phone interview that he was returning to his home around 3 p.m. last July 10 when he was accosted by policemen led by Catoburan for failing to wear a face mask.

The police team came to Purok San Francisco, Barangay Poblacion over a reported gambling activity involving a basketball game, he said.

After being rounded up on orders from Catuboran, Comanda admitted questioning the official for apprehending them over the face mask violation when he was not wearing one himself.

“That was when he fumed, pulled out a handgun, and pointed it to us,” he said, alleging that the police official reeked of liquor at that time.

Comanda said they were then brought to the Kiamba municipal police station and given a choice to either pay a fine or perform a song and dance number.

He said they chose the performance option and were released after singing four songs.

Allegedly a cop, reeking of liquor, rounded up men for not wearing face masks and for illegal gambling. When the men complained that the cop was not wearing a face mask he pulled out a gun and pointed it at them. Then he forced them to choose between paying a fine or performing karaoke.

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1146891

Two personnel of the Philippine National Police-Maritime Group (PNP-MG) in Agusan del Norte were charged with murder after they were implicated in the killing of a fisherman in Cabadbaran City on Monday.

In a statement Tuesday, Police Regional Office-Caraga (PRO-13) director, Brig. Gen. Romeo Caramat Jr. identified the police personnel as Senior Master Sgt. Rizyl B. Torricer, 34, and Pat. Ariel Jay M. Panes, 26.

“The subject police personnel were tagged in the fatal shooting of Ikiel A. Kintanar, 31, a fisherman and a resident of Barangay Calibunan, Cabadbaran City,” Caramat said.

He added that the killing of Kintanar took place on Monday afternoon off the coast in Cabadbaran City while the suspects were on seaborne patrol and confronted a group of local fishermen in the area. 

Two cops accused of killing a fisherman.

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1459500/75-rouge-cops-dismissed-from-service-since-march-eleazar
Seventy-five police officers were dismissed from the service since March for involvement in various offenses, the Philippine National Police (PNP) said Wednesday.

PNP chief Guillermo Eleazar said the 75 ordered dismissed by the National Police Commission (Napolcom) were part of 166 erring police officers who had received sanctions. Of this number, 48 officers were demoted in ranks while 43 were suspended.

Eleazar, who serves as an ex-officio member of the Napolcom, said the sanctions imposed on the erring personnel prove that the “mechanisms to discipline policemen is working.”

“These 166 police scalawags who were sanctioned are proof that the police organization does not tolerate any wrongdoing or criminal involvement of our men,” Eleazar said.

Eleazar also noted that the administrative cases filed against the 166 “police scalawags” went through a thorough investigation and due process.

Out of 166 "erring police officers" 75 were dismissed, 48 demoted, and 43 suspended. That means 91 scalawags remain within the PNP ranks.

https://cebudailynews.inquirer.net/388151/coa-flags-cebu-citys-purchase-of-p90m-covid-test-kits-machine

State auditors flagged down the purchase of RT-PCR test machine and kits, and Rapid Antibody Test Kits made by the Cebu City Government that amounted to around P90 million.

This was contained in the 259-page 2020 Annual Audit Report for the City of Cebu that was recently released by the Commission on Audit (COA). 

In its report, COA mentioned eight significant observations, one of which was the purchase of the test machines and the test kits. 

A copy of the report dated June 14, 2021 and signed by Regional Director Marilou Rizzari was furnished to reporters. 

In its report, the state auditing body questioned the procurement of RT-PCR machine and testing kits that cost P18 million and P29 million respectively. 

They also pointed out that the city’s purchase of 1,670 boxes of Rapid Antibody Test Kits, totaling P43 million, could not be considered under “emergency procurement modality.” 

COA also noted other irregularities in the purchase of the COVID-19 test kits and equipment. 

They found out that the supplier of both the RT-PCR and rapid antibody test kits, a certain Novus Avenir Pharmaceutical based in Marilao, Bulacan, has only acquired its Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Certification in July 2020, or months after the procurement was made. 

The sale of both types of COVID-19 test kits and the RT-PCR test machine to Cebu City transpired between March to April. 

