Week 10 of Vice President Sara Duterte's impeachment trial focused once more on her use of confidential funds. The prosecution called PSA Assistant National Statistician Marizza Grande to the stand. She testified that 37 of the recipients of confidential funds were dead.
| https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/2300322/37-alleged-recipients-of-sara-dutertes-secret-funds-are-dead-psa |
Government records showed that 37 alleged recipients of confidential funds released to Vice President Sara Duterte are already dead, an official of the Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA) told the Senate impeachment court on Monday.
At the resumption of Duterte’s impeachment trial, the prosecution team presented PSA Assistant National Statistician Marizza Grande— its 10th witness for Article 1, which pertains to Duterte’s alleged misuse of confidential funds.
During her direct examination of the witness, private prosecutor Mae Divinagracia inquired about the PSA’s reply to the House committee on justice’s request to ‘re-verify” the single-match entries of the alleged recipients of Duterte’s confidential funds.
"Based on our re-verification of the single-match entries, we found that some of the names under the OVP (Office of the Vice President) had records indicating that the individuals were already deceased. We found official death certificates for 32 of the names," Grande said during the direct examination of private prosecutor Mae Divinagracia.
"The other list, pertaining to the DepEd list naman, had five official death certificates that we found in the CRS (Civil Registry System) database," Gandered said.
Duterte concurrently served as secretary of the Department Education (DepEd) from 2022 to 2024.Divinagracia earlier noted that the OVP listed 1, 992 recipients of its P500 million in confidential funds while DepEd’s P112.5 million supposedly went to 677 recipients.
The witness later confirmed the information contained in some of the death certificates presented by the private prosecutor to the court.
One of them was Fortunato Salig, who supposedly received a P200,000 reward.
Citing PSA records, however, Grande said Salig already died on June 29, 2011.
A certain Emilio Sagan also supposedly received P70,000 “for the purchase of information,” although PSA data indicated he passed on July 28, 2015.
"How long had Emilio Sagan been dead as of 2022?," Divinagracia asked.
In response, the witness said Sagan had been dead for seven years in 2022. He died at the age of 49, Grande added.
Another death certificate indicated that a certain Rodolfo Traya died on May 04, 2021, and yet he was listed as a recipient of a confidential fund worth P120,000.
Not only did dead men receive confidential funds but so did a few infants. A total of 25 minors received confidential funds.
| https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/2300352/25-payees-of-ovp-deped-confidential-funds-were-minors-psa |
Some recipients of the confidential funds disbursed by the Office of the Vice President (OVP) and the Department of Education (DepEd) were notably minors, a statistician said on the 22nd day of Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial on Monday.
Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA) assistant national statistician Marizza Grande, one of the prosecution’s witnesses against Duterte, noted there were single-match entries, suggesting several minors were among the recipients of the OVP and DepEd’s confidential funds.
A single-match entry refers to a single or isolated record or hit on one specific individual, while a multiple-match entry refers to several records, and a no-match entry.
"Based on our verification, we found that, according to the records, there are 20 minors on the OVP list," said Gande.
"Regarding the DepEd list, based on the records, five individuals are minors according to their birth certificates," she added.
Among the names used in the acknowledgement receipts cited by the prosecution were as follows:
- Miko Alquizar – received P400,000 in confidential funds on March 28, 2023; born June 11, which makes him one year old at the time.
- Beatrice Cuenca – received P400 in confidential funds on March 13, 2023; born Jan. 7, 2022, which makes her one year old at the time.
- Mikay delos Reyes – received P200,000 in confidential funds on March 27, 2023; born Jan. 13, 2020, which makes her three years old at the time.
Asked who among the recorded minors was the youngest, Grande said someone whose records showed the person was only two months old—an individual named Marlin Sunga.
Oddly enough, the same records showed that Sunga was born in 1965 and died in the same year, on Nov. 2.
Grande, however, clarified that all this information was based on PSA records, adding that she could not categorically state that they were indeed the payees of the OVP and DepEd.
One of these infants was born and died in the year 1965. Clearly there is funny business going on. The defense claims these names are all aliases but the real names should be along side any alias and there are no other names in the files. There is also the issue of similar signatures. An infant who died in 1965 can't write his signature.
For 1,685 names there is no civil registry match in the Philippines Statistics Authority.
| https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1283458 |
The Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA) found no matching birth, marriage or death records for 1,685 names submitted for verification from confidential fund payee lists of Vice President Sara Duterte’s Office of the Vice President and the Department of Education, Assistant National Statistician Marizza Grande told the Senate impeachment court Monday.
The total comprises 1,287 names from the OVP’s 1,992-name list and 398 from DepEd’s 677-name list.
Grande’s testimony detailed the searches behind the certifications, including the separate verification of Mary Grace Piattos, and the records later generated for names that produced matches.
Private prosecutor Mae Divinagracia’s presentation also cited at least 37 names matching people already dead and 25 matching children.
Grande subsequently described the death and birth records supporting those categories during questioning by the prosecution.
