Friday, February 8, 2019

Retards in the Government 88

It's your weekly compendium of foolishness and corruption and murder in Philippine politics. 



https://www.rappler.com/nation/222454-bernard-madamba-ambushed-subic-january-2019
In a report by Chief Inspector Jude Bryan B. Maguddayao, acting police chief of Subic Municipal Police Station, the victim was identified as Bernard F. Madamba, 46 years old, former barangay kagawad and a tricycle driver, and resident of P-3, Brgy. Wawandue, Subic. 
Madamba was driving his tricycle along the road of Sitio Cabangaan, Brgy. Cawag with 3 passengers around 5 pm Thursday when suddenly, a blue Toyota Innova with no plate number blocked their path. 
The unidentified suspects alighted from their vehicle and fired two shots at Madamba.  
Madamba's passengers, on the other hand, ran for cover and were unharmed.
Another cold and brutal killing.
https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1080272/drug-cop-slain-in-laguna-buy-bust
A policeman assigned at the Laguna police headquarters in Sta. Cruz town was killed in an anti-drug operation on Friday morning. 
Police Officer 3 Jennyson Soriano, 45, a resident of Pagsanjan town, had been involved in the narcotics trade, particularly in the fourth district of the province and acted either as “pusher or protector,” Laguna police director Sr. Supt. Eleazar Matta said. 
“(Soriano was assigned) here in my headquarters as (part of the) base police,” Matta said in a text message. 
Soriano also allegedly carried the alias “Sir” in the illegal drugs trade.
Another ironic and isolated incident of a PNP officer charged with upholding the law breaking it and making the PNP look bad.  Good-bye to this singular bad egg.

https://cebudailynews.inquirer.net/214995/police-raid-gambling-dens-in-cebu-city-frequented-by-prominent-persons-and-politicians-in-cebu
After weeks of sleuthing, the Cebu City police busted two illegal gambling dens said to be frequented by “prominent” personalities, including politicians, in Cebu. 
Caught in the act of engaging in high-stake poker games or attending to gamblers were a total of 23 persons during simultaneous raids at dawn of January 31 inside a wine shop in Barangay Kamputhaw and in a two-storey building in Barangay Guadalupe. 
None of those arrested, however, were political figures in Cebu.
One would think "after weeks of sleuthing" the PNP would know the proper time to bust the joint and catch thebig fish swimming in this pond. But no.

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1080229/ping-pork-per-house-member-increased-to-p160-million
Sen. Panfilo “Ping” Lacson, a member of the Senate panel on the budget conference committee, said on Thursday members of the House were actually getting P160 million, and not just P60 million, worth of projects in the spending bill approved by the House. 
Lacson said the National Expenditure Program (NEP), which was prepared by the executive branch, had P100 million worth of projects embedded in it for every member of the House. 
The allocation consisted of P70 million in “hard” projects, which usually refer to infrastructure projects, and P30 million in “soft” projects, which usually cover financial assistance programs. 
Speaker Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo then added P60 million to the allocation for her colleagues, Lacson said.
Messed up if true but not surprising either. How is this problem still there and how has it increased when the budget has been discussed and debated for the past few weeks?

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1080880/explain-p190-b-budget-insertions-senators-urged
It's simple. The Hosue has their pork and the Senate has their pork. To each his oink! Year of the pig indeed!

https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2019/02/04/1890630/107-local-officials-ordered-explain-manila-bay-pollution
The Department of the Interior and Local Government will issue show cause orders to 107 local government officials, including two mayors in Metro Manila, for their alleged failure to prevent the pollution of Manila Bay, DILG Undersecretary for barangay affairs Martin Diño said yesterday. 
Diño said the local officials will be made to explain why they should not be held liable for failure to strictly enforced provisions of Republic Act 9003 or the Ecological Solid Waste Management Act of 2001. 
“We will also be filing administrative cases against them before the Office of the Ombudsman,” he said in a phone interview.
A law from 2001 and they are just now enforcing it? HA!
https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1081758/andaya-dbm-generated-p370b-pork-in-2017-more-in-2018
The Department of Budget and Management (DBM) has generated some P370-billion “pork” in 2017 and more in 2018, which could be used to “sway the outcome” of the May polls, House appropriations panel chair Rolando Andaya Jr. claimed Tuesday. 
Andaya said he has documents to show that the DBM generated a total of P370 billion in savings in 2017, which is at the full disposal of Budget Secretary Benjamin Diokono. 
“Documents in our possession show that for 2017, a total of P370 billion was generated in savings. This amount was at the full disposal of Secretary Diokno,” Andaya said in a statement. 
“We also know that the amount for 2018 savings is higher. More than enough to sway the outcome of the 2019 elections, if he wants to,” he added.
The amount of pork people are being accused of hoarding for themselves keeps growing and growing. If these allegations are true and there is that much savings then that means there is no reason to borrow from China or raise excise taxes.