State auditors also discovered questionable details on the documents for the acquisition and delivery of the testing machine and kits. 

“The Request for Quotation (RFQ) and PO (Purchase Order) were both dated March 25, 2020, and delivery was also on the same data, as shown in the Delivery Receipt,” COA said. 

“Same-day delivery is not possible since the supplier is from Marilao, Bulacan. There being no airport in Bulacan, travel destination would be from Bulacan to Manila by land and Manila to Cebu by plane,” it added.

The COA has found many irregularities in Cebu City's procurement of various COVID-19 testing supplies.

https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2021/07/14/2112482/dilg-pushes-raps-vs-officials-destruction-protected-watershed-areas

The Department of the Interior and Local Government recommended the filing of criminal and administrative charges against government officials and private entities for their continued violation of environmental laws in the protected watershed areas of San Roque in Baras, Rizal. 

The department's recommendation came in a letter addressed to the Department of Environment and Natural Resources and the Anti-Illegal Logging Task Force where the DILG slammed what it said was the illegal entry, illegal logging, and encroachment of a private resort and other infrastructure within the Upper Marikina River Basin Protected Landscape in Rizal.  

“What is also appalling and alarming is the large-scale cutting of trees and kaingin activities covering more than 16 hectares in multiple sections of UMRBPL. Several new structures were also erected in the areas where the trees were burned,” he said. 

"They are already subjugating the environment, they still rule the area and do not follow the authorities and the laws to protect the environment," he also said in Filipino.

The DILG wants to sue local officials for allowing environmental destruction to continue.

The Supreme Court (SC) has dismissed a petition filed by former Commission on Human Rights (CHR) commissioner Cecilia Rachel "Coco" V. Quisumbing questioning the Office of the Ombudsman's 2014 decision dismissing her from government service on bribery and misconduct charges.

In a decision written by Associate Justice Samuel Gaerlan and recently made available online, the SC's First Division concurred with Sept. 24, 2014 memorandum of then executive secretary Paquito Ochoa and the October 1, 2014 memorandum of then CHR chairperson Loretta Ann Rosales, which implemented the Ombudsman's August 28, 2014 joint resolution imposing on Quisumbing the penalty of dismissal from government service.

Quisumbing, a former television newscaster, was a CHR commissioner when she was administratively charged with direct bribery, grave misconduct, and violation of the Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act in several complaint-affidavits filed by members of her staff.

According to the complainants Ma. Regina D. Eugenio, Elizabeth Diego-Buizon, Alexander B. Fernandez, and Jesse K. Ayuste, Quisumbing was often cruel, imperious, and disrespectful to her staff. Quisumbing had a tendency to scream at her staff whenever she was addressed incorrectly or her instructions were not followed to the letter.

Furthermore, Quisumbing would sometimes issue illegal or improper orders to her staff, including ordering Eugenio to falsify the total number of undistributed T-shirts made for the celebration of the 60th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and ordered her staff to turn over their salary ATM cards to her.

The Supreme Court upholds the 2014 dismissal of the CHR commissioner. Funny that it took them 7 years to make this decision. That is the slow nature of justice in the Philippines.

Thursday, July 15, 2021

Coronavirus Lockdown: Online Gambling Allowed to Boost COVID Response Funds, 3rd Wave, and More!

More news about how the COVID-19 pandemic in the Philippines is being handled by the public and the government.


The government has borrowed millions to pay for their COVID-19 response but funds have either been unspent or run out. What better way to raise more funds than to promote online gambling?


https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1146320

Despite previously being against online gambling in the country, President Rodrigo Duterte on Wednesday said he was forced to allow the activity to boost the country’s Covid-19 response funds.

In a pre-recorded meeting with his political party officials, Duterte said allowing gambling operations was the most “sensible” thing to do, considering the government is running short of funds.