“Based on the information provided and our database, there is no record of birth, no record of marriage, and no record of death for Mary Grace Piattos,” Grande said.
Questioned by Divinagracia, Grande identified the PSA’s Nov. 25, 2024 reply and accompanying certification concerning Piattos. She also explained that each negative result referred to a separate category of civil registry document searched in the agency’s Civil Registry System, or CRS.
The searches covered all 2,669 submitted names. Grande explained that checking marriage records could account for surname changes, while a death record might exist even when the corresponding birth had not been registered.
“Based on the provided list of names, we conducted individual database searches across our birth, marriage and death records,” she said.
Grande distinguished three possible outcomes: a single matching entry, multiple matching entries, or a negative result.
These categories allowed the PSA to separate names with no matching records from names shared by several people and names producing only one relevant record.
For Jason Ramos, the database returned 907 most likely birth-record matches, 305 marriage-record matches and 53 death-record matches. Grande explained that the name was common and corresponded to multiple people in the database.
Abigail Deomampo, by contrast, produced one most likely birth-record match. Grande described that result against a database containing approximately 143 million birth records.
“It means that there is only one record in the CRS database, this is a unique record or a single match in the database,” she said.
The PSA transmitted its findings through official replies and certifications.
That so many people have no vital records is unfounded.
Assistant National Statistician Marizza Grande made the assessment during the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Z. Duterte after Senate President Win Gatchalian asked whether a person with no record of any of the three major vital events could still exist.
“The chance is very slim because even if a person has no birth certificate, there are people who eventually marry. Or if they die, registration is mandatory,” Grande said.
She said at least one vital event would normally leave a record that could help establish a person’s existence.
Gatchalian asked Grande to clarify whether, based on her 25 years of experience at the PSA, it would be difficult for a person to leave no birth, marriage or death record at all.
“Yes po, Your Honor,” Grande replied.
But, as with previous weeks testimony was cut short. This time so the defense and the prosecution can mark financial records.
| https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1283531 |
The Senate impeachment court on Tuesday suspended hearings for two days to allow the prosecution and defense to sort and mark more than 1,800 bank, insurance, and other financial records ahead of the unexplained wealth phase of Vice President Sara Duterte’s trial.
Presiding officer Francis “Chiz” Escudero said no trial would be held Wednesday and Thursday, with proceedings set to resume Monday, Sept. 14.
“There will be no trial tomorrow (Wednesday) in order to afford the parties time to mark the voluminous documents on the succeeding articles. And the same is true for Thursday,” Escudero said.
House of Representatives prosecutor Akbayan Party-list Rep. Chel Diokno earlier asked the court to devote the two days to exhibit marking, saying more than 1,800 documents had been produced in response to subpoenas issued by the impeachment court.
“There are over 1,800 exhibits, documents that were submitted under the subpoenas released by this court,” Diokno said.
“I am referring, Your Honor, to the bank records and other insurance records, and we need time to mark those documents.”
Defense counsel Michael Poa raised no objection to setting aside the hearing days for both camps to mark their respective documents.
The financial records are expected to figure prominently as prosecutors prepare to present evidence under Article II involving allegations of unexplained wealth.
The defense earlier sought at least two weeks to study the voluminous records, but Escudero cited the Senate’s tight schedule as it simultaneously conducts deliberations on the proposed 2027 national budget.
Instead, the court said it would give the defense flexibility in cross-examining prosecution witnesses while allowing the prosecution to proceed with succeeding witnesses when necessary.
Escudero said the marking sessions would start at 10 a.m., with logistical arrangements being made alongside ongoing budget hearings.
“You see the logistical problem we're facing given the budget deliberations because we are short of hand,” he said.
Diokno was also directed to submit the prosecution’s list of witnesses for the following week, along with any requests for subpoenas or proposed stipulations, to allow the trial to proceed as scheduled on Monday.
This trial is going at a snails pace. At least they have released a schedule from now through November.
| https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/2301305/senate-sets-vp-impeach-trial-schedule-for-september-november |
The schedule of the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte from September to November was set by the Senate impeachment court on Tuesday.
Presiding officer and Senator – judge Francis Escudero announced the trial schedule in the following months as follows:
Trial from 10 a.m. to 2:30 p.m, plenary at 3 p.m.
- September 8, 9
- September 14-16
- September 21-23
- September 28-30
Whole day trial
- October 1, 2
- October 5-9
- October 12-15
No trial to make way for 2027 budget hearings
- October 16 to November 8
No trial for budget debates in plenary
- November 9 to 18
After the Senate defends its version of the 2027 budget, the impeachment trial will return to its “regular programming” on November 19, 20, or November 24.
Duterte’s trial schedule coincides with that of the second regular session of Congress, as well as its hearings on the 2027 national budget.
They are taking off a whole month for budget deliberations. And then what? The Christmas holiday is soon after that. Even with 11 whole days of trial scheduled in October this circus won't be finished until February at the earliest.