https://news.abs-cbn.com/news/02/05/19/nothing-illegal-with-premature-campaigning-comelec-reiterates
"Because it is coming out before the start of the campaign period then automatically it is considered as premature campaigning," Jimenez told ANC's "Beyond Politics." 
"It's not illegal. It's not punishable by law. You might not like that it's being done, you might find it distasteful, but technically there is no violation of the law," he added. 
Jimenez, however, clarified that once the campaign period starts on Feb. 12 for senatorial and party-list candidates, all campaign materials earlier posted would be considered in violation of the law. 
"There's no way that can be legal once the campaign period starts," he said.
The Comelec's rules on premature campaigning are confusing. Right now all these tarps are fine but come February 12th they all become illegal? Why aren't they illegal now? Just make premature campaigning an offence that renders anyone's candidacy ineligible.
https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1082274/house-committees-clear-lapena-of-drug-smuggling
Two House of Representatives committees on Wednesday did not find former Bureau of Customs (BoC) Chief Isidro Lapeña liable in connection with the entry of billions of pesos worth of illegal drugs shipments to the country last year.
Does this mean the charges filed against Lapeña by the NBI are now moot and tossed out the window?
https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1082389/zambales-village-chief-nabbed-for-illegal-possession-of-firearms
Found in the house of Eduardo Lopez Sr., 61, a resident of Barangay Aglao, were several unregistered firearms, including a .45-caliber Colt pistol, a .25-caliber pistol, and a gauge shotgun.  
Police also recovered from Lopez’s possession more than 200 live ammunition.  
The village official is facing charges for illegal possession of firearms and ammunition and violation of the Commission on Elections (Comelec) gun ban.  
That is a nice weapons cache.

https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/news/regions/683990/sangguniang-bayan-secretary-shot-dead-in-north-cotabato/story/
Chief Inspector Rolly Oranza, President Roxas Police chief, identified the victim as Robert Herbilla, 43, SB Secretary of the Local Government Unit and residence of Barangay Poblacion. 
Oranza said that based on their investigation, at least four suspects barged inside the Herbilla's house and without saying a single word shot him several times. 
Herbilla residence was raided by the police in December last year due to his alleged involvement to illegal drugs. He was arrested and was out on bail when shot.
Another local official assassinated but this situation is likely drug related.

https://globalnation.inquirer.net/172963/locsin-denies-chinese-workers-taking-jobs-from-filipinos
“Chill out. New Chinese get in via ‘visas upon arrival’ strictly administered by Immigration (not DFA) and do not take jobs from Filipinos,” Locsin said in a tweet. 
Locsin’s remark was contrary from Sen. Joel Villanueva’s findings which found that some 119,000 Chinese tourists were able to work in the Philippines by circumventing labor rules.
Again we have a bureaucrat spotting off his opinions which are at odds with another politician's findings. Remember when he tweeted that all the DFA's passport records were stolen which started a national panic and then he said he was wrong about that? 

https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/news/nation/684141/china-sends-militia-amid-phl-construction-on-pag-asa-island/story/
China has deployed as many as 95 ships near the Spratly Islands after the Philippines started construction projects on Pagasa Island, a report by a Washington-based think tank has indicated. 
The Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative (AMTI) of the US Center for Strategic and International Studies said the fleet included a mixture of fishing, law enforcement, and naval vessels in what has been called the "cabbage strategy." 
AMTI used photo capture from satellite images to confirm the presence of the vessels.
China builds in the WPS and the Palace says its great and we should all be thankful but the Philippines attempts to build on their own territory in the WPS and China acts aggressive sending in all kinds of ships to form a blockade! Maybe the Philippines should be thankful they sent so many ships?

https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/news/nation/684116/mom-of-17-yr-old-dota-player-killed-in-alleged-shootout-files-murder-raps-vs-pangasinan-cops/story/
The mother of the 17-year-old boy killed in an alleged shootout with policemen in Rosales, Pangasinan last year filed murder charges at the Office of the Ombudsman on Thursday against the cops involved in the incident.
The Philippines' justice system really does need an overhaul. Mothers should not be filing murder raps against the police. Such charges should be the outcome of an investigation by the DA but there are no DA's in the Philippines.


The national budget debacle is pretty scandalous. It is February and a budget has still not been passed! There are two articles above about the the pork inserted in the budget but let's take a look at this series of article and the story they tell.