Itong sugal, bakit ko pinayagan? Wala tayong pera eh. Ngayon kasi kailangan natin ng pera (Why did I allow gambling? We don’t have money…Now that we need money), the most sensible thing is really just to encourage those activities. Though it may sound not really repulsive but maybe repugnant to some, eh magdusa na muna kayo kasi kailangan ko talaga ang pera para sa bayan(you have to deal with it because we need money for the country),” he said.

He said the prevailing pandemic has forced the government to tap reserved funds from gambling operations.

He said it was the only way to prevent Covid-19 from infecting more people in the country.

“Pagdating ng pandemic, naubos ang pera natin. May reserba natin nagamit natin lahat (When it comes to the pandemic, we’re running out of money. We used up all our reserved funds) to contain the viral virus from rampaging all throughout the country,” he added.

It's not an unprecedented move as the DOH gets much of its money from and the Universal Healthcare law is to be funded by the PCSO which runs the lottery and other games of chance. But to say he HAD to do it opens the doors to a slippery slope. If it generates money then why not allow it no matter how repugnant the activity?


If you live in Bulacan and have a Tik-Tok account the government wants you to propagandist the nation.


https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1146264

Governor Daniel R. Fernando on Wednesday urged "TikTok" users, particularly the Bulakenyo youth, to help promote the implementation of the minimum public health protocols, particularly the wearing of face masks and face shields as a measure against the coronavirus disease 2019 (Covid-19).

He encouraged the students of BPC-Pandi to enjoin netizens in following the measures to curb the spread of Covid-19 through short-form videos circulated in the internet using the social media platform.

Through this, he said the youth or the TikTok users will be able to help the government in its implementation of the guidelines set by the Inter-Agency Task Force for the Management of Emerging Infectious Diseases (IATF-EID).

"(We are facing a global health crisis so I believe that you, the youth, will have a great participation in preventing the spread of coronavirus disease (Covid-19) in the country, so do not waste your time on TikTok that does not make sense, make it meaningful)," Fernando said in an official social media post.

There are actually a lot of videos like that on every social media platform. What's really needed is people to make anti-face shield videos in the hopes that perhaps the people will be better educated on the issue and that  DOH will finally come to reason and abandon that unnecessary requirement.


Do you run a tricycle franchise? Are you hesitant to get vaccinated? Do you live in Dumaguete? If so you might be out of a job soon.


https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1146248

City officials are eyeing the possibility of requiring the vaccination of motorcab-for-hire (MCH ) drivers against coronavirus disease 2019 (Covid-19) as a requisite in the issuance of a franchise to operate units.

This was one of the salient points discussed Tuesday during a meeting between Mayor Felipe Antonio Remollo, the Committee on Transportation and Traffic, and other key city officials to formulate guidelines of an ordinance granting MCH franchises to operators from outside of Dumaguete, a media release on Wednesday said.

Vice Mayor Karissa Tolentino said there are inquiries on how to implement the ordinance.

One of the many reasons this would be a bad policy is that the Philippines is facing a shortage of vaccines. How can one get vaccinated if there are no vaccines? Also the vaccines don't actually immunize anyone. In order to fix the shortage problem Pinoy scientists must work overtime to formulate their own vaccine.


https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1146305

“Our scientists must work double the time…Mag-isip talaga kayo.If you have to pour your, ano, matutunaw yung utak ninyo (You really have to think. If you have to pour your, your brain will melt). You must come up with something to help the Filipino,” he said in a pre-recorded meeting with Partido Demokratiko Pilipino-Lakas ng Bayan (PDP-Laban) executives and other government officials at Malago Clubhouse in Malacañang, Manila on Monday night.

He said he believes the Filipino scientists have the capability to be Covid-19 vaccine self-reliant, noting that the government has allotted enough funds for the purpose.

“We cannot be dependent, ill-afford to just sabihin doon sa ibang tao na ‘Bigyan mo kami, bigyan mo dito (and tell other nations ‘Give us supply’).’ That cannot go on. We must develop,” he added.

Seeing as it takes almost two decades to make a viable vaccine it would probably be better for the Philippines to either reverse engineer the current unapproved yet emergency-authorised vaccines or just manufacture them here.