https://news.mb.com.ph/2019/02/07/tinio-confirms-p160-million-pork-per-congressman-parked-in-2019-budget/
“Totoo yun, (That’s true)” Tinio told reporters amid the earlier pronouncement of Majority Leader and Cadiz Rep. Fredenil Castro that the P160-million allocation per congressman in the 2019 budget is “not pork.” 
“We confirm na nandyan ang P160-million allocation per representative. Bahagi ito ng kabuuang pork barrel insertions ng Senate, House at Malacanang ng 2019 budget na nais nila i-approve bukas,” he said.
http://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1061098
Kung nararapat, at kung talagang maliwanag na pork, bakit hindi? Dapat i-veto (If it is necessary, and if it is clearly pork, why not? It should be vetoed),” Sotto said in an ambush interview. 
“At this point hindi namin talaga alam kung alin ang pork at hindi. Alam lang namin sa Senate, ano yung mga institutional amendments (At this point, we really do not know which one is a pork [insertion] or not. As far as the Senate is concerned, we only know the institutional amendments),” he added.
https://www.philstar.com/business/2019/02/06/1891371/andaya-house-may-elevate-supreme-court-possible-duterte-veto-vs-pork
Lawmakers would run to the Supreme Court to seek “clarification” should President Rodrigo Duterte decide to veto the “pork” funds allegedly inserted in the P3.757-trillion budget for 2019, a House leader said Wednesday. 
“I am in full support of the call for the president to use his line-item veto power to remove all pork barrel insertions in the 2019 national budget,” Andaya said. “A veto message prepared by Sec. Diokno will surely perpetuate these unanswered issues, unfortunately with the president as unwitting victim.” 
“The House panel will elevate the veto message to the Supreme Court to clarify, not to defy, the veto message. We need to know the clear implications of the line items to be vetoed,” the lawmaker added.
The story here is unbelievable. The Senate and the House are both admitting the existence of massive amounts of pork in the budget BUT they both want Duterte to line-item veto every instance of pork! They are passing the buck to the President instead of doing their jobs. Does Duterte have time to figure out which is which? Of course not. I bet these politicians are counting on there being so much noise that no one will figure out what is going on. The Senate is willing to pass the budget as is, pork and all, and let Duterte do their work for them. Amazing!

Thursday, February 7, 2019

Reservoir of Rabies

Dogs. Stray dogs. All over the Philippines. An epidemic.  An infestation.


If you have followed this blog or if you actually live here you would know that stray dogs are quite the problem in the Philippines! Now it's a new year and new goals have been set. Goals to stem the tide against the "reservoir of rabies"!

http://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1060830
Majority of dogs that have not been vaccinated against rabies in Iloilo province are stray, making them a “virus reservoir”, the Provincial Veterinary Office (PVO) warned on Friday. 
Last year, the province, including municipalities and barangays, targeted to vaccinate 70 percent of its dog population. 
Given that this goal has been reached, the remaining 30 percent continues to pose a challenge, PVO Veterinarian, Dr. Darel Tabuada, said in an interview. 
“The 30 percent unvaccinated dogs are most likely be made up of stray dogs,” Tabuada said, adding that they continue their campaign to local government units to widen their dog vaccination coverage to prevent the rabies virus from spreading. 
He called the unvaccinated strays  “virus reservoir” that can transmit the virus to other dogs through biting.
Woof, woof! Oh but guess what? If you get bit you might be out of luck!
https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/news/metro/683473/hospital-reports-fake-rabies-vaccine-sues-distributor/story/
The hospital has reached out to almost 2,000 patients who were administered the fake vaccine to examine and vaccinate them. It has also filed criminal charges against Geramil Trading.  
“We did our obligation to tell the public that this thing is happening and I would now like to put the burden on the Department of Health, that this is a public health issue that should be addressed and confronted,” said The Medical City CEO Dr. Eugenio Ramos. 
The DOH said that the fake vaccine has no ill effects, apart from not being a real vaccine to protect one from rabies. 
Let me get this straight. Being injected with a fake vaccine which is made of who-knows-what will have no adverse effects on your body? Is it just a saline solution? Hopefully the rabies vaccine for dogs is not fake or else one city will not be able to meet its goals to vaccinate 20,000 dogs this year.

http://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1059519
Last year, the CVO was able to vaccinate 19,625 out of the total 20,816 dogs in the city, which is a 94 percent accomplishment rate. 
High density anti-rabies vaccination is an annual activity of the CVO that seeks to maintain Legazpi’s status as a zero-rabies locality. 
Aside from vaccinating dogs, Andes said her office will also conduct all year round impounding of stray dogs to prevent the spread of rabies in the community.
The dogs the city wishes to vaccinate most of all have owners. What is great about this program is the plan to impound stray dogs. It is stray dogs that are the problem. Digging through trash, messing everywhere, biting people on occasion, breeding like mad, and generally causing a ruckus. Is any neighbourhood in this country free from stray dogs? Rounding them up and putting them far away from society sounds like a wonderful idea and the first step to a healthy environment.

Godspeed to Legazpi and Iloilo Cities and their efforts to vaccinate dogs and stem the tide of the "reservoir of rabies."

Wednesday, February 6, 2019

Trucks of Garbage

Could it be that the current zeitgeist in the Philippines is that pollution and littering is bad and it's high time to clean up all the trash?  The Manila Bay clean up netted 45 tons of garbage! That is both awesome and disgusting. Now other regions are getting into the spirit and cleaning up their polluted water ways.

http://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1060906
Around 700 volunteers joined the clean-up drive on Sunday along the coast of heavily polluted Panalaron Bay and Mangon-bangon creek in this city. 
Although not all solid wastes were removed during the three-hour cleanup, organizers said they are happy with the outcome. 
“At least we’re able to raise awareness on the value of cleaning our bays and waterways. This is in support to the program of President Rodrigo Duterte to rehabilitate the polluted bodies of water,” said An Waray founder Bem Noel, one of the event organisers. 
The activity collected at least five truckloads of garbage. 
Joining the drive were the Maritime Group of the Philippine National Police, Sangyaw Foundation Incorporated, Rotary Club of Ormoc Bay, San Juanico Eagles Club, Boy Scout of the Philippines, Tau Gamma Sigma members, students of Eastern Visayas State Universities, Carigara School of Fisheries Alumni Association members, villages officials and An Waray party-list volunteers.
That is a lot of garbage. Five truck loads! Even the AFP has gotten into the spirit.
http://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1060828
Former members of the Moro Islamic Liberation Front and the Bangsamoro Islamic Freedom Fighters also took part in the campaign.  
“The project aims to sustain cleanliness, beautification, and sanitation in the municipalities through an active and continuing partnership among government agencies as part of the clean and green campaign of the national government,” Catu said in a statement.
Great! Even terrorists are pitching in and picking up the trash.
These beautification projects are a real testament to how polluted the waterways and highways of this country are. Hey fun fact! If all the garbage from all the waterways in the Philippines were removed then flooding would be reduced dramatically!
https://www.sunstar.com.ph/article/1752637
Garbage is still one of the reasons why Cagayan de Oro City is vulnerable to street flooding, and this was seen during the de-clogging operation in the flood-prone Villarin Street, Barangay Carmen where tons of garbage were collected. 
Not just Cagayan de Oro!

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/918666/floods-made-worse-by-garbage-ecowaste
A waste and pollution watchdog deplored on Saturday the reckless waste disposal of cities in Metro Manila which worsened the floods triggered by monsoon rains enhanced by Typhoon Gorio (international name: Nesat). 
“The rainwater will not drain fast enough to Pasig River and its tributaries if the storm drains and creeks are clogged with trash,” said Daniel Alejandre, Zero Waste Campaigner of EcoWaste Coalition. 
Alejandre pointed out that many are yet to realize how waste disposal could affect them. 
“It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to grasp the need to keep the waterways free of rubbish and debris to allow the water to freely flow and minimize flooding, but many have yet to realize what we recklessly throw on the ground or estero (creek) will come back to haunt and harm us,” he said.
Are there any rocket scientists in the Philippines? Are there any Filipinos concerned about these kind of effects garbage has on the environment or are they just happy to get rid of their garbage? Only a fool would spurn these projects.

And only a fool would rest on their laurels without instituting programs designed to instill an anti-littering mindset in the population.

There is a lot of work to be done. In fact there is so much work to be done that the Office of the President has taken over all the reclamation projects in the country. Nice to have it all centralised and streamlined right?
https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1081560/palace-takes-over-all-reclamation-projects-in-the-country
The Office of the President (OP) now has direct control and supervision over the Philippine Reclamation Authority (PRA), which has jurisdiction over 43 reclamation projects in Manila Bay alone. 
One reclamation project has been awarded to Dennis Uy, a businessman from Davao City who has close ties to President Rodrigo Duterte.  
The 265-hectare project, called Pasay Harbor City, is estimated to cost P62 billion. 
The President has issued Executive Order (EO) No. 74 delegating the power of the President to approve reclamation projects to the PRA Governing Board. 
EO 74 repealed directives that placed the PRA under the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR).
Dennis Uy? The billionaire Davao businessman and friend of Duterte whose company Misatel just happened to win the contract for the nation's third telecom which just so happens to be linked to Chinese interests? That Dennis Uy? And now he has won a contract worth P62 billion to clean up Pasay Harbor City?

Which other friends of Duterte will be receiving massive contracts for reclamation projects?

Only in the Philippines can an environmental project stink to high heaven of corruption!

Tuesday, February 5, 2019

Martial Law: Whitewash

An explosive and chaotic week in Mindanao commenced with the bombing of The Cathedral of Our Lady of Mount Carmel  in Jolo just days after the BOL was ratified. The story is still being unravelled but it appears this bombing is the second Marawi incident warned about by the AFP and PNP last year though of course not in scope and intensity but certainly in that there were prior warnings and lapses in security just like the first Marawi. Following on the heels of this attack a peace consultant for the NDFP was shot in the face point blank as he slept on a bus which set the communists in an uproar. All the while the Supreme Court began hearing oral arguments on the validity of the third extension of martial law. With so much happening it will be best to succinctly break down each incident to show how they connect and where everything is headed.