DND Secretary and Chairman of the National Task Force Against COVID-19 says there is no timeline yet to lifting restrictions. However Dr. Ted Herbosa, an adviser to the NTFA-COVID 19 says once 50 million people have been vaccinated face masks and face shields can come off.


https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1457561/face-masks-shields-off-once-50m-get-shots-says-govt-task-force-adviser

If Filipinos want to end the inconvenience of wearing face shields and masks, about 50 million of them must first be fully inoculated against the coronavirus, meaning about half of the Philippine population should have received two doses of the vaccine against COVID-19.

Dr. Ted Herbosa, adviser to the National Task Force Against COVID-19 (NTF), said Filipinos still have a long way to go before they could get rid of those face coverings because only 3 million had been fully vaccinated as of Thursday.

“The target to advise the removal of the face mask and face shield is 50 percent of the target population, which is about 50 million, between 40 to 50 million,” Herbosa said at Thursday’s Laging Handa briefing.

Meanwhile, everyone has to continue complying with the prescribed health protocols, such as frequent handwashing and avoiding crowded places, Herbosa said.

It was unclear whether the 50-million mark was set by the NTF or the country’s pandemic managers as an official target.

They will surely move this goalpost. The problem is of course getting vaccines into the country and into the provinces. But once vaccines are administered there is the problem of proving that one has been vaccinated if they want to travel.


https://news.abs-cbn.com/video/news/07/09/21/no-signal-weak-internet-hampers-move-to-digitize-vaccination-proof

Here's one challenge facing local government units seeking to allow domestic travel for fully vaccinated residents: weak internet signal can sometimes hamper verification of QR codes or digital vaccination certificates.  

"Kasi kung minsan yang mga QR code, lalo na sa mga boundary ng checkpoint sa land travel ay hindi naman lahat ng lugar sa kalsada ay may signal. So ang hirap nung QR Code na mangangailangan ng internet,” Quirino Gov. Dakila Cua, president of the Union of Local Authorities of the Philippines, said in an interview on TeleRadyo. 

(Sometimes the use of QR code is difficult especially in checkpoint boundaries for land travel as not all areas have signal. So QR codes that need internet is a challenge.)


According to Cabinet Secretary Karlo Nograles, the Philippine government is working on a common digital ID that would serve as proof of an individual's vaccination against COVID-19.

Why does it have to be digital? IT seems that it the problem here. 


How will you know if your neighbor has taken the vaccine? One barangay has the solution.


https://news.abs-cbn.com/news/07/12/21/davao-village-puts-stickers-on-homes-of-vaccinated-residents

Workers in Barangay Lasang, Davao City are visiting homes of vaccinated residents since Thursday to put stickers on their gates and houses. 

This is part of the barangay’s initiative called household tagging and mapping to encourage other residents to get vaccinated against COVID-19. 

Barangay Lasang chairman Allan Simo-ag said the barangay prepared 1,000 stickers. Indicated in each sticker is the name of the household and a checkbox if he or she is already vaccinated with first or second dose. 

As of the latest count, there are 274 residents that have already received anti-COVID-19 vaccines in Barangay Lasang.

How would these stickers encourage anyone to get vaccinated the authorities do not say. Probably they think peer pressure will do them in but there is also the problem of availability and the tiered system. Some folks may not be able to get vaccinated.


Don't think COVID-19 is anywhere near being over. The DOH says cases are high among those 15-19 and below 2.  This is odd because all relevant data says those under 18 are not at high risk for COVID-19 infection. They also say there is a third wave happening.


https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/news/regions/794983/central-visayas-on-3rd-wave-of-covid-19-pandemic-doh-resu-7/story/

Central Visayas is now on the third wave of COVID-19 pandemic, Unang Balita reported on Monday, citing Dr. Eugenia Mercedes Caña, chief of the Department of Health Regional Epidemiology and Surveillance Unit (DOH RESU-7). 

"Yes. We are in a third wave now. We have been monitoring the cases for the last 4 weeks in Central Visayas, not just Cebu City and our epidemic curve shows an upward trend," Caña said in a message. 