First the bombing in Jolo.

https://www.rappler.com/nation/222109-jolo-bombing-january-2019-what-we-know
The attack was executed with two improvised explosive devices (IED) detonated at the Cathedral of Our Lady of Mount Carmel in Jolo. The cathedral was filled with around 100 Mass-goers.  
At around 8:58 am, while the Second Reading was being read, the first IED inside the cathedral was detonated, injuring scores of Mass-goers and alarming military and police officers stationed outside
Just as soldiers and cops rushed to enter the cathedral, the second IED exploded at the church's entrance.  
"The second [IED exploded] after around 12 to 15 seconds," police chief Director General Oscar Albayalde said in an interview with reporters at the blast site the day after the attack. 
Most of the security personnel who were hurt by the blast are from the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP), as they were tasked, according to Albayalde, to secure the "inner perimeter" of the cathedral. This setup has made AFP personnel closer responders, and now, victims.
With security personnel tasked to guard the inner and outer permitter of the church as well as PNP and AFP officers being dispersed through out the city at various checkpoints they fact that anyone was able to sneak a bomb past them is mind boggling. But not really. It's the same old story as in Marawi: security lapses.
https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2019/01/28/1888905/palace-admits-security-lapses-may-have-led-jolo-cathedral-bombings
"We will have to investigate how it happened. There may be some lapses in security. How they were able to put there — is that a motorcycle with a bomb — despite the fact that there were soldiers securing the place," Panelo said in a press briefing.  
"There is no other conclusion to reach.  If you have security there and there is one or two bombs being placed inside, then there must be a lapse in security. There is no other reasonable conclusion," he added.
It remains to be seen if bombs were even placed anywhere as, after first denying, the government is now confirming that this bombing was the handiwork of two Indonesian suicide bombers. A husband and wife team.
https://www.rappler.com/nation/222473-ano-sources-say-jolo-suicide-bombers-indonesians
Interior Secretary Eduardo Año said initial information from sources identified two Indonesians behind the deadly Jolo Cathedral bombing. 
Año, on Friday, February 1, emphasized that this piece of information must still be verified. 
"Ang talagang nagpasabog doon ay Indonesian suicide bombers (The ones behind the bombings are Indonesian suicide bombers)," he said in the Barangay Summit on Peace and Order in Palo, Leyte. 
"Hindi pa tapos yung ginagawang investigation but I have sources na itong pagsabog ay project ng Abu Sayyaf at itong foreign terrorist na related sa ISIS (Islamic State group)," he later on said in an interview with reporters. 
(The investigation is not over but I have sources who said the bombing was a project of Abu Sayyaf and this foreign terrorist related to ISIS.
Año said information from his sources matched details made public by President Rodrigo Duterte – that the suicide bombers were a husband and wife team.
Año, a former military intelligence chief, said he sees no connection between the Jolo cathedral bombing and the Zamboanga City mosque bombing. 
What may be related, he said, is the Jolo blast and the deadly bombing in Lamitan City, Basilan on July 31, 2018.  
Lorenzana had said at the time that the blast also appeared to be a suicide attack. Año said what links the two attacks is the alleged involvement of a foreign ISIS member in the Basilan blast.
What kind of situation is it where the President is publicly revealing details of an investigation which contradict the statements of the AFP? Why wouldn't he just let the investigation run its course and from where and who is Duterte receiving information that contradicts the AFP? Why did the AFP suddenly decide Duterte was right and they were wrong? Too bad there was no CCTV to capture the whole attack.
https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/news/nation/683755/dilg-chief-ano-failure-to-install-cctvs-inside-outside-bombed-jolo-church-a-security-lapse/story/
The DILG chief also conceded that while he has announced that an Indonesian couple bombed the cathedral based on the accounts of his sources, this was not captured by CCTV videos owned by private businesses near the cathedral that authorities were able to secure. 
Still, Año was confident in his pronouncement that the suspects are connected with global terrorist group ISIS which is also known for beheading hostages.

Now we come to the part which is so reminiscent of Marawi. Prior knowledge and failed intelligence. First prior knowledge.
https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2019/01/29/1889151/lorenzana-was-aware-threat-churches-mindanao-palace
"Secretary Delfin Lorenzana was telling me, 'You know, the threat against the churches, we knew about that,'" Panelo said in a mix of English and Filipino. 
The problem was that the perpetrators pretended to be churchgoers, avoiding suspicion from government troops inspecting the area, according to Lorenzana.
This seems to be a general threat unlike the specific information which named Marawi as a target one month before the actual siege. The excuse that these bombers posed as churchgoers is not a good excuse. At every mall one must enter through metal detectors and have their bags searched. How much more so in the wake of threats against churches during a state of martial law?  Are we to believe that there is more security at malls than at a church which has received threats and is in a zone where martial law has been imposed? Of course not which is why those who attended mass at the now bombed out cathedral don't believe the government's claims about what happened.

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1080878/jolo-mayor-tan-fears-whitewash-in-probe-of-twin-blasts
He said investigators in Jolo were hampered by the state of the preservation of the crime scene. 
“Our field operatives are encountering some difficulty because so many people have come in and out of the cathedral and may have accidentally moved the physical evidence,”Guevarra  said.  
Residents as well as the families of the victims who either died or were wounded in the twin blasts refused to believe claims by President Rodrigo Duterte and other government officials that Indonesian suicide bombers may have carried out the attack. 
Instead, they wanted security forces to answer why the bomber was able to get inside the cordoned-off area and evade the tight security implemented around the cathedral as early as seven months ago. 
“The church [was] tightly secured, very secured. Troops [frisked and inspected the belongings of] every person trying to get into the premises, we are not that stupid to buy this (suicide bomber) theory,” said Eugene Non, a son of Fe Non, who died in the blast on the day he celebrated his birthday. 
Roadblocks and checkpoints manned by soldiers of the Army’s 35th Infantry Battalion were erected on five roads—General Arulas Street, Buyon Street, Travesia Road, Sanchez Road and Muralla Road—which lead to the two church structures
For six to seven months, the church had been highly secured, soldiers had kept people out and people were not allowed even to touch the cordon,” said Fr. Romeo Saniel, OMI, apostolic administrator of the Jolo vicariate. 
Tan said it was “a big question to all of us here” why a bomb got through. “No vehicle was allowed to pass in front of the cathedral. No vehicle, not even a motorbike, was allowed to park nearby,” he said. 
Arthur de los Reyes, whose wife Daisy also died in the blast, said even getting inside the cathedral was difficult. 
“Our bags, even our small items, were thoroughly inspected, so [we cannot accept] these recent reports that a man and woman were able to get inside with a backpack. How?” he said.
How? We may never know as the integrity of the crime scene has been comprised by being left unsecured and people being allowed to walk in and out not to mention the President's photo-op.


Why are Davao Mayor Sara Duterte and Senatorial candidate Bong Go visiting the bomb site? Why are any of those people there? Instead of shuffling around the debris looking solemn and somber and out of place they should let investigators do their work.

As for failed intelligence? Well ISIS claimed the Jolo bombing and now the government is confirming that claim as well as the likelihood that suicide bombers carried out the attack. But now they also wish to link this attack with the bombing in Basilan last July because ISIS also claimed to be behind that attack. The problem is they denied those claims then.
https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2018/08/02/1838931/afp-chief-isis-not-behind-basilan-blast
A few weeks later during a budget hearing the DND admitted ISIS was the nation's biggest threat but how serious did the DND actually take that threat if foreign terrorists affiliated with ISIS were able to conduct a suicide bombing operation in Jolo?

A lot of detritus has floated to the surface with this bombing such as the risk it poses to the BOL peace efforts and the MILF's responsibility to deal with extremism the grenade attack on a mosque in Zamboanga and an IED attack in Cotabato as well as Duterte's charge to the AFP to crush Abu Sayyaf and the resultant clashes but we will have to pass those issues by and take a look at the next event of importance which is the brazen killing of NDFP peace consultant Randy Malayao.

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1079622/murder-of-peace-consultant-outrages-ndfp
The NDFP is the umbrella group of communist-led organizations that has been representing the insurgents in the on and off peace negotiations with the government since 1986. 
“In view of the murder of NDFP consultant Randy Malayao, the NDFP and all revolutionary forces within its fold are now in the process of reconsidering its policy of being open to peace negotiations with the GRP (government) under the Duterte regime,” Sison said in a statement from Utrecht in the Netherlands.
This man was shot in he face while asleep on a bus! Who did it? Who would shoot a peace consultant for the commies in the face on a bus? The PNP thinks the armed wing of the CPP, the NPA, executed him over financial irregularities.

http://manilastandard.net/news/national/286927/-ndf-man-killed-over-fund-misuse-.html
Randy Felix Malayao III, the slain consultant of the  National Democratic Front, was sentenced by the revolutionary justice system or kangaroo court for increasing the sum of revolutionary taxes or permit to campaign  and  permit to win  from political aspirants in Region II, Region I and Cordillera Autonomous Region (CAR), police said. 
This development belied the claim of the CPP-NPA leadership who put the blame on President Duterte and the Armed Forces of the Philippines  for what they called ‘summary execution’ of leftist symphathizers like Malayao, police said. 
Malayao  doubled the amount of PTC and PTW to 100%, defying the Communist Party hierarchy, according to a statement from the  PNP Regional Office2. Malayao was accused of pocketing the money  for himself and to another ranking member of the CPP-NPA Agnes Mesina, whom Malayao eloped with lin March 2018, the PNP RO 2 said. 
Malayao had collected  P1 million  from congressional candidates, instead of   the   P500,000.00 as set by the CPP-NPA, police said. 
Police said that for provincial candidates instead of collecting P400,000.00,  Malayao charged  P800,000,00. For vice governor candidates, instead of collecting P80,000.00, Malayao asked for  P160,000.00 each. For City Mayor  aspirants,   Malayao imposed  P600,000.00 on each candidate. For vice mayoralty candidates,  he charged  P400,000.00.  
Malayao double the amount fixed by the  leadership of the CPP-NPA for his personal gains. Malayao’s PTC-PTW operations were felt by local politicians not only in Cagayan Valley but also in Region I and Cordilleras, police said.   
Investigation conducted by PNP PRO2 further divulged that Malayao was questioned by his party top brass on how he managed the party funds for the whole Cagayan Valley front especially in the “Lakbayan” activities in 2017. Malayao was said to have released meager amounts and had withheld the bigger sums  resulting in  the failure of the CPP-NPA to achieve the targeted number of participants.
A stunning claim indeed that politicians are paying the communists double the money for the privilege of campaigning! Will the PNP disclose the names of the politicians who paid those sums? The CPP-NPA is of course denying they killed their own man in the name of revolutionary justice. And who can trust either party? Who does one trust: the violent communists or the corrupt PNP? The PNP cant even trust their own men as several officers have been relived for mishandling evidence in this case.
According to Banac, evidence taken from the scene where NDFP peace consultant Randy Felix Malayao was killed were allegedly mishandled by investigators.
The PNP has already messed up this investigation!!