Caña said the main reason for the upward trend is the more transmissible variants of the coronavirus that causes COVID-19. 

"The virus keeps on evolving as it is its nature to mutate resulting to different variants which increases the virus' transmissibility," she said. 

Also seen as likely reason for the trend is the gatherings held by some residents like weddings, fiesta and birthday celebrations. 

"These events drive the transmission because you bring people together without observing the public health measures," Caña said. 

Other reasons cited by Caña were inappropriate use of public health and social measures and inequitable and uneven distribution of COVID-19 vaccines. 

Despite this, DOH Region VII said the region is better off now than it was during the second wave of the pandemic in February and March.

It's really hard to judge what they mean by these "waves" as life goes on. Where are all the dead? There aren't many because the virus has an over 90% survival rate.

The government is upset that social influencers were caught partying and ignoring health protocols.

Several social media “influencers” are now in hot water after they were caught in a video partying and drinking alcoholic beverages without social distancing despite threats of COVID-19 inside a bar in Quezon City over the weekend.

Rannie Ludovica, Quezon City’s Task Force Disiplina head, said they will consult with their legal department to ask about how to hold accountable those who were caught violating health protocols inside Ciso Bar in San Francisco Del Monte.

The local government has yet to identify those caught in the video flouting health protocols, but Ludovica said some of them were “sad to say, influencers.” 

He said the establishment violated various COVID-19-related measures, such as by allowing its guests to sit close to each other and without plastic barriers and serving alcoholic beverages without food.

This is actually a good thing. These influencers are showing there is nothing to be scared of. 

Remember when they found a new COVID variant in the Philippines and labelled it the Philippine variant and the DOH got mad about that? Well, now the WHO says don't worry about it.

The World Health Organization (WHO) has downgraded the classification of P.3, a coronavirus variant first detected in the Philippines, from a variant of interest (VOI) to an “alert for further monitoring.” 

The WHO website indicates that P.3 was categorized as a VOI on March 24 this year but was downgraded on July 6.  

“The reason for this is its reported detection has decreased over time,” National Institutes of Health executive director Dr. Eva Maria Cutiongco-de la Paz explained in a Department of Health forum.

Perhaps the Philippine variant will disappear altogether.

Wednesday, July 14, 2021

Two Studies Show the Philippines' Education System Stinks

On June 21, 2021 the World Bank released a report assessing the state of education in the Philippines. Overall the report was bleak and concluded that 80% of Filipino students in grades 4-9  did not meet basic skills levels for their grade. Naturally the Department of Education was furious saying that the report shamed the nation by using old data to paint an inaccurate picture and that the World Bank broke protocol by not notifying the DepEd before the report was released. An apology was demanded and the World Bank acquiesced.

President Duterte welcomed the apology.

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1458818/duterte-welcomes-world-banks-apology-expects-more-accurate-report

President Rodrigo Duterte has welcomed the World Bank’s apology over the early publication of its assessment on the sorry state of Philippine education, expressing hope the financial institution would soon publish a “more accurate” report.

“I would not want to begrudge the World Bank. These international bodies working on the problems of the world should be very careful about their statistics. It is not good to commit a wrong internationally. But we welcome their apology,” Duterte said in his taped weekly briefing that aired Monday night.

The president said the Department of Education (DepEd) would do what it could to correct misconceptions about Filipino students’ performance.

“I commend [DepEd] Secretary Leonor Briones for calling out the World Bank on this issue. I hope a more accurate report based on the latest data will be made,” Duterte said.

It's not clear how much more accurate a report can be made than one which was made from the latest data. In fact the World Bank did not apologize over the data they used but over the technicality of not informing the DepEd before it was released.

https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/statement/2021/07/08/world-bank-philippines-on-education-report-july-8-2021

We deeply regret that the report on education was inadvertently published earlier than scheduled and before the Department of Education had enough chance to provide inputs. This was an oversight on our part, and we conveyed our personal apologies in our communication with the government. Recognizing the inadvertent release of the report, we have taken steps to temporarily remove it from the website. We are aware of the Department’s various efforts and programs to address the challenge of education quality. We agree with the Department that the issue of quality has a long historical context, and support its demonstrated commitment to resolve it decisively. We have reached out to Secretary Briones on this matter and look forward to continuing our dialogue with the Department of Education on the opportunities and challenges in the education sector.

There is nothing in this apology "deeply regretting" the statistics used to compile the report or the report's conclusions. Since the report has now been scrubbed from the internet we can only rely on what others have written about it.

The World Bank report, dated June 21, is available on the World Bank Philippines web page, both in its 86-page complete form and in a user-friendly, presentation format. The report clearly states, in the first two paragraphs of its introduction, what its basis and objective is: It is a synthesis of results from the most recent (2018 and 2019) rounds of three international education assessments in which the Philippines has participated. These are the Program for International Student Assessment (PISA), which the Philippines took part in for the first time in 2018; the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (Timss) in 2019, which the Philippines hasn't participated in since 2003; and the Southeast Asia Primary Learning Metrics (SEA-PLM) in 2019, which was the first and so far, only time that assessment has been conducted. Far from being "old data," the data specified by the report is the newest data available, and its synthesis of the results of those three assessments "represent the pre-Covid baseline," the report explains.

The picture it paints of the state of Philippine education is shockingly dark. Overall, about 80 percent of Filipino students in Grades 4 through 9 "are unable to meet learning standards expected for their grade."

This is not the opinion of the World Bank researchers but the unalloyed scores of the three assessments. In reading, 90 percent of Grade 5 students in the SEA-PLM and 81 percent of Grade 9 students in the PISA were "below minimum proficiency." In mathematics, the "below minimum proficiency" levels were 81 percent for Grade 4 students in the Timss, 83 percent for Grade 5 students in the SEA-PLM, and 81 percent for Grade 9 students in the PISA. In science, 87 percent of Grade 4 students in the Timss assessment were below the minimum standard, as were 78 percent of Grade 9 students in the PISA.

https://www.manilatimes.net/2021/07/08/opinion/columns/briones-is-an-embarrassment/1806126

DepEd Secretary Briones complianed that the data from 2019 was old and therefore outdated but the World Bank says it is the latest available information. Briones completely misrepresents the World Bank when she writes:

The use of 2019 old PISA data was admitted by the Senior Economist of the World Bank in a note to an Undersecretary of Education, thus: “Please know that the full report contents are derived from published PISA scores and I hope this can be useful in your response to those asking questions, these are not new findings but data that have been previously published when PISA was published.” 

The World Bank admits to one error: the release of old data based on 2019 PISA scores to the public without informing DepEd. Thus, DepEd and the Philippine government were subjected to public censure and criticism. Even if done inadvertently, the World Bank has inflicted harm on DepEd and the government.

The use of this data was not an error nor did the World Bank admit it was such but rather they only admitted they erred in not informing the DepEd of the report before its publication. Perhaps Briones should apologize to the World Bank for her blatant mischaracterization of both the report and the apology. She also laments that the World Bank neglected the historical context of education in the Philippines.

The report also lacked historical context. The quality of education, at all levels, is a product of a long historical process. The World Bank itself is a party to this historical evolution, being a lender for major reform programs, such as the USD100 million Program for Decentralized Educational Development (PRODED) from 1981 to 1986, the USD113 million Third Elementary Education Project (TEEDP) from 1997 to 2006, the USD200 million National Program Support for Basic Education (NPSBE) from 2006 to 2011, and more recently, the USD300 million Learning Equity and Accountability Program Support (LEAPS) from 2014 to 2018. Giving a snapshot of the current situation without its historical context can easily give the impression that it is the present administration that is to blame, and not mentioning current initiatives can further give the impression that we are not doing anything about it.

If we must look at the broad picture as viewed across time rather than particular measurements to gain a proper assessment of the Philippines' education system then the question we must ask is, "Why hasn't Philippine education improved over time?" Where has all that money gone? What does the Philippines have to show for it? According to the most recent assessment tests, nothing. And it is not just the World Bank that is reporting that fact.