On to the third and last event which is the Supreme Court's oral arguments against the third extension of martial law. The government was given the chance to respond first so let's start with their arguments.
https://www.rappler.com/nation/222228-philippines-reiterates-isis-threat-sc-oral-arguments-mindanao-martial-law
The Philippine government reiterated on Tuesday, January 29, that Islamic State (ISIS) poses a significant threat to the country, and that the terror group is establishing a center in Mindanao. 
“There’s really a plan of the IS to establish their control in Southeast Asia, with the Philippines as its epicenter,” Solicitor General Jose Calida told the Supreme Court (SC) on Tuesday during the oral arguments on the 3rd extension of martial law in Mindanao. 
The statement came during the interpellation by the newest SC justice, Rosmari Carandang, who asked Calida to validate reports that ISIS wants to establish a center in Mindanao. 
“Some of the reasons why Mindanao was chosen to be the epicenter of ISIS is because about 23 factions – I’m referring to Moros – pledged allegiance to ISIS. Probably, also the geography of Mindanao – there are many [entry points], they can easily penetrate Mindanao through Sabah, Indonesia, etc,” Calida said. 
“This fight is not just about reducing them or eliminating them by military means. There is a total government approach to eliminate them, and fighting them in Mindanao requires this martial law so we can be able tor restrict the movement of armed groups from going from one place to another,” Año said.
Senior Associate Justice Antonio Carpio, a consistent dissenter in decisions to declare and extend martial law cases, kept his interpellation unusually brief. He asked whether there exists an actual state of rebellion in Marawi City or Davao City. 
Military deputy chief of staff for intelligence Major General Pablo Lorenzo said there’s no rebellion in Marawi. Calida was not confident of his answer for Davao City, which prompted Carpio to say: “You are defending martial law in all of Mindanao, but you're not sure whether there is Maute rebellion in Davao City?”
There is no defence of the state of rebellion in these arguments. In fact the military says there is NO REBELLION in Marawi or Davao while the original declaration is because of rebellion in Marawi. ISIS is seeking to establish a base in the Philippines. That is a fact and it's good to hear the government finally admit this but how does that constitute rebellion? The legal definition of rebellion is as follows:

"Article 134. Rebellion or insurrection – How committed. – "the crime of rebellion or insurrection is committed by rising and taking arms against the Government for the purpose of removing from the allegiance to said Government or its laws, the territory of the Republic of the Philippines or any part thereof, of any body of land, naval or other armed forces, or depriving the Chief Executive or the Legislature, wholly or partially, of any of their powers or prerogatives." 

https://lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra1990/ra_6968_1990.html

The imposition of martial law has specific parameters and wanting to eliminate terrorist groups is not one of those parameters. Unless we take the nebulous phrase "when the public safety requires it" to be the guiding light of this third declaration of martial law.  But the government's argument has always been that rebellion persists in Mindanao, not that public safety requires it.
https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2019/01/15/1885320/calida-insists-rebellion-exists-mindanao
Solicitor General Jose Calida insisted before the Supreme Court that President Rodrigo Duterte’s year-long extension of martial law in Mindanao has factual basis as rebellion still exists in the region. 
In his comment, Calida reiterated that “[t]he issue of whether such rebellion persists had been determined by the executive department and approved by the legislative department, two of the three co-equal branches of the government.”
A state of rebellion has been determined to exist because of the approval of the martial law extension. That is very circular reasoning that assumes there is a rebellion without actually proving it or defining how the actions of the various terrorist groups constitutes rebellion. The government says they will lift martial law only under certain conditions. Actually only under ONE condition.
AFP chief Lt. Gen. Benjamin Madrigal told the court during the oral arguments that the military defines “destruction of the enemy” when they have “reduced the enemy 30 percent.” 
The enemy’s capability is measured in terms of manpower, firearms, support system (such as controlled barangays) and violent incidents. 
Associate Justice Francis Jardeleza asked Madrigal what it means to the military when the enemy’s capability is reduced to 30 percent. 
Madrigal said that it meant that the capability was “brought down to level of law enforcement or the police can take the lead.” 
When the military attains that, Madrigal said, “we would gladly recommend the lifting of martial law.”
The AFP does not want to crush the so-called rebellion they want to reduce it to a manageable level and then hand the reigns over the PNP.  Let's hear from the opposition.