Acquiescing to the demand of two senior members of President Duterte’s Cabinet, the World Bank (WB) has publicly apologized for the publication of its report highlighting the sorry state of Philippine education.

But the Washington-based multilateral lender did not retract its findings that indicated “a crisis in education” and that are based on the latest global assessments in which the Philippines took part before the COVID-19 pandemic.

Meanwhile, a report of the Tokyo-based think tank Asian Development Bank Institute (ADBI) also lamented the “low” amount of learning—especially in mathematics when taught in local dialects—in the Philippines, despite gains from the K-12 basic education program since 2012, which narrowed the reading skills gap between students in rich and poor households.

ADBI said that “considering the Philippines’ status as a low-middle-income country, improving the quality of the education system must remain a matter of national priority.”

ADBI cited the same problems in the Philippines’ education sector.

It based its working paper titled “Foundational Mathematics and Reading Skills of Filipino Students Over a Generation” on the results of the Functional Literacy, Education, Mass Media Survey (FLEMMS), a national household survey that the Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA) had been conducting nationwide every five years since 1998.

The FLEMMS microdata collected by the PSA in 2003, 2013 and 2019 and that were used by the ADBI paper showed that “the share of students with foundational skills increases between grades, indicating that schooling improves learning,” specifically referring to math and reading skills.

“However, we find that a substantial share of Grade 10 students still do not have foundational mathematics or reading skills. This shows that like many countries, the amount of learning produced for each year of schooling in the Philippines is very low,” ADBI said.

It said the FLEMMS-based math learning profile showed a decline of 5 percentage points in 2019 from 2013 levels. “Among Grade 10 students, 93 percent of students in the 2013 cohort answered the mathematics questions correctly. In 2019, the share was 88 percent,” ADBI noted.

It said the decline “corroborated the TIMSS results.” But “different from TIMSS, … we determined that the decline between 2013 and 2019 was four times as severe compared to the decline between 2003 and 2013,” ADBI said, referring to the math results.

This paper from the Asian Development Bank Institute was based on the PSA's own data which it has been collecting every five years since 1998. The results show that "the amount of learning produced for each year of schooling in the Philippines is very low." This paper appears to have been scrubbed from the web but a web cache shows the abstract which is as follows:

Children around the world largely rely on the formal educational system to teach them foundational mathematics and reading skills. The inability of an educational system to do so may indicate it has structural constraints. In this paper, we take advantage of three rounds of a nationally representative household survey on education and functional literacy implemented by the Philippine Statistics Authority to examine mastery of foundational mathematics and reading skills among students in grades 4–10 students. The three rounds enable us to examine trends in these skills from the turn of the millennium to 2019. We find that a significant proportion of higher-grade students have not yet mastered these foundational skills. We also find that the difference in foundational skills between grade 10 and grade 4 students is small. Based on a comparison between cohorts, we find that foundational mathematics skills continued to decline between the 2003 and 2019 cohorts. Foundational reading skills, however, trended up between 2013 and 2019 after stagnating between 2003 and 2013. The latter is suggestive evidence that major educational reforms implemented by the Philippine government since 2012 may have successfully improved reading skills but not mathematics skills. Overall, the Philippine basic education system, building on its success in increasing access to education for virtually all children, still has ample room to significantly improve its effectiveness.

Math skills have decreased while reading skills have slightly increased. But overall there is ample room for improvement. After all, there is not much difference between the foundational skills of a 10th grader and a 4th grader. 

This paper takes into account the historical context of which Briones says is necessary to understand the Philippine education system. Over two decades the Philippines has not seen much improvement in the education system. Filipino students remain behind their peers. One has to ask why. Why, after all the programs implemented and money spent on improving the education system, do Filipinos lag behind the rest of the world? That is not a question I am going to answer but it is a problem the DepEd must solve. Otherwise the DepEd will only continue to inflict harm on Filipino children by giving them a worthless education. Too bad the government prefers to huff and puff in a vain effort to save face before the international community. Everyone can see the egg on this country's face.