http://cnnphilippines.com/news/2019/01/30/kiko-pangilinan-martial-law-mindanao.html
Senator Francis "Kiko" Pangilinan said no proof has been presented to show that martial law in Mindanao has been effective, countering Malacañang's assertion that it played a hand in preventing more bombings in the southern Philippines.
This is the gist of their entire argument. Martial law is not working. Not that there is no rebellion thus rendering Proclamation 216 moot. No arguments dealing with the constitutional requirements for martial law. If the Supreme Court wishes to abide by the strict letter of the constitution then they will rule there is no rebellion in Marawi as per the original declaration and thus no reason for the third extension of martial law which is based on the contents of Proclamation 216. But this is not the argument the so-called opposition is presenting and the Supreme Court will almost certainly rule in favour of the government and next year this same charade will play out once more.

How do all these events connect and where is it all headed? Well martial law is certainly not working but not because martial is in itself ineffective but because the AFP and PNP are not taking full advantage of martial law. There should be more checkpoints and more searching and more liberties cast aside in favour of security. That is the nature of the beast like it or not.

Where is this all headed? More bloodshed. More bungling. More of the same. Already the investigation into the slaying of an NDFP peace consultant has been botched and the blast site in Jolo has been compromised. According to eyewitnesses and outside expert sources the government is making unwarranted and premature pronouncements about Indonesian suicide bombers carrying out the attack.
https://globalnation.inquirer.net/172903/doubts-raised-over-claims-indonesians-behind-jolo-bombings
Analysts have raised doubts over claims made by a senior Philippine government official that an Indonesian couple was behind the church bombings in the southern Philippines, citing a lack of evidence.  
Sidney Jones, director of the Jakarta-based Institute for Policy Analysis of Conflict (IPAC), said on Saturday that Manila was apparently still in the dark over the identity of the bombing perpetrators. 
“There’s no evidence! Different officials are saying different things — Malaysians, Yemenis, Indonesians. They actually have no clue,” told Jones told The Jakarta Post via text message on Saturday. 
Fitriani of the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) concurred with Sidney, saying that without evidence it was too early to conclude that Indonesians were involved in the bombings. 
Also on Saturday, Foreign Minister Retno LP Marsudi said she was still seeking confirmation regarding the identity of the bombing perpetrators.   
She said Jakarta had talked to the Philippine authorities and was told that the identity of the perpetrators had not yet been determined. 
“Based on information we gathered this morning, the perpetrators have yet to be confirmed because the investigation and identification process are still ongoing,” said Retno in a video statement recorded in Padang, West Sumatra.
Can the government be trusted to carry out an honest investigation of the facts? Maybe the AFP is running with the story Duterte told during his speech about a husband wife suicide team because they don't want to contradict him?

ISIS has claimed to be behind this attack and everyone seems to believe it but it's kind of too late to believe them now after underestimating them and ignoring them for so long. Anyone with a bit of sense could see that more ISIS attacks were coming. I will end with an observation I wrote last August and which still holds true today.
They should be forthright with the public and let them know that ISIS still has a footing in the country. With these kinds of denials and subsequent retractions which show an unwillingness to face reality it is certain more violence will come.
https://philippinefails.blogspot.com/2018/08/martial-law-6-pnp-vs-100-npa.html

Monday, February 4, 2019

Merry Christmas and Happy New Year from Al Espino Part 2: A Follow Up

Christmas has long gone yet the smiling faces of many politicians are still wishing us all Christmas and New Year Greetings from tarps they have failed to remove. Last year I posted an article about the many Christmas tarps Al Espino had posted around town. After the new year his campaign team did a relatively thorough job in exchanging the Christmas tarps for new tarps wishing everyone a Happy Bacolaodiat.

I say relatively thorough because a few of his Christmas tarps managed to escape their notice.


The fate of one tarp in particular caught my attention because it was strung up with five other tarps on a row of poles. For whatever reason his team missed this one and it lingered sadly in the wind hanging about like a weeping willow.


That picture was taken on January 11th. Three weeks later this tarp finally decided it had enough of life and rather than continue attempting to hang onto the pole it dropped to the ground and died.



A rather undignified way to go. This tarp, like many others, will have the unfortunately all too common fate of undergoing a sky burial which means the elements will beat its corpse relentlessly until it dissipates and dissolves and the wind blows its tiny fragments to the four corners of the earth. 

Or maybe one of the groundskeepers at the factory where this tarp used to hang will toss it into the garbage.